Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
Iran: Israel too weak to confront us    Dudi Cohen
31. Niether Iran nor Israel will attack.
Both know attacking each other does not solve their problems. Iran knows attacking Israel will make it the target of military attacks by the US. Israel on the other hand has no wish to become a suicide bomber by attacking Iran. Israel has tried to cajole the US to attack Iran and has failed miserably. But one can never tell what the liar-in-chief in Washington will do.
Persian CAT   (01.28.08)
32. US can't attack Iran it's over the dirty work is for us
US is too weak to attack Iran bush has lost the iraki war and he is only in office for a year ! as usual the Europeans and the Us let us doing the dirty work and we will have to face Iran alone ! we have all the might to do it ! Iran could disappear if we use our nuclear arsenal so they should better think twice before threatening us !
dovdevan ,   ashdod , israel   (01.28.08)
33. Jan, what are you reading? Ku Klux Klan News?
Yonatan ,   USA   (01.28.08)
34. Think about it
Bush, Bolton, Iran, and almost all of the world wants Israel to be the first to move. The word says that all the world comes against her. I believe that it will happen. The world wants mount Zion. Don't give it up on their terms. Be strong, furbish the sword but use it in Righteousness. Prepare your little ones, and your homes, call on your God. It is He that will rescue.
stephen ,   ludlow usa   (01.28.08)
35. #30
Got no answer to that have you. Why? Because it's all true. Just check out the stats. Thousands of Palestinians killed at a ratio of 4:1 Palestinian children incarcerated. A 500 mile long wall built around a whole people. Gaza imprisoned and collectively punished. Apartheid roads? Yes plenty of them in the West Bank. makes Iran sound positively modern and civilised in comparison
Jan08   (01.28.08)
36. the big difference
Mottaki said that "If Israel's nuclear missile warheads could have helped, she would have won the (Second) Lebanon War." The same could be said about the Yom Kippur war! But here you see the difference. Iran would use the A-bomb if it was at hand! Israel is a responsible country and would only use it in case of existentual threat!!!
jacob ,   munich,Germany   (01.28.08)
37. Xerxes: 300 Spartans too weak to confront us
Oops!
Jake   (01.28.08)
38. #21
One thing is certain - more palestinians and lebanese have been killed at the hand of isreal than than the other way round or by their own. Can't dispute that.
Jan08 Ph.d   (01.28.08)
39. Lebanon failure? wtf
People keep going on about Israel's failure in Lebanon but you forget that this wasn't a war against a nation, against a real army, it was against pathetic cowardly hezbollah who hid in civillian houses. It wasn't a real war, it was basically one side firing rockets blindly into civilian areas while the other was painstakingly trying to pick out the millitants from their hidy holes within civilin areas. The whole world knows this apart from Iran. It would be a different story against Iran as the Iranian army would be separate from the civillians in their tanks and planes so would be a fairer fight.
Nick ,   London   (01.28.08)
40. #17, depending on which figures you believe
Between 25,000 to 500,000 civilians killed by Iranian backed Shia militia in Iraq. Also Iran executes it's own civilians on a regular basis. Palestinian "civilian" deaths are no more than 2000 over 7 and half years - Israels are around 800 - and the "civilians" in Lebanon would be between 300 to 600 once you strip out the Hizbollah "civilians" from the usually quoted figures. I assume you have a point?
Danny   (01.28.08)
41. #28, building up a strong head of outrage here
"Extra judicial killings" would that be killing people that no one but no one denies are "militants"? Are you advocating killing people who aren't "militants"? Or do you have difficulty understanding what a war is? "journalists" murdered? One guy who in the middle of the night in the middle of a curfew decides it would be a great idea to run up to a tank. Or maybe you are confusing us with the three journalists executed by Hizbollah in the last war for "spying". Or with the 50 odd foreigners that the Palestinians have killed in the last 7 years? "open prison", usually prisons don't have one large open door for people to enter and leave at will. Total number of people held in administrative detention in Israel is 838 - which by the way isn't "thousands", in case your grasp of elementary arithmetic is as good as your grasp of current affairs. Cluster bombs? The ones that 18 months later nobody can find? 3.5 million unexploded in Lebanon? Try 943 found which over 70% of Lebanon cleared. "Civilian houses bulldozed" what like the ones just outside Tel Aviv built illegally and bulldozed? Nope, guess not because they have Jews in the them and we can't muddy the waters of Jews evil Arabs good. "Missiles fired in to civilian areas" - why do I suspect you aren't talking about Hizbollah Katyushas(1 out of more than 4000 hits a military target) or Palestinian Qassams(2 out of more than 2,500 hits a military target). Gosh so many lies so little space - how did you manage it?
Danny   (01.28.08)
42. Delusional
What a pathetic bunch of chest thumpers they are. They believe their own propaganda.
malone ,   hfx   (01.28.08)
43. #35, maybe he should make them up like you
The Green Line is 300 miles long. If Israel built along it's border it would still be "hundreds of miles long". Gaza "imprisoned", you not reading that news are you - hundreds of thousands in and out of Egypt through a gapping hole. Apartheid roads? What roads are they? I know of roads for Israelis and I know of roads for Palestinians. Thousands of Palestinians killed - yep and the vast majority of them "militants". In fact the ratio of Israeli civilians killed is 70% and the ratio of Palestinian civilians killed is less than 40%. Note that Israeli civilians were killed miles from any fighting and were clearly civilians unlike most of the Palestinian "civilian deaths". As for child prisoners - tell me what country you are from and I will GUARANTEE you have juveniles incarcerated. For instance if you come from Israel, we have Israeli Jews who have been convicted of crimes whilst minors. makes you sound like you simply don't know what you are talking about.
Danny   (01.28.08)
44. #38, so what?
Danny   (01.28.08)
45. ahh, the iranian arrogance again!
we all remember the voice of cairo pre '67, c and during that blitz war , boasting that egyptians soldiers already swiminig in the sea of telaviv, with naked jewish girls.... and know all too well the REAL outcome... iran will have to be succumed one way or another......
oded   (01.28.08)
46. Amen Danny, callin #28 out for that crap
excellent
Jared ,   orlando   (01.28.08)
47. Iranian obsession with Israel
They think just cuz theyre 50 times larger and more populated and swimming in oil they can take on Israel.! Isn't that what Egypt said? And Syria...and Jordan....and Lebanon...and Iraq...
James ,   New York, USA   (01.28.08)
48. what a load of iranian BS
Last i checked hezbollah didnt win that war either, not getting utterly obliterated isnt victory you morons Are you that insecure and bereft of self-esteem, that anything anything such as not getting completely annihilated or blowing up a few israeli tanks is victory for you. You're pathetic. Second, the FM suggests the use of nukes in the lebanon war. Perhaps he is just ignorant, or maybe projecting irans own idea of proper nuke usage onto the israelis. Believe he has israels nuclear policy confused with the ambition of his own nutjob country
jared ,   orlando   (01.28.08)
49. Jan #38
If so, all that proves is that the Israelis are much better in defending themselves than the bulllies are in attacking. If that were not the case, Israel would have disappeared years ago. And take that Ph.D. off your name please, unless you have earned it, as I have.
Jason, Ph.D. ,   USA   (01.28.08)
50. the man is right
As long as this regime is running Israel the country will continue to be seen as the weak pathetic clown of the region rather than the respected power that its naighbors feared. If Israel has a strong man with a will to turn things round Israel can be a respected enemy and feared once again but unless somebody like that comes along then Israel is going to continue to be seen as weak and pathetic. Doesnt matter if its Olmert, Barak or Natanyahu they must have a will to change things and they must not be all words no action. They have to do as they say.
zionist forever   (01.28.08)
51. I really want "jan" to reply to #44 Danny. Come on "jan"...
If you can successfully counter his concise and well-written argument, your aggressive and insensitive talkbacks will look like less of a simple regurgitation from various leftist zines.
A ,   Jerusalem   (01.28.08)
52. Iranian FM
Maybe it's true and these nutjobs really believe what they're talking. Why is it they don't know the difference between believing and knowing?
Ahmad ,   LA, USA   (01.28.08)
53. Truth hurts!
But somebody has to deliver it to those living in the past too.
IRAN#1   (01.28.08)
54. amazing
I am noy jewish or Muslim I finbd it amazing that people will make threats from a safe distance or behind wepeons of their own, but when it comes to talking face to face they won't do it . either back up what you say or shut up Johnnie
Johnnie ,   KY U.S.A   (01.29.08)
55. turn the knob into an Off position
Ypip ,   Canada   (01.29.08)
56. to number 4
Why not criticize Iran for the violent threats that it has made? Israel did not threaten to erase any countries off the map...Hamas, Hezbulla and Iran ARE! Criticism is acceptable but double standard is NOT!
shakshuka   (01.29.08)
57. Iran Egypt relations
It is wonderful that Iran and Egypt might reestablish diplomatic relations. It makes no sense for two of the most important nations in that area to be opposed to each other. Both of these nations are seats of great empires in antiquity. They should be friends.
James Richardson ,   San Diego CA USA   (01.29.08)
58. Jan 08 speaks the truth. Bravo!
new_york_loner ,   Rochester NY   (01.29.08)
59. #58, er, no he doesn't
Danny   (01.29.08)
60. More Rooster Talk
It's like the little punk with the big friend backing him up! Iran thinks it can talk tough because it has Russia in it's back pocket! They forget the prophecy in God's word that declares Israel will defeat Russia and drive her back along with her middle eastern allies and Damascus will be a ruinous heap! Don't mess with Israel because her God is a protective God! Christ didn't die in vain! All scripture will be fullfilled!
Kerry ,   Canada   (01.30.08)
 Previous talkbacks
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks