News
Arab MK accuses MDA of racism against Palestinians
Meital Yasur-Beit Or
Published: 09.01.08, 21:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. very deceiving article
amir ,   israel   (01.09.08)
The article is very deceiving. The directive specifically states (article 3) that the directive does not apply to Palestinians "treated on the ground". Only to those transferred from Palestinian hospitals. So there is no racism against Palestinians for being Palestinian. The directive is aimed at Palestinian hospitals. Hospitals are known to harbor resistant bacteria so the directive makes sence. Palestinians are being transferred to Israeli hospitals to receive medical treatment, yet somehow that proves that Israel is racist. Dr. Tibi should be ashamed of himself. Apparently the irony and absurdity of his claim is lost on him.
2. then why dont u go live in gaza?
Tal ,   IDF   (01.09.08)
u have a problem with our security and precautions? then get out! wake up, nobody trusts arabs anymore, one day they smile - the other day the blow themselves up! WAKE UP TIBI! WE'RE AT WAR AGAINST TERROR!
3. #1 Amir - send Tibi an e-mail!!
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (01.09.08)
Tell him this!! Matter of fact, I will do so!
4. these "Palistinains"
(01.09.08)
might try to kill the ambulance driver cause they are jewish
5. Why is MDA carrying palis?
jason white ,   afula,israel   (01.09.08)
The people who donate to MDA should know their money is used to help the enemies of Israel. We citizens of Israel should not have to foot the bill or have our hospitals filled up with the enemy. Finally tibi has no right to sit in the knesset. He never served in the I.D.F. No one Jew or arab who never served should sit in the knesset or any other position in the government.
6. Israel should not treat Palestinians
Mordechai   (01.09.08)
They are an independent people who want their own state. Therefore they should be treated by Palestinian ambulences going to Palestinian hospitals.
7. How wrong
paul malykont ,   United States   (01.09.08)
I am so disappointed by the hatred and racism shown by some of our fellow Jews. Self defense is required, but illness and injury are non-denominational.
8. He's right!
Yossi ,   Levittown, PA, US   (01.09.08)
Dr. Tibi is right about this. Hospitals for Palestinians are no more at risk than those for Israelis, or Americans, or any other people group. They are ALL a concern because of the antibiotic-resistant organisms (MRSA, VRE) and other nasty bugs (Klebsiella, proteus). MDA should routinely wear gloves and disinfect the ambulances after EVERY transport, no matter of whom.
9. Arab, anti-Jewish party
Andras Bereny ,   Kfar Tapuah, Samaria   (01.09.08)
1. Advising "paramedics to wear masks and protection suits when handling Palestinians from Gaza or the West Bank, and to disinfect the ambulance after each transfer" is not racism, it is higyne 2. Racism is working towards the destruction of the Jewish character of the only "Jewish" State 3. Racism is being involved with and getting elected in an ethnicly discriminating "party". How many Jewish members and/or candidates and/or MKs the united Arab list have? 4. What would Tibi say if there was a united Jewsh list? Wouldn't he cry out loud: Racism, Racism! 5. In fact Rav Kahane's party was deamed "racist" by the election commettee and prevented from running. Double standards? 6. Isn't it ironic that the country in which Arabs have more rights than anywhere else in the Arab world Tibi still want more and more? 7. I've heard of cases in which Jewish paramedics were prevented from volunteering for MDA because they would have refused to treat Arabs. How many Red Crescent volunteers were refused because they DO NOT ever treat Jews?
10. Hey Jason (#5) - what country do you live in?
JPS ,   Efrat   (01.10.08)
Last I heard, Tibi was an Israeli citizen and qualifies to be a member of Knesset. Same as all the Jews in the Knesset who have no military service. Go learn about democracy, and then read the laws of the land (yea, the land of Israel). If you don't like the laws that say any citizen can run for Knesset (ok, no nasty previous convictions allowed), then why not form your own fascist arab and jew hating party and make Israel a military state... you can change your name to something similar to Pervez Musharaf. Then you can close the newspapers you don't like and lock up all the opposition members too. And just to let you know, a recent traffic accident here in the Gush saw about a half dozen MDA ambulances and the local fire crew and IDF forces rush to help the victims of an Arab cab that rolled off the highway. None of us Jews out here complained at all. Just makes us better people for it.
11. This is common sense not racism.
Roni   (01.10.08)
12. Israel should not be treating Palestinians
Roni   (01.10.08)
they are given huge sums of money by european and American taxpayers. What are they using it for?? Hospitals? Cleaning the ones they've got? No. Let's wake up.
13. Arabs are not a race, this is not racism!
Antonio ,   Haifa   (01.10.08)
Enough with demagoguery and lies already! Arabs are our enemies, and MDA should not be treating them period. Let them treat themselves, and if they can't let them die.
14. MDA & Racisim
Yoni ,   Ireland   (01.10.08)
As a paramedic you clean the vehicle after every call out. the duty of every paramedic is to preserve life. MDA paramedics do this. please dont try to make an issue out of this,
15. #7 Paul - It is easy to be philosophical in USA
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (01.10.08)
Paul, When you are confronted with an enemy that seeks your destruction, sends suicide bombers, stabs, kidnaps, and shoots at friends and family, after enough casualties one loses his idealism and pursues the cold reality of survival. I would suggest that you come to Israel and spend some time in Sderot or other places to learn the situation on the ground and not in your ivory tower in USA.
16. This directive applies only to transfers
Roman ,   Lod   (01.10.08)
of patients from Palestinian hospitals. If there is a reason to suspect dangerous outbreaks (several such cases in recent history, coupled by overall low sanitary conditions in aforementioned Palestinian hospitals), then one should indeed take extra care and not risk contaminating more hospitals. This isn't "racism", Tibi, this is basic medical common sense! MDA can't go and check every single Palestinian hospital, so they have to make such sweeping directives.
17. MDA medics have to be careful of many things in regard to
Rivkah   (01.10.08)
Palestinians since they like to attack ambulances staffed by Jews because Pals refuse to live in peace.
18. #7
joseph ,   tel aviv   (01.10.08)
Paul, how many non-paying Mexicans do you transfer from Mexican hospitals to American ones? None. Zero. Who's the racist?
19. its a anti-bio security precautious messure
the noname ,   bandit   (01.10.08)
I dont think that they should even let any transfers go through. let them go through to egypt for their needs crybabies need 100% care 24/7 ?
Back to article