Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
‘Revoke citizenship of Arab MKs’    Aviram Zino
1. Yes
Let these fifth column enemies go and live where they truly desire: Lebanon, Syria and Yemen. Israel needs to shake itself off these backstabbing SOB's who are undermining the state from within. Come on, Israeli government, do something about them! Or did you only have problem with the late Rabbi Kahane, may G-d avenge his blood, 'cause he was a Jew and right?
Avraham   (03.28.07)
2. HEAR THIS, JEWISH LOBBY!!
DO YOU THINK ISRAEL WILL BE SAFE AFTER IRAQ FALLS TO THE ISLAMIST!! AS IRAQ GOES, SO GOES ISRAEL!! YOU HAVE DONE THIS TO YOURSELVES!!
(03.28.07)
3. Put them in Prison with the Hamas government
who are still enjoying life in an Israeli prison cell.
Israel   (03.28.07)
4. The Law is the Law
enzo ,   london,uk   (03.28.07)
5. Revoke citizenship, maybe but charges of treason, yes!
Consorting with the enemy during war time is treason and these Arab MK's who use their immunity to undermine the security of the country that feeds them MUST be held accountable. During the last war, besides visiting the enemy, they committed acts of sedition and were supported by ceratin members of Meretz. Freedom of speach is one thing but misreprenting the truth about Arab villages housing IDF weapons and telling CNN that the Arabs have not air raid shelters in Haifa is sedition and all the MK's involved must be charged. It is time that this ridiculous "immunity law" was repealed. No one is above the law!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (03.28.07)
6. Get rid of them! No other country would put up with this!
Yonatan ,   USA   (03.28.07)
7. Thank you Shurat HaDin!
Andras Bereny ,   Kfar Tapuah, Shomron   (03.28.07)
8. Racist hate and contempt
You have the nerve to make such outright statements such as this and the treason charge if a jew marries an arab!!??? We better watch out!!! The world is waking up and they will start to revolt against us (Israelis/jews) and it will be our own fault!!!! When will you fellow jews get over your ego and come to see we are causing our own pain!!??? You want ethnic cleansing, but if someone says something against a jew or Israeli they are being "anti-semetic" whaaa!! This will not be a world where you have your cake and eat it too!!! Please wake up from this nightmare!!! Please stop causing us such undying pain!!! Let's live in peace!! We are better then the states we consider our enemies. RIGHT?!
Elokim ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
9. #8 - Elokim
To Elokim, sorry, but haven't you noticed that the world has always revolted against us. Due to the restraint shown in the last Lebanon war so as not to kill too many civilians, we paid a heavy price and lost many soldiers, and the world still screamed that we were the "bad" ones. Get off your high horse, we are not going to commit suicide to make the world love us. Israel is a nation of people, mostly good, some bad, we are not better or worse than the rest. I am sick and tired of all this political correctness and hypocrisy. And its time these enemies of the State of Israel realized that there are consequences to their actions.
Gillian ,   Ashkelon   (03.28.07)
10. Finally, a voice OF THE PEOPLE!
Reality Check ,   BaGolan   (03.28.07)
11. 8 - i agree
i agree that it would be racist to let these MK's get away with breaking the law. arab MK's get away with doing things much worse than what regular jewish MK's get thrown into jail for. these racist practices musr end. everyone must abide by the law or suffer the consequences.
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.28.07)
12. They should go for other reason..
If the visit to syria harmed Israel's security, then the government has to provide evidence and if they are convicted they should go to jail. otherwise, empty accusations are pure incitment, A lot of jews travel to Marocco and Tunisia which are enemy states but we don't hear anyone complaining. On the other hand, I think these ppl should go home beause they failed their electorate, their visit to Syria did not advance peace nor advance the situation of Israeli arabs, on the contrary it gave the right winger more reasons to incite and spread hatred against Israeli-Arabs. For this sreason they should go home, I hope Israeli- arabs don't vote for them anymore.
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (03.28.07)
13. Arab MK;s
I could not agree more with Shurat Ha-Din. These MK's have called for the PA to "liberate Jerusalem", they have incited violence and everyone knowsexactly who they are workling for and what they are working for. Israel needs to be a democracy but being a "democracy" does not being committed suicdde or tolerating members of the Knesset who give aid and comfort to the most most vicious of enemies. In other states this would NEVER be tolerated.
Ephraim Rubinger ,   Miami, USA   (03.28.07)
14. Spineless, weak Israeli government
Olmert is projecting the image of weakness that will only encourage further Arab aggression. These Arab MKs should be deported.
Yakov ,   Ashkelon   (03.28.07)
15. they forgot a few
how about Achmad whats his name, Zibi or is it tibi? and Barakah? and the rest of the fifth column traitors we allow to spy on us in the knesset?
Mike ,   Jerusalem   (03.28.07)
16. The Question Is...
Why the hell has Israel put up with this treasonous behavior for so long? Now, the next in line to lose their citizenship should be those psychos from Naturei Karta.
NYC Girl   (03.28.07)
17. better late than never - they continually ignore the law !
redkmike ,   israel   (03.28.07)
18. #8 - you are obviously Peace Now or something as vile
the law was changed to prevent MKs going to enemy countries and since then they have gone twice. Do you think that they are outside of the law ? Of course not ! A Jew would have been serving time in jail now for doing the same thing.
redkmike ,   tel aviv and london   (03.28.07)
19. Respect yourself, #8
There are some laws that are good and some aren’t. The law which we are discussing here is the justified law in the eyes of the international community. If Israel will not stay on the principals of law then she will never survive. If Israelis will not respect their own laws they will never gain the respect of the others.
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.28.07)
20. Kick them out
They should be kick to Syria and not aloud them to return to Israel.
Francisco ,   Herzlyia   (03.28.07)
21. Hopefully -- this is the beginning of the end....
of the disgusting behavior of these MK's and others who are working actively to destroy the State. Kol Ha'Kavod (and a financial controbution from me) to Shurat Ha'Din.
AJ ,   Washington, DC   (03.28.07)
22. #12 Shalom again Rami.....
The main problem in Israel is NOT that Arab citizens want the same INDIVIDUAL rights as all citizens but the fact that the majority of the Israeli Arabs oppose the existence of Israel as a HEBREW NATION STATE. No minority in the world has the right to incite against the NATIONAL rights of the majority in the nation state and that includes the Arab minority in Israel. A recent poll from Haifa University shows that 76% of Israeli Arabs equate zionism or Jewish national rights with "racism", 50% support Hezballah's terror against Israel and 28% deny the Holocaust. These values will lead you nowhere in Israel but OUT of Israel....
Dan ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
23. to Dan # 19
I don't know how accurate your figuers are speacially about hizbullah, which is not even an sunni organization. However, It is only in the last 10 years that many Israeli-Arabs came to hold unfavorable views about is Israel, mainy after the events of 2000. They did not always hold these view and all this can change if the jewish leadership would stop marginalizing this sector and start treating them as Israelis lekol davar
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (03.28.07)
24. #8 is correct, and no Israeli should loose
their citizenship because they visited an enemy state. If such a visit threatened the security of Israel, a fine or imprisonment would be sufficient.
Richard ,   New York, USA   (03.28.07)
25. Dealing with representatives
B"H These representatives do not consider themselves citizens of the Jewish state, but rather representatives of an Arab state. It might be a good idea to restructure those who have no allegiance to the concept of a Jewish state to a different standing, perhaps Ambassadors of the Arab population. If you want to define what powers these Ambassadors have more carefully, that might help straighten the situation out where those who do not believe in the concept of Jewish state are somehow representatives of it to their constituents. Plus, it would lower expectations in terms of their visits to Arab states that they consider friendly to their cause of replacing the Jewish State with an Arab celephate based in Saudia Arabia, at Mecca, or perhaps in Tehran. It is a problem that needs to be definately be better dealt with, and it is a sensitive issue given the number of Arabs living inside Israel who are represented by these people who in many cases actually share their wishes and desires for a different government system.
Steve ,   USA   (03.28.07)
26. #8 Is correct and to the point
Those MKs are moderates and not extremists. MK Bishara is even a Christian. They do not whatsoever constitute a threat to the state of Israel. This racist Israeli attitude needs to stop or else as Elokim said the world will revolt against Israelis. Yesterday's survey results clearly show a terrible Israeli views towards their neighboring cultures and peoples. This is just as bad as anti jewish statements.
MK ,   USA   (03.28.07)
27. Throw them out
They broke the law, live with the sentence. If the arabs want to citizens then support the country. Arab-israeli should be part of the check point personnal. Use israeli soldiers as a secondary check. See how fast those arab-israeli run when the have to do something for the country.
E ,   Canada   (03.28.07)
28. #23 To Rami
First of all, the problem is NOT new, Israeli Arabs have for years been radicalized against Israel by extremist values from the Arab world. Rami, let me be absolutely clear: Nothing and I mean NOTHING justifies the Arab racist incitement against the existence of the Hebrew nation state of Israel. Inciting against Israel will hardly give the Israeli Arabs any benefits or anything in Israel.
Dan ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
29. Whether Arab or Jew, treason is not acceptable
Tracy W   (03.28.07)
30. To #25
Hey Steve, they don't want a different type of government, they want the destruction of Israel. Nothing less.
Joe ,   Israel   (03.28.07)
Next talkbacks 
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks