Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
Author of Holocaust book admits it is not true    Associated Press
1. Mischa DeFonseca
Isn't this just what we needed when there are already enough anti-Semites who think the entire Holocaust was a hoax? Now watch the talkbacks and you'll see them come slithering out from under their rocks.
NYC Girl   (03.01.08)
2. # 1
Anti-semitists and other rasict fools would spread their lies even without such faked books.
Bielik ,   Poland   (03.01.08)
3. You vile woman, you wanted to make money.
You hideous person, you make me sick to my very soul.
(03.01.08)
4. Yet again
Yet another example of the holocaust industry gone mad. Don't think the world is going to keep falling for your extortion schemes.
John Bull Capistrano   (03.01.08)
5. Misha Defonseca
has some very serious issues and needs help. Fast. I jus find it very disturbing that someone would so something like that. She should be made to donate at least some of the proceeds to Yad Vashem and to programs that help survivors.
Avi   (03.01.08)
6. The author
Is a novelist. Since her novel has been translated to so many languages, I gather it's very good reading. Her only crime is that she pretended it was autobiographical.
tma   (03.02.08)
7. not much different from the late, unlamented, edward said.
dante ,   uk   (03.02.08)
8. which of which is untrue?
observer   (03.02.08)
9. to # 5 A vi
this is really bad that a goy can make mony from the holaucost ....is it your reall consern ???
Sabra   (03.02.08)
10. Of course, in a world where
we believe that a country sustaining a three-front war, unable to feed or clothe its own people would be involved in a massive extermination effort, we would also believe that an orphaned girl could be adopted by a pack of wolves and kill a German soldier. Brilliant, eh?
Zeal ,   Zionist America   (03.02.08)
11. many jewish refugees and patizans were protected
and living in the woods with wolves
(03.02.08)
12. #9 Sabra : It is one thing
for the author to put a disclaimer like "this is a collection of stories from survivors of their experiences..etc.etc." In that event, it would be coming from someone who really had in mind to bring the message of the Holocaust to readers. The author did not do that. What she did was to pretend that all these events that she made up actually happened to her, in all their gory detail. Something is not right with that. That she made money out of this is despicable, and I treat it as an insult to those who really did experience the events that happened under the Nazi's. I still think she should donate at least part of proceeds to Yad Vashem or to surviivor's for this insult she has committed.
Avi   (03.02.08)
13. zeal hates Jews and Israelis
but is such a coward that he/she does'nt dare to give his/her name and town . A nice sample of a bipede , a poor one
charles ,   petach tikva   (03.02.08)
14. Unfortunate headline
What is being admitted as untrue, the book or the holocaust? Now that Matan Vilnai is saying that shoah is just another word, is YNET joining the bandwagon and downgrading the holocaust word?
Chanalau, Tova ,   London, UK   (03.03.08)
15. Charles, I will never give my name or city
to a scoundrel like you. Your posts are so boringly hateful that I might as well correct them: incorrect: "but is such a coward that he/she does'nt dare to give his/her name and town . A nice sample of a bipede , a poor one." correct: "but is such a coward that he doesn't dare give his name and town. A nice sample of a bipede: a poor one." Learn from that you Zionist moron.
Zeal ,   Zionist America   (03.03.08)
16. Re.Edward Said
ya... he annoys you alot, right? a famous, educated Palestinian... all that you need to destroy your theories of superiority.. its so disgusting how racist you are.
Sam ,   Boston-USA   (03.03.08)
17. Regarding this Zeal , # 10 , Shoa denier too ?
in this tb he/she is denying the Shoa ? He/she , is a true antisemite , even if he/she told us he/she is a "semite" too . But his/her vocabulary only show his/her low level . A poor coward bipede , that's what he/she is
charles ,   petach tikva   (03.03.08)
18. Chalanau, Matan Vilnai said "Shoah", not "The Shoah"
Shoah means disaster. But as you know but deliberately try to obfuscate, Matan Vilnai (Deputy Defense Minister) spoke out of turn and made an off-the-cuff stupid blunder, he was not speaking about some kind of planned genocide.
Jake   (03.03.08)
19. Oh I'll bet she started out as a TB and went from there!
if it weren't so sad ,   it would be funny!   (03.03.08)
20. To NYC Girl #1. The Mistake Of Thinking.
You write :"Now watch the talkbacks ...". FROM the so-called Micha Defonseca we can learn that if a non-Jew claims to be a Jew -- dishonesty WILL take birth and thus dishonesty will prevail. So, NYC Girl, don't make the mistake of thinking that Jews are wrong. The non-Jew PRETENDING to be a Jew -- she/he is WRONG.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (03.03.08)
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks