News
Nasrallah: Arab peace plan is lifeline for Olmert
Roee Nahmias
Published: 11.05.07, 23:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. I like Israel and want to move there!
Lina ,   USA   (05.12.07)
I simply like Israel and feel ashamed of Lebanon, will you take me in?!
32. Lina, you will be greeted with open arms :-)
sarit   (05.12.07)
to be honest, soon there wont be any safer place in the world. it's simply god's land ;-) good luck lina!
33. to #10,13,20,25
HEZBOLLAH   (05.12.07)
#10 - thank you for that comment. you just gave a perfect example of the arrogance of you people. "Lebanese goats threatened by Hizballah anal terror may agree with this statement but not free people." im not even islamic. just to repeat what i said earlier, jews are known for being arrogant and abnocious. i will not say anything further, i dont want you to cry about it. #13 - lina, do you want me to send you all of the videos on the internet that shown isreali troops running away. there was an article on this sight saying the soldiers during the war had to go to a hospital for mental reasons, because of the fright hezbollah soldiers gave them. as for respect, i have already given mine on other articles about isreal, and so has hassan nasrallah in a previous speech, but ofcourse zionists wont do so, because as i said, they are abnocious and arrogant. #20 - what the hell are you saying? your whole talkback you were talking from your ass. you shouldnt be even talking about lies - look at the fools olmert and peretz. plenty of evidence there - but thats the isreali way right? to be a hypocrit, arrogant person who has no respect. another comment to back up my theory. #25 - your right. im serious, your comment is really true. but define what arabs you are talking about? but hezbollah are fighting for lebanons freedom from the US, not to take over the country. we are ruled by them because are countries are weak and all are divided. i must show my respect to isreal because everyone is united with each other. that is what makes isreal strong. some arabs are idiots, but only because america told them about the 'new middle east'. thats a load of bullshit, and i cant respect that.
34. HEZBOLLAH
(05.12.07)
basically you have it over old events, mistakes have been made and coorected as should be now, try to kidnap Israeli soldiers again and try to shoot rockets again you will find many nice surprizes
35. lebanon war
rj ,   england   (05.12.07)
nasrallah talsk from his backside...yes Israel did not do themselves any favours by going into lebanon too softly and should have included beruit in its bombing..but never the less looking at the stae lebanon is in structually and politically i cannot see how nasrallah can claim victory in any way shape or form...Israels only fault in a war they did not start was Israel was too compasionate and too merciful in their actions...Israel should learn to be more agaressive and not to pander to the idiot leftists and dogooders around the world...arabs beware Israel shall not make the same mistake twice by being too soft..
36. the punisher is back
SOUWEIDAN.M ,   lebanon   (05.12.07)
and he is more stonger than anytime mr nassrullah still exist becz of ur idiots leaders . He is the punisher becz all ur leaders are going home and he still exist ( from blair to bush to chirac to olmert to sanyura to arab leaders ) ur leaders are nothing just monkies cleverly disguised as human being .they should open a restaurant and start selling food and cleaning tables and taking order and deliver pizza not leading countries and armies haha
37. When Nasrallah begins to talk like Saddam Hussein
john ,   nz   (05.12.07)
He should know what the consequences would be.
38. HASSAN NASRULLAH IS RIGHT
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (05.12.07)
It may not appeal to many readers but looking at it closely,Nasrullah is right.
39. #18: ISRAELI DEFEATED FORCE
Noora ,   Bahrain   (05.12.07)
40. #39 - Right, just like the USA army was defeated by Saddam
Allahsaurus   (05.12.07)
in 1991. Claiming you won and winning are not the same thing...unless, of course, you're an arab. Seems like any war that lasts longer than 6 days is considered a victory by you...
41. #27 - what did Hezbullah win if Israel lost ?
redkmike ,   tel aviv and london   (05.12.07)
If one side is defeated then the other side won. What did Hezbullah win ? Sorry but no visible logic in your post. Please list the winner's gains. thanks - Mike
42. Funny...
Micha   (05.12.07)
how such supposedly mature people here resort to personal attacks. pathetic.
43. #27, how did you manage to pack so much error
Danny   (05.12.07)
into one post. 40,000? try less than 5,000. Unlimited support - seem to recollect the war was stop start due to international pressure, maybe you can recollect the "ceasefire" to allow medical aid to "civilians". "fieriest" fighting? Try the least lethal fighting Israel has ever had. 160 dead in a month, Palestinian suicide bombers did better than that before Defensive Shield. "Primitive" - Hizbollah had the latest equipment, Anti-tank missiles - crap against Merkevas, quite good against infantry - anti-ship missiles - sort of effective if the crew switches off all countermeasures and decides to have dinner rather than man watches. One has to wonder what would have to happen for Nasrallah to admit defeat - South Lebanon devasted, his image of Hizbollah "deterring" Israel devasted, his long-range rocket arsenal devasted, his bunker system in South Lebanon devasted, neglible causalties on the Israeli side and firing rockets clearing not stopping the war, the end of the war with 1000s of IDF in Southern Lebanon and Hizbollah retreating, Nasrallah whinning about other arabs not coming to his rescue and being stabbed in the back by Siniora, Hizbollah threatening anyone who doesn't publish their account only. Oh yes and not a single prisoner released. If that is "victory", then the arabs have come a long way since they were going to "liberate Palestine" and "throw jews into the sea".
44. To 43 it is time to think real
George Saliba ,   Canada   (05.12.07)
Israel throws 4 battalion to south Lebanon with the best Golany , so count your self. Israel has complete air domination in the sky .how many rides? Uncountable. US opposed all call for cease-fire from the entire world and tried to extend the war by all mean in the United Nation giving Israel week after week to complete mission. And I don’t want to argue with you just read Winograd report. My friend the time when Israel use to come to Lebanon for “promenade” is gone. Seat down and make peace before it is late and Islamist come to power in all surrounded Israel countries
45. To all Lebanese posters. Winning what?
Lebanese ,   Melbourne.   (05.12.07)
After all what we suffered in a long civil war we should have learned by now that there is no winners in wars. The victorious one is the one who can achieve more killing & destruction in the oponent. For Israel not winning the war does not make us winners. I can see that Nasrallah is trying to twist the truth to convince us that the war was inevitable & that having Israel prepared for the war four months prior to it ,is a proof that Israel was going to launch the war regardless if he kidnapped the soldiers or not. This assumption is not acceptable. Since it is very logical for any country to prepare itself and to put military plans to respond againt an expected attack from an enemy. I think it is time for the Lebanese people to stop supporting adventurer's like Nasrallah & to put them to trial for the killing & destruction they caused.
46. Don't confuse missing objectives with defeat
Igor ,   NYC USA   (05.12.07)
Don't confuse missing objectives with defeat. Did Israel achieve all of its objectives- no. Does that mean was it defeated? - NO!! Is Israel's ifrastructure in ruins, begging the world for funds, Prime Minister under seige from a militia, UN troops on its soil? -NO!! That's for the country that lost the war.
47. # 25 Nice, But it's not hard to belittle #3
# 3 is a ,   Joke   (05.12.07)
The person pressing the buttons for #3 appears to be living in a vacum. I'm suprised he didn't say Mickey Mouse taught him. LOL
48. #33 Hizbullah soldiers did not defend Lebanon
Lina ,   USA   (05.12.07)
You didn't deny Hizbullah soldiers ran away and abandoned their positions and weapons. You didn't deny many were taken prisoner or killed. Nasrallah carefully avoids mentioning his losses. Unlike Israeli soldiers who risked, and in some cases sacrificed their lives to save their comrades, Hizbullah fighters left their dead comrades behind. Israel provides psychological assistance to their soldiers becuase war is traumatic. Hisbullah fighters also experienced a trauma and surely the Lebanese civilians did but to admit the need for help is a weakness for Hizbullah. In Israel it's a necessary response where professionals are trained to provide this assistance. I see you have not answered the other posters who asked what you won? Was the death of 1200 Lebanese, the destruction of hundreds of homes, roads, infrastructure, bringing the trauma and destruction of war worth it? Is Nasrallah happy now that he destroyed Lebanon or was this actually one of the goals he hoped to achieve? #44 George, Israel is already surrounded by blood thirsty Islamists. It is very naive to expect Israel to make peace with people intent on their destruction.
49. The delusional George Saliba # 44
Doc Holliday ,   Detroit   (05.12.07)
As pointed out here by others you lost 1200 with about 600-700 Hesbo fighters. Front line elite fighters at that. All infrasturcture in the south destroyed. The southern border of Lebanon which had dug in terrorists from Hezbo have been replaced by the 10,000 man UN force. You lost the key position to attack Israel from. Hezbo showed the world that it hides behind women and children in war. That it believes in launching attacks from civilian positions in order to gain a PR photo-op. Hezbo will trade their kids ( or should I say someone else's child ) just get world sympathy. What cowards!! If crawling to th UN on your knees begging them to make Israel stop is a sign of victory, May you have many more. In a way I feel sorry for the delusional people who get their butt kicked and don't know it and come back for more. Please follow Nasrallah into hell, that is where he will lead you. Please look at post # 16 click on the link.
50. #44, maybe you should try actually reading the report?
Danny   (05.12.07)
You might discover one or two things once you get past the self-serving testimony of Peretz and Olmert.... For instance that it is the Golani BRIGADE not battalion and four battalions isn't 40,000 people - which would be virtually all of Israel's combat capability... Learn to read, learn to use your brain and learn to distinguish propaganda from fact.
51. #37, he isn't talking like Sadam
Danny   (05.12.07)
He is talking like Nasser in 1956. Remember he also "won" against the Brits and French as well as the Israelis and we all know how that ended.... I wonder how Nasrallah would spin Israel re-occupying South Lebanon?
52. Hezbollah won a large Victory
Hakim Kaeka ,   Shia S. Lebanon   (05.12.07)
Got the UN to protect the Muhajaden. South Lebanese destroyed Cities and Towns will be rebuilt with better bunkers and ambush sites. All within the civilian population, so more attacks = more negative propaganda for Israel. UN protecting Muhajaden resupplying missiles. HA HA HA HA HA HA Here is the funny part. The Muhajaden have launched thousands of un-guided missiles and rockets towards your cities, and your own press have told them where the rockets have hit. They know what launchpad, which weighted rocket with what warhead goes in what direction and how far. Tested new kinds of designs of solid fuel, and all of this means they have figured out a hell of alot. Not to mention shaving Merkava Armour like butter. Great Victory. And the Mujaden are still arming! Oh yeah, and your little "STRONG" soldiers were crying to sleep. So was your Northern towns. Allah Akbar Greatest Victory
53. #52, "shaving merkeva like butter"
Danny   (05.13.07)
Really, how many merkevas did you destroy in 33 days? Is it the same as the number of planes you "shot down"? Or the ships you "sank"? When Israel fought the Egyptians they nearly wiped out two divisions of tanks and shot down a third of the IAF. When Israel lost 2,500 soldiers in 3 weeks in 1973 lot more people were crying, did Egypt win with it's armies completely surrounded and cut off? Hell even the Palestinians managed more than a measley 160 dead and they didn't have unlimited Iranian funds, six years of training and the latest in Russian and Chinese weaponry and in Defensive shield they held off for two months, before running to mama UN to stop nasty Israel defending itself? If you were winning then why was Nasrallah whinning like a bitch about being stabbed in the back and demanding others come to his rescue. One last PS, we rebuilt by the end of last year. How long you going to have to wait for your home?
54. #52 Hakim, Allah Snakebar
Lina ,   USA   (05.13.07)
Thanks for exposing what Nasrallah and his Muhajaden are up to. Still using and abusing Lebanon. Now that Lebanon has been rebuilt, you're fully ready to initiate more destruction so you can play terrorist instead of getting a real job. Just bring more poverty and dispair to Lebanon. The Lebanese need to take back their country and kick blood suckers like you out. I understand Lebanon used to be a very beautiful country.
55. Israelis trying to get rid of Olmert arabs want to save him
zionist forever   (05.13.07)
Olmert is so desperate to save his own failed politcal career he is willing to sacrifice the interests of the country and accept the arab plan which is a plan for disaster. If Olmert had any respect for the people he would resign and hold fresh ellections not keep clutching politcal survival or simply giving Livni a coranation because she is even more pro arab plan than he is. First Halutz refused to go untill he was eventualy chased out, now neiether Peretz or Olmert are willing to resign non of them have any honour or respect for the public even though their approval rating is only 2% - 3% New ellections now lets get rid of this whole failed kadima/labour regime.
56. 52
zionist forever   (05.13.07)
Your right hizbollah did win this war not because of their superior millitary ability or tactics but because Israels tactics were all wrong. As for the merkavas out of over 100 sent into battle only 3-4 were totaly destroyed and some others were damaged but were back in action soon enough these included the older merkava 2 used in the original Lebanon war and non of the newest merkava 4 were were dmaged. In the scale of things I think that the merkavas held out pretty well The main reason that the others were destroyed or damaged is because of cut backs in the millitary budget the IDF did not invest in anti tank missle an defense system to keep the cost of the tanks down which could have stopped many of those missles Hopefully there wont be another Lebanon war and Israel and Lebanon can make peace Israel can be an ally to Lebanon against Syrian interfearence in Lebanon but if there is anothe war then Israel needs to make sure that there are better people running the show Halutz selling his investments on the eve of war, Peretz the idiot defense minister and Olmert the idiot PM who didnt know what he was doing it was a failing on all fronts by Israels leadershi and an army is only as good as the men running it. ALLAH AKBAR The next great victory will beling to Israel.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article