News
Livni: I think of Temple Mount prayers during negotiations
Neta Sela
Published: 19.02.08, 13:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
31. Are there no MEN in Isreal?
James ,   Texas USA   (02.19.08)
Pacify, grovel, cowtow, lick their boots, and die anyway!. You will have war. You will be attacked. BE MEN OF G-D. Stand firm. Protect all of your homeland. Be revolultionary, change your Government. G-D iis with you.
32. Tzipi is a fine person
Tikva   (02.19.08)
Please leave Eitan and Sarah Livni out of this. They're both dead and can't defend themselves. In any case, they've done an excellent job raising Tzipi. She has more balls than any men in the government to tell Israelis that they must eat their medicine to get better, even though the medicine is bitter. Tzipi believes in Eretz Israel but it is not time yet to have it. Have a little faith in HaMoshiach, for G-d's sake.
33. Livni, what do you expect from paratroopers at Wailing Wall
observer   (02.19.08)
of course to shed tears, Not to shed blood! Your American friends said it before: If, however, the strict terms of the Balfour Statement are adhered to-favoring "the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine" With the best possible intentions, it may be doubted whether the Jews could possibly seem to either Christians or Moslems proper guardians of the holy places, or custodians of the Holy Land as a whole. The reason is this: the places which are most sacred to Christians-those having to do with Jesus-and which are also sacred to Moslems, are not only not sacred to Jews, but abhorrent to them. It is simply impossible, under those circumstances, for Moslems and Christians to feel satisfied to have these places in Jewish hands, or under the custody of Jews. http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/crane.html
34. To Abraham #4. GREAT Idea.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (02.19.08)
I like your idea of a Middle East Union like the EU where Israel can be one of the members. I would like to add that also the Kingdom of Jordan and Lebanon should be included in that Middle East Union. Great idea, Abraham. I think USA, EU and Russia should gently encourage them. The UN should NOT be involved -- the UN creates more problems then solutions.
35. livne
sas ,   israel   (02.19.08)
she gives the impression that she only thinks of herself/her job. otherwise she would have quit when she realized that ohlmert made a big mistake when she spoke about it on tv and radio.i have NO respect for this woman. she speaks against the PM and conitinues as his FM???????????? the 2 do not go together. she's a liar - fully over-rated and worth ZERO.
36. livne
sad ,   israel   (02.19.08)
she only thinks of her hair.
37. Israel needs a King, from the line of David
patriot ,   chicago, US   (02.19.08)
Surely there is a descendant of King David somewhere in the World. That is the proper order of succession. A King can so "No" and can prevent the 'splitting' of Israel. The Knesset is a 'joke'. And it is a Failure!!
38. Livini's nonsense
Edithann ,   USA   (02.20.08)
What nonsense..... Where were the Jews for 3000 years?..They were nowhere near Jerusalem..no Jews called, no Jews wrote, no Jews visited...and now they can't part with East Jerusalem? Oh, that's right..they said the word Jerusalem it in their prayers, while they were vacationing in the Catskills and on Miami on Beach... They couldn't take a cruise to Jerusalem in all that time? Can we say Pilgrimages?
39. # 30 baffled?
(02.20.08)
YOU ARE ONE IN A MILLION. And I mean that literally. Arabs hate Jews They are trained to hate Isreal and the Jewish people. They are also raised to hate Isreal from childhood. If you don't hate them then you must love them!
40. #30 Don't be baffled.
Jerry ,   Phuket Thailand   (02.20.08)
I don't believe that all Arabs hate us. But they are definitely not helping us with misguided sentiments such as you have expressed. The Palestinians already have a state - Jordan - to call home. All the Arab leaders who have cried out for the sake of the Palestinians - what have they ever done for them? Have they allowed them to settle in their own countries? Have they offered aid to help Palestinians become better educated to better be able to run their own lives? Who actually took the dignity away from the Palestinians? Admittedly, Israel had a hand in this, but the bigger culprit would be the leaders that the Palestinians have chosen to follow. The tide in the Middle East is not turning against Israel. It has always been against Israel. This is why the Jews have to unite and stop all this talk of division. This Livni is a threat to peace in Israel. Israelis need to remove her from her responsibilities. The same with Olmert and Barak and all the others who work toward Israel's destruction.
41. In the world of fantasyland
Brod ,   USA   (02.20.08)
Reading Livni's reasoning shows that she does not have the biblical and historical foundation to ground her to reality. Living and breathing in fantasyland is dangerous for Israel. This is exactly what Israel's enemies want to see Israel's government to wallow in. It also shows that she does not know the ultimate goal of Islamist-Jihadism. If she thinks giving in to the demands of the Antisemites and Islamist-Jihadists would result in heavenly peace for Israel, she must be living in fantasyland indeed.
42. Livni under Bush gun to reach Pal state before he is out.
(02.20.08)
43. To Maansingh
Abraham 34   (02.20.08)
Thanks. Starting with Lebanon and Jordan is a very good idea, Hopefully all countries will then follow the path of reason and common sense.
44. Holiest site for Jews is the rock under the dome. NOTTHEWALL
Adam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (02.20.08)
45. to14
huda ,   jerusalem   (02.20.08)
itisthereligousehistory of the city // sure it is right as islam is the last religion as it is not more than 1500 years // but here in jerusalem there were people who are not judism and i think judism for the jews as it is now it is for special people not for the all it is not like islam a religion to any whatever the father and the mother religion is ... iam moslem i think before islam i had no moslem grandfather it is the logic .. but iam araby i believe my very old grand father was araby and live here in jerusalem
46. To Edithann #38. Has Been Proven To Be WRONG.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (02.25.08)
You write :"Where were the Jews for 3000 years ?" IN 992 B.Chr. King David was living in Jerusalem ( he ruled Israel from 1000 B.Chr. till 967 B.Chr. from his capital Jerusalem). IN 957 B.Chr. King Solomon built the First Temple in Jerusalem (he ruled from Jerusalem from 967 B.Chr. till 927 B.Chr.). IN 33 AD Lord Jesus Christ was living in Jerusalem -- where he got killed in that same year by the Roman rulers of the Roman Empire. Don't you think King David was a Jew ? Don't you think King Solomon, the parents of Lord Jesus Christ were Jews ? SO, Edithann, at least 1000 years of your 3000 years has been proven to be WRONG. Edithann, don't you think you need to do some History study before speaking about history ?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article