News
BBC denies reporter staged kidnapping
Roee Nahmias
Published: 09.04.07, 13:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Not news that he suffers from delusional thinking !
redkmike ,   tel aviv and london   (04.09.07)
Why the BBC wanted to ax him is of much greater interest ? If they had come to the conclusion that he was presenting biased stories which of course he was then this is a significant step forward. One can now feel sorry for him at hope that he will get needed treatment when he's returned to the UK.
2. clickfool - what's your take on this conspiracy?
CK Tan ,   Singapore   (04.09.07)
It must be manufactured by Israel, right? If true, your fave BBC boy likes his both of his palms greased.
3. This could be a cover up.
Boaz ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (04.09.07)
Or scapegoating the victim; because both hamas and fatah had failed to release him.
4. The Integrity Of BBC Reporters
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (04.09.07)
If true, it's just another good example of the integrity of BBC reporting on the Mid-East & in particular, Gaza. The BBC does not report news, it's just a propaganda outlet with no objectivity. The way things are going, Britain will soon be a third-world country along with the rest of Eurabia.
5. LOL! way to go BBC !
(04.09.07)
6. #3 do you work for the beeb, Guardian or Independent perhaps
redkmike ,   tel aviv and london   (04.09.07)
this scenario may mean that the Beeb (because of recent government pressure) had decided to fire this biased idiot which would be excellent news ! Why would you want to suggest alternative theories suggesting that he is a scapegoat ? Either way - good riddance to him (from the BBC) and Bishara - it's a wonderful end to Pessach !
7. That patriotic BBC
Tracy W   (04.09.07)
"The BBC has cancelled the commission for a 90-minute drama about Britain's youngest surviving Victoria Cross hero because it feared it would alienate members of the audience opposed to the war in Iraq. "Private Johnson Beharry's courage in rescuing an ambushed foot patrol then, in a second act, saving his vehicle's crew despite his own terrible injuries earned him a Victoria Cross. "For the BBC, however, his story is 'too positive' about the conflict in Iraq. "The film is now on hold and it will only make it to the screen if another broadcaster picks it up." (This story appeared on the Telegraph and Little Green Footballs.) http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/04/08/wiraq308.xml
8. #2 - don't encourage her nonsense please ! I'm begging !
redkmike ,   tel aviv and london   (04.09.07)
the sooner she is ignored the sooner the flood of dumb posts will stop. you want to bait bulls then please post on Madrid type blogs :-)
9. #4 - BBC and oymorons
redkmike ,   tel aviv and london   (04.09.07)
11. BBC integrity 10. Computer security 9. Political science 8. Tight slacks 7. Definite maybe 6. Pretty ugly 5. Twelve-ounce pound cake 4. Diet ice cream 3. Working vacation 2. Exact estimate 1. Microsoft Works
10. you didnt believe me when i told you this
rashid ,   palistinian   (04.09.07)
we never kidnap this crusaider, you always blame us for everything, i told you that i read our newspapers and they said that this crusaider want to join us and you didnt believe me i am happy
11. Please do not release him!!
Mark ,   USA   (04.09.07)
I hope the entire BBC goes to Gaza!
12. Yes! I called it!
David ,   San Francisco USA   (04.09.07)
From Day 1, I knew it was a hoax. No one kidnaps their best supporter. This makes my day!
13. BBC has got great reporters(not) but what is new?
linda   (04.09.07)
14. Will he split the $5 Million.Sure beats the £100K the Lady
Alan ,   SA   (04.09.07)
Sailor from UK got for 2 weeks eating Pistachios & Dates in Mullahland
15. CK Tan please dont call Clickfool here.Ellen's bad enuff.
Alan ,   SA   (04.09.07)
Leave him for Ha Aretz!! Please . Thank You .
16. What stands for......
Roscio ,   Rome, Italy   (04.09.07)
Blatantly Biased Crap. It certainly doesn't stand for truth, decency, or Western values. If the BBC propagandist is truly kidnapped, then I hope that he is released safe and sound just as soon as our IDF soldiers are released. If this is a sham, then let him stay with his barbaric cronies in the bowels of Gaza.
17. To redkmike and Alan - my apologies :-)
CK Tan ,   Singapore   (04.09.07)
I also had enough of his/her wild conspiracy theories n this couldn't help myself. Promise to behave better :-)
18. Now we have abbas, PA, and BBC operatives in Gaza
Shuki ,   Haifa   (04.09.07)
Fatah, BBC, and Hamas gangs operate in Gaza for some time. All 3 want EU money. We shall see who will get.
19. BBC integrity
Simon ,   London-GB   (04.09.07)
If the BBC had any integrity it would have published the Balen report. The report looked at the conduct of the BBC in reporting the ME conflict. One can only assume that if the conclusion of the report was that the BBC reporting was impartial then they would publish. Clearly that is not the case. The BBC could argue that they don't intentionaly appoint reporters with a anti Israel bias but what they do is appoint reporters with similar political prospectives. Under those circumstances you can never get impartiality. Finally older UK TV journalists have started to comment that todays reporters at the BBC spend far too much time putting forward there own views rather than report facts.
20. the smell of rot
Cameron ,   USA   (04.09.07)
Sorry to see the honesty & objectivity of the BBC slowly decline to this point. The BBC used to set the standard, but now has fallen by the wayside.
21. Dont U know?BBC isa de facto UK political party with mouth.
Alan ,   SA   (04.09.07)
piece that most Politicians would die for . BBC is seen in world as honest,British Fairplay Gentleman Medium that U can trust!!! Like a CONMAN the BBC cons everyone . They are fighting like hell to keep that report about them (??Balen) out of the public domain. Their TOGA ROSA Judges/Advocate Barristers are working like the Devil to keep it hidden.
22. Let him rot there...
(04.09.07)
BBC doesn't need this creep to pursue its agenda. Look at their headlines while the infighting continues in Gaza: LATEST NEWS Israel 'has Shalit exchange list' Palestinians discuss BBC reporter Israel fires missiles into Gaza US Democrat Pelosi in Syria talks Press hails US policy 'change' Israelis kill gunman in Gaza raid Fair and balanced my a....
23. good reporting by NZ Herald. BBC, learn...
(04.09.07)
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/feature/story.cfm?c_id=601&objectid=10433220
Back to article