News
IDF operation in Gaza ends, soldiers leaving Strip
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 03.03.08, 10:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. Victory
MormoninUtah ,   Salt Lake City, USA   (03.03.08)
Only the dumbest trash in the world would walk away from a 100-2 loss and call it a victory.
2. Olmert must go
Frank ,   Canada   (03.03.08)
Olmert is surrending once again. He must go. This guy is a pathethic liar who claims one day that no one can't prevent Israel from defending her citizens and who surrender a couple of hours later.
3. I agree 2# What a joke.
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (03.03.08)
Bush whines and Olmert sneezes.
4. THE UGLY OLMERT SURRENDERS AGAIN TO THE DEVIL AMERICA
(03.03.08)
5. Ring!Ring! -End of round 1
Daniel ,   Hasharon   (03.03.08)
6. Typical Israeli way
David ,   Rehovot   (03.03.08)
Here we go again never finishing a Job, Olmert spins again A iguana cant change color so quick like Olmert spins..... Do you think we are stupid Mr. Olmert?
7. T0#1 Victory
Raoul ,   Israel   (03.03.08)
Your reaction is really too dumb to relate to, but nevertheless I will give it a try. Do you not consider such a result positive, considering we are dealing with Hamas, arch terrorists. Or put it another way - are you for or against terrorism?
8. Here we go again, running with our tails between our legs!!!
(03.03.08)
9. Olmert Retreats.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.03.08)
Olmert stops the war because Ms Rice is coming - she's unhappy because her phoney peace process is falling to pieces just like every other policy she has initiated. Olmert doesn't want a Gaza invasion anyway - if we have to re-occupy Gaza, then obviously, the disengagement was a total failure. Land for peace doesn't work. If that's the case, why are we talking to Abbas? The peace process is shown to be a total fraud & Olmert & his peace buddies have based their political careers on this fraud. This is why we are leaving Gaza & I bet the military is burning mad.
10. SPEECHLESS!!!!!!!!
ROBERT ,   FARMINGTON   (03.03.08)
SPEECHLESS!!!!!!! MAY THE LORD FOREVER BLESS THE STATE OD ISRAEL.
11. The Best (temporary) Solution Is To
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (03.03.08)
Depopulate Gaza of the Arabs. But, even that won't solve our problems with the Arabs. They will just shoot at us from further and further away with bigger and more accurate missiles. In the end, only G-d can help us. And He will....
12. #1 they aren't going to ivite you to their "temple";
(03.03.08)
you have your own.
13. Olmert should get into his...
Ari ,   Jerusalem   (03.03.08)
pilot suit, ride in an F-16 land in a street in Gaza, show us the victory sign and declare "Mission is Accomplished"! Why do we keep in electing fools from the left and the right into PMO?
14. Returning "heroes"
Chanalau, Tova ,   London, UK   (03.03.08)
Scoresheet so far: Dozens of dead civilians including women and children, rockets still falling on Israel, widespread negative hasbara over Israel's 'shoah' on the Palestinians , lack of support in the US and Europe, and the leaders of Iran and Iraq getting together. Not exactly a success story.
15. I will state what many in golus are feeling..
Al   (03.03.08)
We fear for you Israel. I am truly afraid for the state and the Jews therein. More so I look to the Jews in Canada /USA and I am more afraid for you. You in Canada/America are uterly defencless. You have bought into the notion that your host country will defend you. Nothing is furthur from the truth. America will have a black moslem prez and Canada sadly is being flooded with arabs esp here in Quebec. The Jews in Canada/America are without arms.They do not have any arms nor do they even believe in the need to have them. Having said that I can say without question that the majority of Jews in the world today are in potentially mortal danger. We look to you Israel.Show the entire anti-semitic world you are fighters, that you are winners. The world respects a winner. Thats how it works.Otherwise we are all in terrible danger. I pray to G-d that common sense will previal and that you will be victorious. G-d bless you...
16. Hamas WON
M.M.   (03.03.08)
While ALMOST 10 Rockets were fired into Israel Monday morning, powerless Olmert leaves Gaza. Olmert, the weakling, is concerned about his position in the government and fears another Winograd report. OLMERT WOULD RATHER SEE SOME ISRAELIS DEAD than having to deal with the US, UN, EU, PeaceNow, Human Rights and other Leftists. WHAT A LEADER ISRAEL HAS MERITED!
17. Lebanon war mk 2 - mk 2.
Danny   (03.03.08)
Anyone seeing the similarities? Shall we already start seeking out judges to do the inquiry? Hamas has already claimed a - presumably divine - victory.
18. gaza
sas ,   israel   (03.03.08)
why did we send in soldiers if we already pull them out and the rockets keep on coming????? instead of leaving gaza we should leave this country.
19. ohlmert
sas ,   israel   (03.03.08)
number 13. he should resign and admit that he is not capable of being PM.
20. And again Israel lost the PR war.
(03.03.08)
21. gaza
michael g ,   israel   (03.03.08)
why should we stand by and let our cities get bombed by animals who have no value for human life.The left in this country is like the mixed multitudes of the past.Human civillian casualties is a part of war .Why should we show restraint to animals who dont want peace they want piece s of all of israel they want to annihilate us.What would america do to someone who is constantly bombing there city
22. The army should stage a coup
Olmert must go ,   Israel   (03.03.08)
Olmert and the rest of the idiots in the government must be uprooted immediately. There's no time to lose. The IDF must seize control.
23. What makes you think a withdrawl
Ypip ,   Canada   (03.03.08)
is some sort of scaling back of the operation? Be reasonable.
24. How you ALL listen to Hamas
Talula ,   Israel   (03.03.08)
They SEEM to think it's over, they are PRAYING that it’s over which is why they pathetically declared they 'won'. This statement can only be to calm down the Palestinians who were not lucky enough to escape to the West Bank for a better life. The rockets WILL stop, it will take time, but they will be stopped. Then, in my humble opinion, we should just keep firing rockets indiscriminately into Gaza everyday and let them stop us – turn the tables – give them a taste of what the folks down south have had to tolerate. I also think you are all a sad sorry bunch of misfits for not reading ALL news articles in Ynet. Instead you decided to listen to a bunch of hopeless terrorists declaring that it’s over. Shame on you all.
25. God bless our soldiers
Leonie ,   south   (03.03.08)
26. kol hakavod le tsahal
Yehud   (03.03.08)
am yisroel chai
27. Pulled Out of Gaza BECAUSE RICE IS COMING
M.M.   (03.03.08)
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/Flash.aspx/142589
28. #14 - Yeah, and you adding your weight...
(03.03.08)
....to that list of shameful political movements. Well done.
29. You cant win if you don't play the same game
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (03.03.08)
We are playing chess and they are playing checkers. The board may be the same but the game isn't. We are targeting the terrorists but they continue to: 1. Shoot missiles 2. Hide among cvilians 3. Stage casualties for the press 4. Claim the "David and Goliath" poor PAL speech THE ONLY ANSWER IS TO PLAY THE EXACT SAME GAME ON THE SAME BOARD. 1. Line up all the tanks and mortars 2. When they shoot we far back everything we have. Don't even stop to aim. Just shoot. 3. As long as they shoot, we shoot. HAMAS, the Arab world, and the entire world will understant the equation. THIS IS THE ONLY SOLUTION THAT WILL WORK
30. Adapted rules.
Jean Van Daem ,   Metula   (03.03.08)
As the main target of the terrorists are the civilian population our response to this kind of war should also be without compromising. First of all, the medias should be kept away from the battlefield until the army has finished its job. The civilians collaborating with the terrorists, the “human shields”, should be treated as soldiers without uniforms. We should not have humanistic considerations unless they will treat the kidnapped soldiers and their families in a human way as well. But lets proceed with order as explained at : http://israelagainstterror.blogspot.com/2008/01/stop-them-with-clear-cut-victory-part-i.html
Next talkbacks
Back to article