News
Palestinians open to possible land swap
Associated Press
Published: 10.10.07, 23:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. About time
Reality Check ,   BaGolan   (10.11.07)
Give them the Arab Triangle in the Galillee. We can always use a respite from our internal 5th column terrorists who routinely call for PA rule. Then let's see them whine and scream when the reality check hits regarding the real version of Arabic 'democracy' and living under Sharia. They will start a new intifada BEGGING to return! It's a win-win for us
2. GOOOOOD
Benny ,   Here and there   (10.11.07)
Ariel, Maaleh Adumim, Gush Etzion, etc. for Wadi Ara, Taybeh, Umm el Fahem, etc. Who wants to start killing again? Not me.
3. "Palestinians complain about expanding settlements"
Sam ,   Canada   (10.11.07)
Palestinians continue firing missiles at Israel so why are they complaining about settlements? Palestinians should understand that if they don't give Israel peace and quiet those settlements will expand and expand and expand.
4. Land Swap w/Terrorists
Israelinmyheart ,   US   (10.11.07)
Since when do we negotiate with terrorist. Last time I checked the palis are still represented by Hamas and we are supposed to make any deals with them when they still have our soldiers? Making deals with these people...until they have a proper government why make deals that will just put us in danger?
5. What are they swapping? They don't HAVE any land.
Baruch ,   Boston, USA   (10.11.07)
6. give them the golan and screw syria!
(10.11.07)
7. Peac is in the Hands of Israel not the Palestinians
Nader ,   Ramallah   (10.11.07)
This is what Israel needs to do to acheive peace: - remove the 450 raodblocks accross the west bank. - Boost the economic cooperation between the PA areas and Israel - Ensure that there are real steps are taken by the Palestinians to build a stong security system. The only way to build a strong security system is by convincing the population that there is a real hope for peace. - Agreed to return the land occupied in 1967 to the Pals. - ensure that the PA leadership is a clean leadership to ensure the continuity of the security system and the economic development in the PA area. - increase the Peopl-to-People interaction to normalaize relationships between the two sides of the conflict. bottom line: THERE WILL BE NO PARTNER ON THE PALESTINIAN SIDE UNLESS YOU ISRAEL CREAT THIS PARTNER. and the way to creat a partner is by supporting the moderate leadership and make that leadrship convincing in the eyes of the normal people THUS undermining the RADICALS.
8. For one time, try the real peace
Saleem ,   Ramallah   (10.11.07)
Israel has never tried to go into a fair peace process with the Pals.. This is the scenario; Israel refuse to end it's occupation to the land occupied in 1967, then people keeps resisting occupation, Israel demands that Pals stop Intifad and the armed strugle for peace !! and we are going into endless loop.. Let us all stop looking into the past, NOW, you are occupying the west bank and Gaza... it's simple, get out from the land and let us make peace !! Always remember that you can always occupy the west bank and Gaza,,, it;s a piece of cake for Israel, so incase you dont get peace in return for the land, you are free to do whatever you want. BUT do not keep fooling us by peace when you are not ready to go into a true peace process.. Whatever you do, you will never vanish the people of Palestine, you have mo choice but for both of us to live in peace, and without you returning our land, there will be no peace ! You can tell us any storry you want, but I can tell you, no land as occupied in 1967, NO PEACE.. Your strong enough to say "NO, yes, you can say no because your have the upper hand now, but let us all remember that life changes, and let us take conclusions for the Lebanon war and what Hizbullah have done with you !! And by keep syaing NO, you are ONLY boosting the Radicals and weakening the moderates.. If that's your goal, then good luck with Hamas and Hizbuallah.
9. Who elected Abu Queraie to speak/negotiate for Palestinians?
d ,   usa   (10.11.07)
UN 194 (Partition of Palestine) must be implemented in its entirety and it is not for Querai and his corrupt regime to give up Palestinian lands.
10. #4: Since Always
emanon ,   USA   (10.11.07)
Actually, you are correct, Israel does not negotiate, they just cave in to the terrorists demands and get nothing in return . . . nothing but more terrorism I should say. Want proof? Look at Gaza. That is the precedent the terrorists are building on.
11. this bogus offer will probably impress olmert
dante ,   uk   (10.11.07)
the arabs should have thought of that before they made war on Israel. having done so repeatedly and savagely, they must pay the penalty. and, apart from that, Israel should not be forced to abandon its ancient patrimony. nonetheless, the Israeli government is in the hands of fools who cannot be counted upon to discharge their duties with intelligence, wisdom, or <> sense.
12. The Pali Leader are always open!
PLO Monitor ,   OPT   (10.11.07)
Unfortunately!
13. the obvious solution
(10.11.07)
give them big part of the negev. it's hardly usable by israel anyway, and you might even be "large" with them and give them more then they asked. they get the land, and god knows they love the desert.
14. i got a compromise for you...
illogical logic ,   jm   (10.11.07)
you agree to give me whatever i ask for... and i agree to take it. do we have a deal?
15. Land swap
eddie ,   london UK   (10.11.07)
the land given in such land swap would also be used to fire missiles at israel..
16. just get it over with....just go to the beach and jump in
jack bauer ,   ashamed of usa   (10.11.07)
i hear that drowning yourself is actually not as bad as it may seem. Rather then being driven into the sea just do it yourselves.....oh wait, you already are!
17. Land for Peace, because It Worked So well Before ;-(
David P. ,   Central Coast, USA   (10.11.07)
18. nader in Ram,llah
Yehu Ben Zohar ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.11.07)
when should we march into the sea, before the conference or after, I guess we have to give Olmert time to use his one way ticket to Paris. And are you really ready to live under the benevolent rule of Hamas? Gaza is such a great example of Hamas rule. Oh, wait, I forgot, its the Jews fault that Gaza is a shithole, right? With Hamas in charge the Jews all dead all of Hamas and Fatah will walk arm in arm in the new Islamic paradise, right? If only we nasty, selfish Jews would just drop dead, but give you everything first, the Arabs will be at peace with the world, Islam will stop murdering people in Indonesia, Thailand, the Phillipines and elsewhere, since you only kill them because of Israel right? The PA can't run a fruit stand without screwing it up, and you want a state, you must be smoking the same stuff that Olmert is smoking, If I were you, and I'm glad I'm not, I would ask for my money back, you bought some bad drugs dude.
19. To Mr. A. Qureia. Land Doesn't Belong To You - It Belongs To
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (10.11.07)
You say :"Israelis and Palestinians (Arabs) are slowly rebuilding trust, ..". THIS rebuilding of trust just got started in August 2007 -- after Fatah got forcibly kicked out from Gaza Strip by Hamas. Mr. Qureia, you SHOULD know that this trust rebuilding WILL take at least another 30 years from now -- during which time the Palestinian Arabs of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip should be re-educated, STARTING by removing the Jew-hatred and destroy-Israel wordings from the School Textbooks. ONLY after 30 years -- after having educated the NEW generation of Palestinian Arabs -- will we see whether the Palestinian Arabs have become Jew-lovers, or not. ONLY at that time -- when the new generation of Palestinian Arabs have become Jew-lovers -- will you get a state in the West Bank under one condition : that Jews should be ALLOWED to live all throughout the West Bank. BTW if Jews are not allowed to live all-over the West Bank -- you can NOT have a state in the West Bank. WHY NOT ? Because Judea and Samaria, nowadays known as the West Bank, belongs to the Jewish People -- given to them by Yahweh, the Supreme Lord, in 1320 B.Chr.. It belongs to them, it is NOT yours -- to start with !!!
20. Possible land swap, my foot
john ,   nyc   (10.11.07)
Well sort of, but, if, however, perhaps. When Israel proposed exchanging Arab populated areas in Israel for Jewish areas on the West Bank both the Arabs and good Israeli Left cry foul. Also, Abbas is still fully committed to the Right of Return. The more Israel bends the more the world demands. Now Ynet has an article from the EU justifying the Right of Return. Also Abbas includes all of the lands that were "No Man Land" along the Armisters line (Green Line). And, he insists on cutting Israel in half to have a land-link to Gaza. After all this cutting and chopping what will be left? Certainly not a viable Jewish State. Oh, sorry, wasn't that the hidden plan of the ultra-liberal left?
21. Swap Ariel for Ramat Aviv + TAU
Salomon S Mizrahi ,   Sao Carlos/SP/Brazil   (10.11.07)
So Arabs and jewish leftist could live happy side-by-side: Arabs: Adbahoo El-Yahood ! (Cut the throats of the Jews!) Leftist: Poor Arabs! We are so sorry! we sinned! We came from Europe and contributed for the nakba!
22. #8 You forget... Losers dont call the shots.
Evan ,   Milwaukee, Wisconsin   (10.11.07)
Call it occupied territory all you want, but being a sore loser because Israel won in '67.
23. The Pal shouldn't get land at all
Ido ,   Portland, USA   (10.11.07)
First of all Eretz Israel belongs to the jews when G-D gave it to them more thatn 3000 years ago. Originally it belonged the jews not the arabs. We should not give up any land no matter what!
24. #7 Nader
Korem ,   New York, USA   (10.11.07)
I agree with most of your proposals personally but why is it Israel's duty to ensure an efficient PA leadership? That's up to you guys not Israel. We don't ask you to purge corruption in the Knesset. Plus if Israel meddles in internal Palestinian politics it would probably draw protest, even if it's for a good cause.
25. #7
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (10.11.07)
You forgot to mention spoon feeding and a$$ wiping - diaper changing routine..
26. Um El Fahm, Palestine.....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (10.11.07)
and Ariel, Israel. Works for me.
27. And the PA and Hamas are already cozying up !
redmiike ,   tel aviv and london   (10.11.07)
Hamas says 'soon to give up control of Gaza!'. What is going on between the PA and Hamas is so transparent as to be laughable. Olmert, for all his failings is not stupid and needs to ask the PA to clarify its position vis a vis Hamas before the intended conference in Annapolis. Gaza is very nicely closed off and the final touches just need to be made - sealing it off from Israel completely. The whole conference is so silly anyway because the two sides are nowhere near agreement on even one thing that's up for discussion. And now we hear new 'demands' from the PA every day and Mazen can't guarantee even one thing.
28. Just make sure that the arabs go with the land
(10.11.07)
Make sure that you dont end up giving up the land and Israeli arabs simply move to haifa and tel aviv . knowing the skills of israeli negotiators, that outcome wouldn't surprise me in the least.
29. "the old Israeli-Palestinian frontier"
Reuven ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (10.11.07)
Since Palestine was never an independent state, the pre-1967 boundary was never an "Israeli-Palestinian frontier." It was the armistice line with Jordan. There is nothing to "give back" to the Palestinians, because they never controlled anything before.
30. THEIR IS NO ISRAEL
(10.11.07)
AS ALWAYS OVER THE HISTORY , THE JEWS NEVER HAVE A COUNTRY BELONGS TO THEM , WHY? BECAUSE THE JEWS ARE RELIGION FOLLOWERS . THEY HAVE NEVER BEEN A NATION. AND NEVER STAY IN ONE AREA. AND USUALLY THEY HIDE UNDER THE TAIL OF SUPER POWER , AND DOING ON THEIR BEHALF ALL THE DIRTY JOBS . NOT TO FORGET WHAT THEY DID TO THE POLISH FARMERS ON BEHALF OF THE LAND LORDS . THIS IS ONE EXAMPLE BUT IF YOU LOOK FOR MORE , YOU CAN READ THE WORKS OF WILLIAM SHAKESPEAR .
Next talkbacks
Back to article