News
Palestinian turns Israeli teen into sex slave
Yael Branovsky
Published: 17.08.07, 08:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
80 Talkbacks for this article
1. nothing but rubbish
Ali ,   Nablus   (08.17.07)
This story is not true and it can not be anything but rubbish .
2. The perfect backdrop for erotic fiction
Mike ,   Atlanta, USA   (08.17.07)
Love in the Time of Intifada
3. Who's the Victim Again ?
Hani ,   Palestine Vagabond   (08.17.07)
"... She agreed to sleep with the friend as a one-time gesture for her beloved boyfriend, but was forced to have sex with others as time went by. " A Sexual Predator and a natural whore. Just who is the victim here?
4. I have a real hard time buying this story
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (08.17.07)
You can't tell me this girl was completely innocent or blind to what was going on. My bet is she was a fully active participant until she tired of the relationship for some reason and then concocts a cover story to gain sympathy. I've heard these stories before.
5. Those who express such contempt for this girl
Kim   (08.17.07)
may have daughters and sisters.... What would you do to them if they made a mistake? I think I know the answer. No. People like you have no right to judge.
6. Shamful
Salah Sider ,   West Bank   (08.17.07)
I am sorry to hear this story. I consider this action as a serious crime and the person who was behind of this crime (the perpetrator) must be punished. I think that the young girl should be smart and aware that they well be subjected of mistreatment by stupid guys if they don’t use their mind before taking any decision. So please don’t give your trust easily to anyone and you should inform and consult your family about your activities, otherwise you will face many problem and risks during your life. Finally, I wish you all the best in your life With my respect and warm regards Salah
7. sex with an ennemi? she deserves what happened to her...
stephane ,   france   (08.17.07)
8. #3, Naive 18 year old israeli girl
Khalid ,   Lebanon   (08.17.07)
Ah to be young again....maybe I can con a naive 18 year old to fall in love with me and force her to service lebanon. I guess then she would be the victim. But wait, that means she is the victim in the palestinian territories too...oops....neber mind.
9. #3 Hani
NYC Girl   (08.17.07)
Never mind who is the predator and who is the whore. Whichever one is the Palestinian must therefore be the victim according to the prevailing wisdom, correct? The fact that this 18 year-old girl was naive enough to think she could make her life living with a Palestinian in Ramallah just shows you unsophisticated she is. Not only that, but where were her parents when all of this was going on? It doesn't sound as if this girl has had a lot of guidance, but let's put all the blame on her. After all, the predatory Palestinian boyfriend shouldn't be held responsible for his role in this sordid situation because Palestinians are never guilty of anything.
10. Love Thy enemy
edmundo ,   London UK   (08.17.07)
Such a sad story of exploitation, israeli girl sleepig with theenemy, and agrees to do favours for more enemies. maybe peace now will demonstrate agains publishing this story becasue it highlights some bad habits of thebelvoed palestiinians
11. @1 So-called "loverboys" are a well-known phenomenon
(08.17.07)
in the world; so also in Israel/PA.
12. We have our share of dummies ...
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (08.17.07)
Many of our young people are empty headed morons - the product of a failed educational system, lack of parental supervision, & the "modern" life-style. I see them every day - at the mall, on the beach-front, etc. with the extreme hair styles, the tatoos, piercing, etc. We have a large catagory of under-achievers - and in large measure, this is the fault of our lousy educational system.
13. taa daa
(08.17.07)
14. No victim, no predator
Thinkpad ,   london, uk   (08.17.07)
the writer is clearly fantasising. mental masturbation!
15. #1 - you obviously have inside info on this which is great !
redmiike ,   tel aviv   (08.17.07)
Please explain the facts? Mike
16. #11 - and "lovergirls" too !
redmiike ,   tel aviv and london   (08.17.07)
What is very common in Europe now and in Germany in particular is for young Muslim women to have affairs with non-muslim men and then threaten to leave them if they don't convert to Islam!
17. Truth be known....
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (08.17.07)
it all started out with somebody's only trying to get her to model burqas. Where's Rashid????
18. Serves her right
tFighterPilot   (08.17.07)
She should be thankful she wasn't killed for her stupidity.
19. sex slave
abed ,   jerusalem   (08.17.07)
israeli officail having sex qushind & might go to jail , palestinian official having sex get promotion. shame shame
20. 9 - you misunderstood 3. She did censure but then justified
'occupier' ,   Israel   (08.17.07)
She did concede that the Palestinian was a sexual predator. But don't worry. Based on Hani's logic in all of her talkbacks, once the 'occupation' ends (I believe that includes the 'occupation' of Tel Aviv too, according to her), then a Palestinian such as this will automatically turn into a big, morally-upright sweetie.
21. Sex indistry... no more no less
Mustafa   (08.17.07)
Sex indistry knows no borders. I lived in so many countries, and have not met a lover who is willing to have sex with a lover's friend ... bla bla bla ... Stop this BS, please. She must have come to Ramallah to do what she wanted to do, and what she actually did. For pay or other reasons, she left, and wants to become a hero. Not that this is an industry I support, as it only humiliates women, and brings 'humans' closer to animals, but in reality we all know this happens everywhere. Thisis similar to Israelis bringing their vehicles to PA areas, and selling these, and then going back to claim 'oh...car stolen by bloody enemy'. Even high ranking Israeli army officials were caught doing this.
22. Educating Our Naive Youth
mr ,   Israel   (08.17.07)
If this is for real, I suggest that parents take a more positive stand and interest in what their offspring are up to and into and deter them from entering into dangerous liasons.
23. Multiethnic
Raphael ,   Netanya   (08.17.07)
The new fashion among Israel bashers and Jew haters is to promote the "one state solution": this story is a good sample of what happens if you put together a postmodern society with prehistorical female thieves comforted by the sharia.
24. Item 12. Terry
Joel ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.17.07)
It may be impossible to get the full story, although its basic line seem credible. I think that Terry made a solid but painful observation. There is a problem with the mindlessness and lack of values in modern scoiety -- both religious and secular.
25. Is she an orphan. Where were her parents in all this?
LEE ,   NY, USA   (08.17.07)
Either she's mentally imbalanced, or her parents did such a poor job of raising a girl who could make such obviously poor decisions. Or maybe her parents are Peace Now activists. That would explain everything.
26. They can easily get virgins in Heaven
john ,   nz   (08.17.07)
Why do they need to capture one on planet Earth.
27. to most of you
popet   (08.17.07)
i have worked many years in a shelter for woman and ether your all very nieve or just stupid and have no idea how some of these woman have grown up i think its very privliaged to sit back in disgust when you dont no what your talking about i think you all should all give some spare time to an instetution and then judge.
28. Hey, at least they prefer girls now.
Barry ,   Tokyo   (08.17.07)
With Arafat, it used to be boys. Nice to know that our tax money is being put to good use in lavish Ramallah villas.
29. to #1, & 7
George Khoury ,   Beit Lahem, Palestin   (08.17.07)
To # 1: Why don't you believe it? I am an Arab like you and that is expected from Palestinian authority regardless of the religion of the girl... Do you think they would save their girls? PLO had been correpted since the 70s and the only reason it staed so long was because ot ehir respect to Arafat. PLO had been penetrated by Mosad and CIA for decades and their weapon was only used against each other. To #7: She is not sleeping with the enemy. In fact, PLO leaders are your best friends and popits... She is only paying a small price for big favors those corrupt PLO leaders aredoing for Israel. You should be happy for this bargain price. Once Peres said that he pays PLO in salaries more than Arafat used to pay them monthly.. It was true as they handed Lebanon to Israel and now they hand Palestine to Israel...just to become president of something unidentified called Palestine.
30. #12: So torah based education is needed..
abdullah ,   ashkenaz   (08.17.07)
b'cos you see the same thing in progressive non-jewish societies in germany, england, usa, in spite of their superior secular education systems. however, you don't see much of this in traditional jewish communities, in the galat - be it in the muslim or western galut. So what is lacking is torah-based education.
Next talkbacks
Back to article