Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
Arab MKs: Israel committing crimes     Yonat Atlas
1. Tibi is not a traitor
A traitor is somebody who switches allegience! He never had allegience for Israel! He is part of a fifth column! He should - first of all - be ousted from the Knesset! Then charges should be brought against him! Good for those from the Right who were there!!
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (01.22.08)
2. the PA and the Saudis say that Hamas is to blame !
http://tiny.cc/hpv8s Mike
redmiike ,   TA - LA - London   (01.22.08)
3. tibi and all israeli arabs
get our of our beautiful country, now!
(01.22.08)
4. Out of the Knesset, out of the country.
If we don't get rid of our hostile enemy 5th column, we will end up like Lebanon.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (01.22.08)
5. Ha! What a laugh. Tibi calling others "warmongers' :-)
I always find these comments amusing. I mean , these turkeys wrote the book on "warmongering". They are the past-masters of deceit and double play. What a frustrating lot of scumbag riff-raff claiming high purpose while in reality sodomizing Israel's freedoms to pursue their ultimate 'go no where' goal of removing and killing Jews, not just from Israel - but anywhere. The "market" really is due for a "correction".
Scott   (01.22.08)
6. tibi should emigrate to gaza with his brothers
dovdevan ,   ashdod   (01.22.08)
7. for an upstart to come in and try to oust the old-timers
atilla karagözoğlu ,   Yeretz Ishmael   (01.22.08)
8. all world supports palestinians' cry secretly
No conscience can run away from the fact.
atilla karagözoğlu ,   Yeretz Ishmael   (01.22.08)
9. The enemy Of Palestinians
Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Fatah and Hezbollah have done many things for the Palestinians. They are fully responsible for : 1. Bringing the Israeli Army Into Gaza and the West Bank 2. Taking away all freedoms from Palestinians .3. Restricting Palestinian movements.4. Attacks by Israeli Air Force and Army 5. Israeli Checkpoints.6. Stopping Creation of A Paestinian State 7.Loss of jobs in Israel for Palestinians. 8. Stopping food and other needy things from getting to Palestinian people. The worst ENEMY of Palestinian people is = Hamas , Islamic Jihad, Fatah and Hezbollah.
Joseph David ,   Toledo, USA   (01.22.08)
10. thats right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Israel is committing crimes against they own people by not protecting them letting rockets fly all over the place and not doing nothing about it and giving in to terrorist and the nations which supports them.israel is not committing crimes against the arabs they are committing crimes against there own people.
Robert ,   farmington   (01.22.08)
11. DID THE ARABS PROTEST AGAINST HAMAS ROCKETS?
andy ,   orlando,u.s   (01.22.08)
12. Arab Israeli MK criminal hypocrisy
The media grossly downplays Qassam missiles menace which not only ruined the lives of thousands of Israeli civilians but also killed and maimed hundreds. It caused property damage in the millions of dollars and demanded creation of shelters in kindergarten and schools. About 10,000 Qassam missiles rained over Israel since 2001. It was hoped that disengagement from Gaza in 2005 will stop firing these missiles, but it did not. 2-3 Qassams were fired daily but the number increased and recently 40 such Qassams were fired in one day. There are three Qassam models: The older 1 and 2 have a steel sleeve which weighs 12 and 70 pounds while Qassam 3 weighs 198 pounds. All have a load of explosives 1.1, 13.2, and 22 pounds respectively. They need ignition systems, detonators and delivery systems. Production of 10,000 such missiles requires hundreds of tons of steel, explosives (mostly made of fertilizers) and accessories. In short, there is a need for a factory, a production line. Yes, there is also need for a lot of money to buy the steel, explosives to manufacture the Qassams. This factory must be a multi million operation. An industry. While Palestinians and others complain about human rights of the Gazans there is enough electricity for the missile factory and enough money to buy explosives. Moreover, Hamas tightly controls Gaza and firing of Qassam missiles is done by their orders. They use surrogates terrorist organizations to divide responsibility and shift the blame from Hamas to others. In the same time the Israeli nurseries in Gaza that brought 125 million dollars annually to the strip are destroyed. Israel should deny the Palestinians any supplies. Gazan can go to Hamas and demand Hamas terror to stop. As brutal as it sounds Israel has to stop the continuous punishment by Hamas terror. 50% of Israeli in Sderot have post traumatic syndromes, are maimed and killed. The other option is for IDF to attack Gaza. If the Palestinians think that this is a better option let them tell us. If Gazans can produce missiles why can't they use the fertilizers to reactivate the profitable nurseries?
I. Barr ,   Michigan, USA   (01.22.08)
13. #8 Attila - Anyone who condemns us for fighting the constan
#8 Attila - Anyone who condemns us for fighting the constant bombardment on our cities is a hipocrit. The PALis elected terrorist Hammas to represent them and they are getting exactly what they deserve. They should not get ANY electricity, water, or gas until the bombardment of our cities totally stops and Shalit is returned.
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (01.22.08)
14. #9
That's interesting. Were members of h Hamas driving the bulldozers that demolished houses and crushed Western protestors? Was a member of Islamic Jihad holding the gun that has killed hundreds of children, women, civilians and foreign journalists? Was it a Fatah member who blocked the free movement of students, pregnant women, the ill and the dying? Is it Hamas who are buidling a 500 km wall around the West bank. Was it Hizbollah who build illegal settlements on Palestinian land? Do Fatah patrol the hundreds of check points and patrol the apartheid / segregated roads that criss - cross the West bank? Do Islamic Jihad fly the planes that unleash missiles into populated areas? Or that deliberately set off sonic booms?
Invicta ,   Europa   (01.22.08)
15. JUST BOMB BOMB BOMB.
USE HOWITZERS AND MORTARS TO RETALIATE AGAINST CIVILIAN TARGETS. IT IS LEGITIMATE IN WAR! DONT GIVE UP BOMB, BOMB, BOMB!
nerio ,   boston   (01.22.08)
16. Chaya from Bat Yam is correct! Tibi is honest
He does not sing Ha Tikva! Let me know who translated this anthem into Arabic
z   (01.22.08)
17. to : # 13, Squalid Ibn Harman
you are not fighting. you are raping.
atilla karagözoğlu ,   Yeretz Ishmael   (01.22.08)
18. #8 - Atilla
And I thought you were an intelligent man! Boy, was I fooled!!
Chaya ,   Eretz Yisrael   (01.22.08)
19. lets examine the headlines
MK Tibi says MK Eitam is 'a vile murderer of civilians'. Eitam responds, 'Ahmad Tibi is a traitor.' MK Zahalka calls on Palestinian President Abbas to cease negotiations with Israel Eitam is right, Tibi is a liar Eitam hit the nail on the head. surprise!
jack bauer   (01.22.08)
20. #10
Robert: 'Israel is committing crimes against THEIR (not they) own people'. '..... over the place and not doing nothing about it . . . . . ' think about it and you may realise you make no sense or at least not the sense you intend. '...... crimes against THEIR (not there) own people . . . .
Jan 08   (01.22.08)
21. Loyalty Oaths
Once again I bring up the issue of demanding at least all those in the Knesset be given loyalty oaths to sign which state they are loyal to the Jewish State and if they don't sign these, they need to resign or removed as they do not represent any Israelis. Following that if need be, loyalty oaths should then be given to the population and those who refuse to sign should be given a few months to leave voluntarily before they are thrown out. Israel is at war and these are measures often taken in a time of war.
GZLives   (01.22.08)
22. HEY EVERYBODY< GUESS WHAT
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3497522,00.html Go see what I think . . . Especially Attila!!
Franco Frattini   (01.22.08)
23. #12
Israel's current war in the Occupied Territories is one of conquest, not defense. The West Bank and Gaza Strip, along with the eastern, Arab half of Jerusalem, were seized by Israel in the June 1967 war. It considers these lands to be part of "Eretz Israel" (Greater Israel). Since then, Israel has engaged in a policy of colonization, demolishing Palestinian olive groves, homes and towns and setting up strategic Jewish colonies. Israel then justifies its extension of its military control over the region, as well as its seizure of key water sources, as necessary security measures to defend its settlements. As one historian explains, Israel is the region’s most powerful state–not a besieged victim, but a colonial aggressor: The postwar tactics of the Israeli government in the occupied territories are characterized, in the contemporary euphemism, by the continuous "creation of facts." Among these facts are the expropriation of Arab land, the expulsion of the Arab population and the establishment of Jewish colonies. The overall strategy, again in the popular phrase, is "creeping annexation" of the occupied lands. This strategy is pursued by the dominant military and unique nuclear power in the region; it has been adopted neither from any overpowering force of circumstances nor from a compelling need for greater security. This much has been publicy conceded in Israel by ranking members of the military establishment who claim that at no time before, during or since the June war has Israel been in any danger of defeat.
Richard ,   London UK   (01.22.08)
24. to .14
Thank you for describing all the other things that were caused by Hamas , Islamic Jihad, Fatah and Hezbollah attacks on Israel. All those things would not happen to Palestinians if Israel was never attacked. The Palestinians know the terrorists cause all their problems. All ACTIONS by the ISRAELI ARMY WERE CAUSED BY TERRORISTS ATTACKS. Stop attacking Israel or suffer. Those who throw stones at soldiers should be shot on the spot. Israel is much too nice.
Joseph David ,   USA   (01.22.08)
25. Atlas (converted to Atilla) Liman the Greek
This is where you are hiding little Greek! Are you afraid that your neighbors will discover that you are secretly praying at home to baby Jesus and one virgin instead of 72?
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (01.22.08)
26. oy, kahana(zl) was so right!
one need not be aroght wing , or an arab basher to come to a simple conclusion-- the arabs in our midst and around us are here to annaielate us! and therefore we must rise first and kick them out of here!
oded   (01.22.08)
27. #17 - Atilla
With absurd statements like this that have no bearing on truth you are really showing that you are a total idiot! Aptalin birisin!
Yuksel ,   Montreal   (01.22.08)
28. #20
by Israeli governament not doing nothing about the rockets that they have to endure everyday they are committing crimes against the people of israel .thats the only crimes israel is committing as far as the arabs go they get what they deserve. no food ,no electric maybe when they starve to death they will get the point does this make sense!!!!!
robert ,   farmington,wv   (01.22.08)
29. Tabi is actually right!
If we put behind all what his friends and relatives are doing to us from across the boarder! I do not understand; why should we be concerned about what they are doing within their territory? Tabi is right; in democracy every one is free to do as they please. How can they help if stray rockets are landing in Sderot and Ashquelon? We are simply making a fuss over small matters. Allow him to go there, he will receive better salary there, for these few sentences he has ever uttered.
Daniel ,   Israel   (01.22.08)
30. Richard #23
How kind of you to bring up the 1967 war issue. Was it then that Nasser was boasting to drive all Jews into the sea? Well, what to do?, Israel defeated them and they have refused to make peace ever since. Because one cannot ask the victor to capitulate unconditionally (what did the British do when Hess the Nazi flew to England to offer peace? Put him in jail, because the Allies wanted Hitler, not Hess, and they wanted defeat or surrender, not a unilateral peace offer). It is quite the other way around: the party that was attacked and won can impose conditions. Someone smart said it in antiquity - vae victis! You want to go back to 1948? To Azzam Pasha's inflammatory dithyrambs? Ooops, lost again. When didn't they lose? Why can't they learn the lesson? By the way, I went to school in the 60's and 70's of last century. What I learned about Israel was that it was a desert. There was no flourishing Arab/ Palestinian culture (not even olive or almond trees) to document or write home about. And Palestine was the Land of the Jews, as in Jews, go to Palestine!
israeli ,   israel   (01.22.08)
Next talkbacks 
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks