News
Catholic leader rejects Israel's Jewish identity
News agencies
Published: 19.12.07, 17:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
128 Talkbacks for this article
1. Caths, like Muslims have MANY states.Jews have ONE
Alan ,   SA   (12.19.07)
Jews may not even have a country the size of New Jersey or Wales. For two thousand years they have been expelled and/or murdered in the lands of these other two religeons.
2. NUTZ to the Catholic Leader
Christy ,   Boston, US   (12.19.07)
The Catholic leader(s) should become more familiar with their Bible. Only someone NOT familiar with a Bible would make such a nutty statement!! This man doesn't speak for all Christians. Neither does the Catholic Church.
3. Well said,Alan #1
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (12.19.07)
Actually,they are burning to start another robbery.Burning! They can't stand with G'od's promisse being fulfilled and us Jews comming back to our Land after 2000 years.They are surprised and disgusted. I guess another attempt to hurt us will end up in their burning in the fire of evil they created.
5. Hypocrite Roman Catholic Palestinian with agenda
hypocrisy ,   usa   (12.19.07)
''This land cannot be exclusive for anyone..." Tell that to other countries too, like Saudi Arabia. Only Muslims are allowed to go to Mecca. Why don't you complain about that? Will the Catholic Church allow Jews to live in Vatican City?
6. Judaism is the only religion...
Mark Kleiman ,   Florida, USA   (12.19.07)
that practices freedom of religion. Everyone should visit the very Jewish State of Israel to see ALL religions there. Only a Jewish state would protect all religions :)
7. Israel not for Jews only?
Nora ,   Tel Aviv   (12.19.07)
Patriarch comes Patriarch goes, Israel stays as a Jewish State.
8. Go to the Vatican
(12.19.07)
9. Solution
Shmuel   (12.19.07)
I believe that Israel is only for Jews but since we are a democratic country we have to allow other nationalities and religions to live in Israel. Therefore I recommend that all other religions have to pay taxes and Jews live TAX FREE. With that we will feel better about these anti-Semites.
10. The Patriarch
Steve ,   Atlanta USA   (12.19.07)
should recall that between 1948 and 1967 Jews were not allowed to pray in Jerusalem, but Muslims and Christians did so. He should also remember that the Muslims in Gaza killed a Christian just a few months ago --for the crime of being a Christian. Israel exists as a Jewish state in part because Christians, and to a lesser degree, Muslims murdered and discriminated against Jews for 2,000 years. That behavior continues to this day, making a Jewish state essential for the survival of the Jewish people. When Muslims decide to truly recognize Israel as a Jewish state and stop shooting and inciting,there will be peace.
11. Jewish State and Democracy
A friend ,   Palestine   (12.19.07)
A state that claims to be a democracy cannot also be an ethnocracy/theocracy. Israel must compromise its Jewish character if it still wishes to be recognized as a democratic state. True, Jews should have Israel as an official state, but not at the expense of others i.e. Palestinian Muslims and Christians, Druze, Bahai, etc. The US may have a majority Christian population, but it has never called itself a Christian state. Perhaps Israel should begin comparing itself with better models of democracy rather than resorting to cheap comparisons to Muslim/Arab states with which it allies itself (e.g. Egypt, Jordan).
12. oh, it's only sabbah, arab militant in roman collar
dante ,   uk   (12.19.07)
from the headline, one could have thought that some respectable church official said the outrageous things quoted, but it turns out that it is only sabbah pretending, again, to be a holy man. he is a disreputable cretin who is an unabashed ally of the terrorists and who damages the image of the RCCh. the Israelis should demand that the Vatican withdraw him or appoint a replacement.
13. He'd never criticise Saudi, the Vatican, etc...
Laila ,   Manchester   (12.19.07)
But the Catholic Church has a long history of antisemitism. They're also the robbers who took many ancient Jewish aretefacts, which they still keep in the Vatican. They refused to allow Jewish families have their children returned after WW2, because the children were forcibly converted to Catholicism. They helped preside over the "trials" at the Spanish Inquisition, and many Catholic Bishops helped the Nazis round up Jews during WW2. Catholics have never been "Jew friendly".
14. This "patriarch"
charles ,   petach tikva   (12.19.07)
is first of all "palestinian" then catholic . Was'nt he who had transported arms for his fellow "brothers" ? So we don't need to be surprised . If you're not happy here , bye bye , leave us , we don't need you . Maybe you go to Gaza , there you will enjoy the "freedom" you need .
15. Sabbah the Dhimmi spoke
(12.19.07)
16. Was he talking about Saudi Arabia?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (12.19.07)
This hypocrite should be made persona non grata & recalled to the Vatican for another assignment, like in Saudi Arabia. I'm sure the tolerent Saudis will welcome him the way he deserves.
17. If our gov't. had any self-respect ...
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (12.19.07)
All gov't. officials should boycott the bishop until he is forced to leave. His denial of our rights should have consequences .... But, of course, this is wishful thinking - our gov't. obviously has no self-respect or they would have walked out of Annapolis due to the shabby treatment they received.
18. Call's for Dismissal/ Removal from Israel
Jim   (12.19.07)
19. Who cares? He has no authority over Israel.
Korem ,   New York, USA   (12.19.07)
20. clergiman
(12.19.07)
talk about little boys
21. He doesn't speak for all Christians!!
John ,   Jerusalem   (12.19.07)
This racist is not representative of all Christians. Please people, don't give him any attention. However, as a Christian living in Israel, I can say that not all religions are treated fairly. Citizens of many faiths in Israel pay taxes so that a branch of the Prime Minister's Office, the Conversion Authority, can actively convert people to Judaism. This is absolutely wrong, as is all public funds going to preface one religion over another. Israel can be a democratic state with a Jewish character and majority, but religion should be a personal choice and not a govt sponsored activity.
22. Latin Patriarch In Jerusalem
Major ,   Florida USA   (12.19.07)
Sabbah needs to address the milleniums old shortcomings of his own religion -- Catholicism -- and let the Jews take care of their own country, Israel! *sheesh!*
23. US a Christian Country?
Brenda ,   London, Canada   (12.19.07)
Would Jews like the US or Canada to call themselves Christian countries? Why copy Muslems? Please, no anti-Catholic venom (I'm not Catholic). Just makes hate.
24. #9 RIGHT!
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (12.19.07)
No more tax exemptions to churches in Israel.What a stupidity they have had this previlege up to now.Why should they,why?
25. #4
israeli ,   israel   (12.19.07)
No can do, Marwan, you would want that too. First you would come to us begging for work, then you would say we stole it from you. But you can, and you actually do, have the land of your dreams in Gazahstan.
26. I thought the Vatican
israeli ,   israel   (12.19.07)
in Rome was the Catholics' holy of holies. No matter which way you look at it, padre, Jesus was a Jew. Born a Jew, circumcised as a Jew, died a Jew. You are still bowing to a Jew, padre.
27. Interesting article... - Great response..
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (12.19.07)
This is the best response to the "unHoly" leaders of the world: http://www.kahane.org/meir/dear_world.htm
28. of course, because christianity's prophecy says: Exile
uli ,   jerusalem   (12.19.07)
29. Respond in kind
JD ,   Washington DC   (12.19.07)
Perhaps the Israeli ambassador to the Vatican should denounce the Pope's stubborn insistence on maintaining his Catholic identity.
30. Rome still plagues us...
Stephen ,   Minneapolis, USA   (12.19.07)
We should not be surprised by this. The Roman Empire, and its successor....the Vatican have a history of destroying the Jewish state. Let's not forget that Rome is the reason why there is even a contest over the land today. The Romans deported the Jews out of Eretz Yisrael into all reaches of the Empire, allowing others to move in and take over. Fast forward to the late 1800s to today, when our people come back...there are squatters in our homes. Now what? I think that the Roman patriarch in Jerusalem should ponder and reflect how many lives may be lost from his reckless, adventurist proclamations. He should also be advised to know that the Jewish state is the ONLY state in the region that is 100% tolerant of other religions and their faithful (much more so than even his state and religion is!)
Next talkbacks
Back to article