Jewish Scene
Most Israelis would accept a gay child
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 07.07.07, 08:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
156 Talkbacks for this article
31. Kyle
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.08.07)
Again your stupid comparison . Homosexuals have their relations with consenting adults . Pedophilia and rape are comitted AGAINST the will of , in this case , victim .
32. Whatever happened to "saving lives"?
sk ,   USA   (07.08.07)
Given that "reparative therapy" will not work, why haven't the Haredim figured out that accepting their gay teens will save lives and is therefore required? Oh I forgot: "saving lives" is only appropriate as part of a bribery scam like Oslo and the Disengagement.
33. #15 & 27
Connie ,   VA. USA   (07.08.07)
There is a Christian organization called "Exodus International", who deals with this very thing. You obviously love your son very much and want see to him change.That is the way God feels. He loves us but wants us to repent and come back to Him. Keep the lines of communication open so he feels he can come back to you. You are a great mom, not a failure. Hold on to your faith and God bless you.
34. how would i respond to what i despise?
yahn goodey   (07.08.07)
hopefully i would not execute him myself and end up in a prison full of more of them-but he definetly would be asked to leave and not return until if ever he smartend up.
35. To Mom of a gay child
Baruch ,   Boston, USA   (07.08.07)
Thanks. You are the only one who makes complete sense. One should love one's child pretty much no matter what the child does. That doesn't mean to approve of everything the child does. A drug addict child is one you love and want to help, as is a gay child. I wouldn't want to host in my house my drug addict child's addict friends for a shoot-up, nor would I want to host my gay child's friends for a GLBT get-together. Those who say that gays are born that way are just plain wrong. They may find that in their society they have a predeliction for GLBT relationships, but they aren't genetically gay. And what about people who are genetically male or female and the GLBT crowd thinks it's okay to physically "change" their gender. Why aren't they male or female if that's the way they were born? Pretty inconsistent, I think.
36. # 33 Thank you for those kind words. G-D bless you.
Mom of a gay child ,   Israel   (07.08.07)
37. Saving lives
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.08.07)
The proper treatment for depressed and suicidal people is MEDICATION and THERAPY, not encouraging them to engage in sexual activity that will make them even more depressed and suicidal. People who are depressed and suicidal but do not have homosexual tendencies and given MEDICATION and THERAPY, not encouraged to act out their destructive fantasies.
38. charles & logic
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.08.07)
I was responding to the claim that homosexuals must be "born that way" and "can't control their urges" because THAT IS THE ONLY REASON they would engage in an activity that is condemned by society. I replied that plenty of people engage in OTHER (not "SIMILAR") activities that are condemned by society but no one claims they are "born that way."
39. Why cast a pearl amongst swine?
Stephen ,   Lowell USA   (07.08.07)
They will only lie to your face.
40. Kyle
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.08.07)
Oyf en ganef brent dos hittel . You are always so anti , that in this case i'm certain that in your subconscient you made the connection . I hope you understand Yiddish . I've read [ google ] : research today is dedicated to find influences and processes wich determine a person's sexual preferences . Sexual preference is assumed to be determined by physical [ genes ] , psychological and social factors . You see , three factors are assumed to determine this behaviour . Now . i , as you i suppose , we are condemning pedophilia and rape . I do'nt agree with , what you call "perversions" , homosexuality . It's nothing for me [ women can be so beautyfull !!! ] but as long their relations are with consenting adults , there is nothing that i can oppose in Human sexual relations .
41. To @21 Charles
freejay ,   Israel   (07.09.07)
You took what i said wrong. I dont agree with what #3 said and have nothing against having a gay child, but this article is decieving. It is a feeble attempt from the left to demonise the haredim and religious by using a decieving heading. Thats why i said it was a stupid article. Im not religious but i see what this author is trying to do. Sorry if you misunderstood me.
42. Kyle proves my point ....blaming haredim...stupid article
freejay ,   Israel   (07.09.07)
43. Kyle and Charles
Baruch ,   Boston, USA   (07.09.07)
I'm a little confused as to who is making what point in your dialogue. First, just because consenting adults do something does not make it right. It may be that it is not something that can be made illegal, but it may be that it is not socially acceptable. Binge-drinking, as long as one doesn't drive or commit a crime is legal, but not socially acceptable, and one certainly would not start a binge-drinking PRIDE movement or have a parade. Still the drinkers may enjoy it together and be consenting adults (remember college days?). By the same token, their inability to control it may depress them as may the reaction of the greater society. If they are alcoholics, we don't accept that they are "born this way" and that it is okay. We, as a society, try to change their behavior, as difficult as the process may be sometimes. If it were your child who is binge-drinking, you'd still love him but surely would do all you can to normalize his destructive and anti-social behavior. Finally, as to why anyone would want to choose a lifestyle that provokes hostility? This is a rather common choice. The hostility of the greater society creates a very strong bond among those who feel oppressed and different and it can be very satistying. Gays are like that, as are motorcycle gangs, and even us Jews.
44. Isn't it cute how Baruch, the Boston yorid, overwrites?
sk ,   USA   (07.09.07)
Baruch, dearest, I had hoped that you had ascended by now. Maybe if we attached a few scuds to you we could send you back. Darn. You'd just land in the Atlantic ocean, I guess. That would be SUCH a crime.
45. Oh GOSH, people actually RECOMMEND #43?
sk ,   USA   (07.09.07)
I'm sure not. Baruch, stop voting for yourself.
46. Silly Cartoon Character (37) regarding Saving Lives
sk ,   USA   (07.09.07)
Huh? Kyle, you do need to edit your TBs before sending. Anyway, the proper "treatment" is to stop endangering fragile teenagers by calling them abominations and kicking them out of the house. Stop tormenting them & they won't need any meds.
47. #43 Binge-drinking Pride Parade
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.09.07)
It's called Mardi Gras. In Germany, it's called Oktoberfest.
48. #40 chuckie
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.09.07)
"Oyf en ganef brent dos hittel" "A stolen hat will burn your head." Well chuckie, I have never stolen any hats so I'll take your word for it. The rest of what you said makes no sense.
49. #44 "Baruch Dearest."?? so sk is a homo? I knew it!!!!!
(07.09.07)
50. #46 Silly Sammy Drama Queen Control Freak
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.09.07)
Coddling "fragile teenagers" by giving in to their every whim is not "treatment," you retard, it is enabling hostage-taking mentality. How many times have you threatened/attempted suicide in order to manipulate others into giving you what you want?
51. Kyle , ignorant
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.09.07)
Mardi Gras is not the same as Oktoberfest . The first one is Carnival , while the second is indeed an , mostly , indoor beer drinking happening . Again your GREAT IGNORANCE by saying they have the same goal , drinking . Well dear , you go beyond all permitted limits of stupidity and ignorance
52. Baruch
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.09.07)
I never said that being gay is OK . I say it again , if this are consenting adults , nobody can oppose this . Regarding binge drinking , they certainly cause troubles , and even if they do'nt drive , they are a danger on the streets . I have seen enough of them in the early sunday mornings hours . Gays endangered their life , Aids , yes , but now they know the danger and do what necessary to avoid it . While binge drinkers continue to endanger their lives , and that's why they are not accepted at all [ exept in the pubs ! ]
53. If mine said he/she became Haredi, I would cut off contact!
Jewish Citizen ,   Israel   (07.09.07)
54. Answer to #53
MOSHICO ,   Jerusalem   (07.09.07)
I would cut off contact with you if I was you daughter or Son. I hope your blessed with many Haredi grandchildren.
55. #8 - Izzy thinks cutting off your children is....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.09.07)
"taking a stand." Thank God most people don't choose that dispicable "stand."
56. #15 - I feel sorry for your gay child...
AJ ,   Washington DC   (07.09.07)
57. #27 - Are you kidding?
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.09.07)
"Explain to me if you can why the majority of queers drink till they get drunk, or take drugs?" My explanation: you don't know WTF you're talking about. The scores of gay people I know drink socially, if at all, and don't take drugs. I really feel sad for your gay child to have a mother such as you. Perhaps your gay child will stop bringing his friends to your house - or maybe just stop coming at all. Believe me, its who we are. Its not a "lifesyle" or a "choice." And given its who we are, we are going to live it to its fullest in strong, succesfull relationships and families.
58. #29 - Vyle
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.09.07)
The good news for you is that being an idiot is a choice and you can turn from that path any time you choose. Start by realizing most pedophiles and rapists aren't gay.
59. kyle southpark - most unusual "case"
ilan ,   rishon   (07.09.07)
it's most unusual when kyle speaks about israel and thinks he knows all when he's not from Israel and has no real connection. his thoughts are foreign and as such have no relevance. but i must wonder why he is so obsessed with posting all over any article having to do with homosexual this or gay that. he really does have an unhealthy obsession with homosexual subjects. rather disturbing.
60. To the pro gays
BUSH ,   USA   (07.09.07)
Is it not your choice to go to bed with someone gay? Drugs and alcohol is an addiction. Is it so hard to see when trying something gay you would get more attached to it. Just because you don't need to force the second party does that make it right? If one has an affair with a married lady that also must be okay if she agrees to it. How about sons and mothers or sisters and brothers? Will they try it once or will they get addicted to such a relationship? It is very nice that your tb's claim that gay is not a choice but stupidity is a choice. i have no care what scientists proved or could prove but scientists are not god they are humans like me and you that have their own ideologies and weakpoints. Only one gullible will believe everything he hears. Stupidity is not a choice. Some humans were born missing some oxygen in their brain which make them stupider. Every human has the choice to be gay or lesbian. You can do it and I can do it tomorrow. I choose not to just like I say no to drugs and I owe it all to my upbringing. My parents taught me the values of life. Regarding scientific facts look at the families of gays and you will see many were brought up with just mothers, lack of attention or were abused as children. Parents caused it and that is why more secular parents will approve of their child being gay than the religious.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article