News
'Israel dissolution rally' planned for Washington
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 07.06.07, 16:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
1. and WHO is standing for Israel?
ilana   (06.07.07)
Where are the wealthy investers in the "new Jerusalem" (NYC)? The Jews do not believe in their right to Israel, so why should anyone else? History is repeating. Jews value wealth, goyim acceptance and assimilation above the honor of Torah or G-d. They get as they give. Anyone with their eyes open can see this.
2. Of course there should be a counter-demonstration
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (06.07.07)
This anti-semitic rally should not go unanswered! Hopefully, there will be thousands at the pro rally!
3. We Stand With You, Stand With US.
enzo ,   london,uk   (06.07.07)
I wish I could join the counter-demonstration with my banner "Israel, we stand with you". Thank you, Stand With US, for your work!
4. Better way
Choni Davidowitz   (06.07.07)
The best and most effective way to fight the anti-Israel rally is to make mass Aliyah to Eretz Yisrael. The longer Jews wait in exile the more virulent the anti-semitism wiil become. Foolish Jews; Open your eyes and see God"s message.
5. StandWithUs is amazing
Jon ,   Detroit, MI   (06.07.07)
StandWithUs is an amazing organization. The members are great people. They deserve our respect and appreciation. Forget giving money to Hillel or ADL. DOnate money to StandWithUs.
6. Typical biased coverage
Jeremiah ,   USA   (06.07.07)
The picture with the Nazi flags has nothing to do with the groups mentioned with the story. Typical smear job by Ynet.
7. We are also organizing a rally in Buffalo
Daphne, Standwithus ,   Buffalo, NY   (06.07.07)
If you know anyone in the Western NY area please have them contact our Buffalo chapter at dzilber@standwithus.com Thank you!
8. BETTER WAY
yosi ,   Montreal,Canada   (06.07.07)
to move to be under the whims of a anti-religios fascist goverment, which is only there to protect their personal intrests ,Its better for the jews to remain were they are ,defending Eretz Yisroel thru demonstrations & showing the world what proud jews are
9. Would go but...
Elianah ,   Los Angeles   (06.07.07)
I'd be at that counterprotest except for one thing: by then, I'll be living in Israel.
10. Israel Dissolution is Bush Road Map
Marcel ,   Florida   (06.07.07)
Why haven't they marched against the real threat to Israel ? Israel has always been outnumbered by the intolerant rabble,but Israel remains strong and vibrant. Israel plus God is an unbeatable majority.
11. RABIN AND ARAFAT NEEDED
Arik Silverman ,   Milwaukee USA   (06.07.07)
israel needs another Rabin and the Palestinians need another Arafat, which is to say, both sides need strong leaders who can guide the two peoples toward a peaceful solution. The present course is heading toward disaster. Israel's "inch-by-inch, bit-by-bit" method of attempting gradually to push the Palestinians out of the area isn't working, and is "inch-by-inch, bit-by-bit" building up opposition and even hatred toward Israel itself.
12. #11 Arik??? Again?
Robert   (06.07.07)
Your pro-Palestinian agenda says it all.
13. I noticed the US Communists will march against Israel
Robert   (06.07.07)
All three of them. But seriously, they shouldn't worry at all. Their comrades in Israel are doing a great job of turning Israel into a binational state. Only it wouldn't be the Communist, atheistic state they envision, but a fully Islamic one.
14. I support Israel and those who stand with Israel
jack bauer ,   usa   (06.07.07)
15. stand and support israel
David Powell ,   Everett,Wa 98201   (06.07.07)
I for one would love to join those in support for Israel against the anti-semetics who are demonstrating in Washington D.C. Unfortunately, I live in the other Washington about 3,000 miles away. I would like to mention about #8 who says president bush would be would seek the disolution of Israel. I cannot think of any other president prior or future who is a greater friend to Israel than President Bush.
16. ARIK must be kidding
gabriela ben ari   (06.07.07)
ANOTHER two master murderers in this world ?
17. AH peace, love and good ol' Antisemitism.
Israel   (06.07.07)
18. blinded by propaganda
RJ ,   Canada   (06.07.07)
I ask myself how can "nice" people be so blinded by propaganda. How can it be that so many "nice" people do not see the evil behind the occupation, the way Israel controls the lives of Palestinians, the Israeli-only roads, the checkpoints, the collective punishments? I stand with those United for Peace and Justice. I too say NO to the Israeli Occupation.
19. To number 18
Brian ,   Dallas, U.S.A.   (06.07.07)
I too ask myself how "Nice" people be so blinded by propaganda. When rockets fall on towns daily from the Gaza Strip, within weeks of the IDF Pull out. Israelis are constantly 'rewarded' for seeking peace with a people who won't even recognize them as a sovereign nation. 'Nice' is long left behind, and 'firm' is all that's left. Firm against suicide bombing. Firm against random killings. Firm against taking advantage of Israeli services (What other country brings wounded from those who swear to be their enemy for treatment in some of the best medical facilities in the world). Israel must remain firm until Palestinians produce evidence of friendship. And I stand with Israel and against anyone who speaks ill of Israel until that time.
20. Israel dissolution rally or God is a liar!
Heatherross ,   USA   (06.07.07)
God gave the land to the Jewish people. You don't know what your doing, going against God. In so doing, you condemn yourselves. Expect only trouble to come your way. I will bless those that bless Israel and curse those who curse Israel. I just don't want to be standing next to you. God forgive you. You better plead with God for mercy, before it is too late. You would have destruction come to our shores again, you are a shame to the USA, better put a millstone around your neck and jump in the deepest part of the sea than go against God, and He will still find you in the deep!
21. #18 RJ - and what else do you say No to?
Robert   (06.07.07)
How about the Palestinian oppression of women, the indoctrination of children, the corruption, the sectarian carnage between factions, the suicide bombers, the attacks on civilians in Sderot? Aren't you and your nice friends blinded to that?
22. Anti-Israel Rally
Mary Jones ,   Munster, USA   (06.07.07)
Woe to anyone who opposes Israel, God's chosen people and land. We are all special to God, but Jews are His chosen people. Jesus was Jewish.
23. Peace and Justice
David Powell ,   Everett, Wa USA   (06.07.07)
I disagree with R.J. in Canada #18. You say you stand for with those who are for "peace and justice" Those are not nice people who would like to destroy Israel and run the Jewish people into the sea.
24. # 19 # 20 open your eyes
jalal balad   (06.07.07)
they are defending themselves from occupation. plain and simple. the israelis rejected peace at the white house by not returning the palestinian holy capitol city of jerusalem. an undeniable right of every palestinian in the world. go back to europe now.
25. Perhaps a dissolve Hamas rally?
Steve ,   USA   (06.07.07)
B"H Or is the US really going to allow Iran get away with posessing nuclear weapons and exporting terror?
26. reality test!
RJ ,   Canada   (06.07.07)
Why should Palestinians trust Israel when Israel continues to build settlements and parts of the separation wall on Palestinian land? Has Israel shown good faith in bargaining for peace? I'd say NO! Palestinians are resisting a brutal and illegal occupation.
27. #16 gabriella
Doctor.J. ,   U.K.   (06.07.07)
Mass murderers?You mean like Hitler and Stalin?This is an interesting comparison,from a psychiatric point of view.Have you been diagnosed yet?Psychotic?Delusional?Psychopathalogical?At Be-Tipul?Lo.Tilchi Miyad.At Be-sakanat Chayim Le-Atzmech.
28. #26 is ignorant of history and facts on the ground
Darren ,   Tampa, FL USA   (06.07.07)
Simply blinded by the lies and propaganda of the Islamists.
29. Counter rally counterproductive
ABC ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.07.07)
Rothstein is dishonest. Numerous Israelis (including myself) think that StandWithUs is counterproductive. Rallies and racism (implying that all Palestinian children are terrorists is factually false. Most Palestinians want peace but are held hostage by official incitement and an unfree regime) do not help Israel and many Israelis have spoken out. Additionally, the Jewish community of DC sees this as counterproductive. From the JTA: The bulk of the Washington-area community will simply stay away, said Ron Halber, the executive director of the Jewish Community Council of Greater Washington. Those opposing the anti-occupation rally are allowing themselves to be defined by it, he suggested. "Who are they protesting against -- the other protesters?" Halber wondered. "We appreciate StandWithUs, and we agree with them 99 percent of the time, but when the media discusses the event we don’t want it to be about dueling protests. "People in the middle are not suddenly going to support Israel because they see a rally. You don’t promote Israel by attacking your attacker all the time."
30. No26
Nachman ,   Yerushalayim I"H   (06.07.07)
And where were you and your ilk when Jordan illegally occupied what they called the West Bank and Egypt illegally occupied Gaza. Where was the cry for a palestinian State then - of course there wasnt becasue until Nasser helped Arafat form the PLO no one even knew there were Plaastinians. A myth conccted by fertile anti-Semitic brains. There is no occupation - far better to live under Israeli rule than under the tyranny under which the peoples of Iran and Syria live. You just oppose the fact of a Jewish State like all anti-Semites so far as you are concerned only the Jews have no right to self-determination - be honest tell us what you believe don't hide behind the usual "I'm not against Jews only their State".Hypocrite!
Next talkbacks
Back to article