News
‘Marriage to an Arab is national treason’
Roee Nahmias
Published: 27.03.07, 19:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
95 Talkbacks for this article
61. Striking a balance
Ilan ,   Ariel   (03.28.07)
The opposite of itermixing is not hatred. Arab culture has it's good points and it less good points, no different than Jewish culture. But coexistence is not intermixing or intermarriage. Coexistence is working togehter and having equal opportunities; having Arab, women, hareidim, national religious, secular represented as equitably as possible in all spheres in our national life.
62. Not Racism To Dislike Enemies.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.28.07)
It's not racism to dislike your enemies. What possible reason do we have to like Arabs? Framing the question in that manner is just more politically correct BS. And saying that Arab culture is primitive & backwards is stating the obvious. What would you call tribal warfare, honour killings, cutting off heads & hands, polygamy, etc.??? The fact of the matter is that Arabs are rightfully perceived as a threat . Our negative feelings about Arabs are only a reflection & a reaction to their hatred against us.
63. #56 - Jews wouldn't allow it. Like what #47 said....
Larissa ,   Australia   (03.28.07)
apparently, yours is the only religion that will not accept an non-jew... while all other religions would be glad to adopt anyone.
64. I think you should all read this Ynet article
Larissa ,   Australia   (03.28.07)
Overview... about a Palestinian Christian married to a Jewish lady. http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3381947,00.html
65. RE:16
zionist forever   (03.28.07)
I believe when they talk about being scared of the arabic language its not the actual language the people are afraid of its the individuals speaking in arabic. Arabs are the ones who have been trying to destroy Israel from the start first through conventional wars now through terror so you see to arabs talking together in a language you dont understand it makes you think could these men be planning a terrorist attack and thats what they are discussing now.
66. Fascinatingly sad !
Hiram ,   Tel Aviv   (03.28.07)
It is absolutely fascinating to discover the inner thoughts of some Jews who have an extremely short memory and who indulge into the unsafe practice of slender and racist statements. In the black years, Nazi germany had set up the Jewish culture as a non-culture, the Jews as the plague and has started building a "1000 Years Reich" based on the same beliefs . Maintaining anykind of relationship - including love relationship" between a "pure "german and a "Jew"was forbidden by the Nuremberg laws. The fight that Israel must maintain is a fight against the Talibans, The Millahs, the terror organisations, the idots like Ismail,Zahar and such, not against the arab people as a whole. JUdaism , like Islam , can be the best and the worst at the same time. We should be careful ! Terrorist using religion as a weapon to oppress masses is not better that Right wing activists bringing up Judaism as a shield against the "arab threat " ...but it is certainly not worse ! There is ONLY ONE SOLUTION for the middle east : SECULARIZE !
67. to #41 Perhaps you are thinking of the invaders from
jason white ,   afula,israel   (03.28.07)
arabia? This is Jewish land! We were given it by HaShem! Read the Bible. Our deed is in there. We were here before the moslems invaded and we will send them back to wherever they came from.
68. #62 Terry: Of course it's racism
Flower ,   Europe   (03.28.07)
Youl call "them" enemies andt think you can get away with your racism. Remember the nazis? They called the jews rats - making it natural to hate the jews. Your path is on the same ugly road, same disgusting mechanism.
69. Jason #67: I do not like to talk religion.
(03.28.07)
Stick to verifiable history. These explanations are endorsed by Driver (Genesis,on Gen. x.). 6 See the relevant articles in Ency. Bib. and Cheyne's Genesis and Exodus. from about 4000 B.C. 1 a wave of Semitic migration poured out of Arabia, and flooded Babylonia certainly, and possibly, more or less, Syria and Palestine also. Also that between 2800 and 2600 B.C. a second wave from Arabia took the same course, covering not only Babylonia, but also Syria and Palestine and probably also Egypt (the Hyksos). It is soon after this that we meet with the great empire-builder and civilizer, Khammurabi (2267-2213), the first king of a united Babylonia. It is noteworthy that the first part of his name is identical with the name of the father of Canaan in Genesis (Ham or Kham), indicating his Arabian origin. 2 It was he, too, who restored the ancient supremacy of Babylonia over Syria and Palestine, and so prevented the Babylonizing of these countries from coming to an abrupt end
70. Pali 42- how about your sister/daughter marrying a Jew?
Tahl ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
71. ‘Marriage to an JEW is national treason’
Mr. equal ,   jerusalem   (03.28.07)
especially you are an Arab girl. Why is Y-Net not investigating Arab racism in the same manner? Do you not believe that every one is equal, man and woman, settler and Palestinian? Or do you also hold by cultural relativism, so that you do expect the same from an Arab as from a Jew.
72. Show me!
(03.28.07)
Show me one couple where the man is a Jew and the woman is a Muslim!!!! Hell, show me one where the man is a non-Muslim and the woman is muslim. Show me a Muslim - Jewish marriage where the children are brought up Jewish with Jewish names Point is their intermarriage is to 'breed' us out. That's why there is a religious prohibition on Muslim women marrying non Muslim men. It's NOT racism that has prompted these views in Israeli society, its security and war. Racism means we wouldn't marry Arabs/Muslims because we think we are racially superior to them. This is not the case, we don't marry because they have a dominating view concerning religion and hatred for our people and state. The leftists screaming racism first need to look the word up, then read about Israeli - Arab relations before commenting with their stupid comments
73. Racism
Jordi Gomis ,   Barcelona   (03.28.07)
I really see many people here asking this survey to be done in gaza, and so...comparing Israel to arab countries. It's funny, cos all of you who write this claim that arabs are inferior to you, but at the same time you compaye yourselves to them...I guess you have a problem. Another question: who's arab? are we speaking ethnically or based on religion? You say christian arabs, israeli arabs, etc... but at the same time, descendants of jews that came from iraq, libya, sirya, yemen, and so on are considered israeli jews and not jewish arabs, and ethnically, most of them would hve problems to say they are not arabs. All those who claim to be better than arabs, please show it...so far, you are at the same level, or even worst, as you all had access to an education, thing that most arabs didn't. Have all a nice day...ahava ve shalom le israel.
74. Incomplete survey - nonsense
Sarah ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
500 participants is hardly a representative percentage of the population. It also doesn't say from what areas the people were chosen. Overall, a stupid survey with no meaning whatsoever.
75. Marriage to an Arab is national treason
Sean Shalor ,   Coventry UK   (03.28.07)
Irrational or otherwise, that's not a surprising view. Here in the UK similar reactions (to Arab or Muslim) are common. This is not because of racism or anything like that. It is because the MAJORITY (polls support this) of Arabs and Muslims resident here, irrespective of their "nationality", cherish a desire to see all non(Arabs/Muslims) dead. It is difficult to deal equitably with such folk.
76. #68 Flower in Europe Somewhere.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.28.07)
They're not our enemies? Where have you been hiding your head? Have you missed some relatively recent events - like 3-4 wars, Jews expelled from Arab countries, anti-Semitism propagated by Arab media & Imams in mosques, suicide attacks on our civilians, daily Kassam rocket fire from Gaza, constant attacks on Israel by Arab members of our Knesset, demands for an end to Israel as a Jewish state by Israeli Arab political groups, non-stop condemnation of Israel at the UN (orchestrated by the Arab serial human rights abusers) - shall I go on? On the other hand, Jews in pre-War Europe were patriotic citizens of every country, contributed to the success of the societies they lived in, & never called for the destruction of European civilization - unlike your current Muslim immigrants in Europe. So, saying Arabs are our enemy is just a statment of fact, nothing to do with racism. Oh, and I forgot Iran's threats to wipe us off the map & denial of the Holocaust. Now that is what I call an enemy!
77. For Arabs, intermarriage is ok only if the man is Arab
Tahl ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
And the woman is Jewish. Not the other way around - a very chauvinistic society. Why don't you try and take this survey in Gaza or Ramallah? Ask Arab men, if they approve of an Arab woman marrying a Jewish man, without him converting to Islam. No way in hell they'd agree to this. If a Jewish man dares to touch an Arab woman, you'd see her brothers go ape, and kill the two, for "dishonoring the family". That's why Moslem-Man-Jewish-Woman marriages are common, whereas Jewish-Man-Moslem-Woman marriages are virtually nonexistant.
78. I don't hate Arabs - just anyone whose PLO-Hezbola supporter
Dudu ,   Kfar Sava   (03.28.07)
79. Racist Poll - what???
Keren ,   Hatzafon, Israel   (03.28.07)
I know hundreds of people in Israel and according to this poll half of them should hate Arabs - and it's just NOT SO. Under what rock the Geocartography find the respondents of this poll? It was obviously not random. What were the other answers on the multiple choice? Talk about beat up a story from nothing!!!
80. Why is something which has no connection with race racist?
daniel   (03.28.07)
I've never heard of an Arab race, have you? I did hear of a European politician who bellieved in a Jewish race. His name was Adolf Hitler. There is neither a Jewish race nor an Arab one. There are Arab Jews though. Iraki Jews, Yemanite Jews...they're not Arabs? Of course they are and they get married to Askenazim no problem. There is nothing racist in not wanting to marry a non-Jewish Arab. It may be discrimination, or selfpreservation. But not racism,
81. What about ARAB GENOCIDE RACISM?
Dan ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
The difference between Jews and Arabs generally is: The Arabs hate us Jews based on who we are, whereas we Jews dislike the Arabs because of what they represent: genocide racism towards the existence of a tiny Jewish state surrounded by 22 Arab dictatorships. What does YNET expect from us when according to a poll from the liberal Haifa university 76% of the Arabs in Israel consider Jewish nationhood to be "racism", 30% deny the Holocaust and 50% support Hezballah's terror against Israel? Enough is enough...
82. Well, my sister married an Irishman...
bobby ,   bobistan   (03.29.07)
Oh really ? No, O'Reilly.
83. I'm not surprised.
Michael ,   Oxford UK   (03.29.07)
Israel is generally known as the "Apartheid State" so this news can hardly be described as surprising.
84. #13 - waiting with baited breath
hawa ,   bangkok   (03.29.07)
it's amazing that you all think that non-muslims SHOULD have a problem with Islam. no wonder the world hates the US and britian for their racisim and thoughts of supremacy over all other races (how drole!). not just for it's idiot president that can't string 2 sentences together, let alone one coherent one without a script. or the prime minister that is just a puppy to the wagging dog. what you fail to realize is that Islam HAS entered into every house. it is the very thing that you all fear because it IS peace. and you fear it because it will become the dominant religion across the planet. It has been prophecized by the beloved Moses, Jesus, and all the prophets before and after them until the last most beloved prophet of Islam (may the peace and blessings of God be upon all of them). "The oppressed have become the oppressors". That saying is very true. beware of this. 'israel' occupied and now wants rid of the real occupants. these 'israelites' have not learnt anything... nor will they ever. stupid, stupid people. Oppression has its end, and then we'll see where this so-called "israel' is. they live in fear, because they ran from it. it must be a very horrible mental state to live like that... to watch over your shoulder every and all the time. oh well, what goes around comes around. i just wait for that day with baited breath! you can add that to your fears too. rest tight and don't let those bed bugs nip you in the a**!
85. why would a (sane)woman want to be beaten, abused and worse?
Jennifer ,   L.A, US   (03.29.07)
the 40% who said they wouldn't mind are completely crazy
86. racism
deborah ,   wichita, ks   (03.31.07)
there is no excuse for racism. none. and those who justify are not civilized, no matter how they loudly they claim they are.
87. SHAME
Nadia ,   Israel   (04.02.07)
i have to say that i'm ashamed to be israeli after reading this! these views that many of you here share is nothing but racism! have you ever been to the occupied territories and seen how IDf soldiers treat palestinians? have you ssen them beat up a 10 year old boy in front of you? i went to defend that boy and i took some beating as well and i was declared as a traitor!!! i'm sick of this racist society and will be happy to leave it forever!
88. 87 i hope u leave soon
haim ,   mtl canada   (06.17.07)
i be happy to help u go as far as u can u traitor i guess i am not the only tht would help u for free chalom
89. the conditions on the website state:
Observer ,   New York, NY   (09.12.07)
"Comments containing incitement, slander, racist slurs and inappropriate language deemed to violate our terms of use won't be published." Thats pretty much every ignorant comment posted on this site with the exception of a few.
90. Reason Trumps Passion
Paige Anderson ,   Phoenix, AZ   (03.26.08)
The reason why so much emphasis is placed on Israeli racial tension against Arabs is because MORE is expected of Israel having their own sovereign state, and therefore better living conditions, better policing and controls, and so they are then in a better position to provide a -tolerant atmosphere for ALL who are within their country. IF Palestinians had their OWN -stable- and -secure-, non-antagonistic state, the same would be expected of them. It is disappointing to learn that those so gifted as the nation of Israel are would be so cruel or to allow or to not crack down on racism against Palestinians or others. Im sure that they do their best, but more can be done and should be. A similar survey taken in Gaza would likely produce even greater intolerance. But again, who is in a better position to educate their citizens against racism of ANY kind? Israel is capable of MUCH better.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article