Jewish Scene
Jewish youth held and abused in Paris suburb
Reuters
Published: 05.03.08, 23:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. If That Slur Is Not Racial, What Is?
emanon ,   USA   (03.05.08)
2. For the memory of Ilan Alima :justice must be served
Rachel ,   usa   (03.05.08)
These criminals must be punished severely
3. Antisemitism and homophobia
Silvan ,   Paris, France   (03.05.08)
On his face was wrote "dirty jew" and "dirty fag". He was also tortured.
4. ....not ONE WORD on the ethnic makeup of the attackers..
Again ,   USofA   (03.05.08)
Gee, ya think they were maybe... Amish or something??? Me neither. Same MSM. "Do nothing and nothing will be done."-ancient neo-Taoist teaching. Time for Jews to DO something, instead of just reacting.
5. paris
sas ,   israel   (03.05.08)
you have an alernative but will only come here when it really gets bad. for me stay there and pay the price.
6. thanks Silvan,
er der   (03.05.08)
He's lucky he was even considered and 'acknowledged' (by the way the chief of staff does his reckoning) . . .
7. French Jews
Noam ,   Algentina   (03.05.08)
Why are they still even there? I know they grew up there, but it is no longer the France they knew. Leave. No necessarily to Israel, but anywhere else. You're in danger!
8. Anti-Semitism.
Jean Van Daem   (03.05.08)
Anti-Semitisn, the hate of Jews, is a phenomenon on which much has been said and written. Anti-Semitism doesn’t even need Jews in order to prosper (It existed in Japan although there were no Jews living in Japan). Anti-Semitism is one of the ugliest defect in human kind and it provokes the appearance of the most primitive and bestial instinct in human nature. Nowadays, it is carried, supported and promoted by Islam. If one wants to fight anti-Semitism one has to oppose the sermons and incitements preached in the Mosques against Jews. We have to fight anti-Semitism as explained at : http://israelagainstterror.blogspot.com/2008/01/anti-semitic-attacks-and-jihadists.html
9. My dear # 7 (Noam)
Arsen Lupin ,   Colorado, US.   (03.05.08)
French jewry is like every other jewry all around the world (that includes Israel!) : you have the poors jews and the rich. In France, especially in Paris, a lot of jews are wealthy and manage very good businesses, if not professionnals (surgeon, MD, lawyers, etc.). They're protected and antisemitism is not really a danger for them. As for the others, the poors and the workers living in the parisians ethnical suburbs, that's another story. But hey - we have the same thing in Israel, don't you? We'll discuss this point by the time a rocket will fall on the core of Tel Aviv.
10. If you write "dirt Jew" on a dudes face, you're anti-semiti
Eric ,   new York   (03.05.08)
especially if it was theft!
11. As long as they demand1 Euro -it is just theft, not Anti Sem
Alan ,   SA   (03.05.08)
12. #6 Yes, antisemitism and homophobia recognized
Silvan ,   Paris, France   (03.05.08)
A free translation of the official statement : 'The six youth has been put in jail for violence worsed(? agrave) for sexual orientation and for membership of a religion, for violence in meeting, torture and barbarian acts. And others. Less 1 hour official information...
13. "dirty jew" on his face and they wonder if it's antisemitism
stephane ,   france   (03.05.08)
of course it's antisemitism! it's not the first time a synaguogue or a jewish is attacked in france by black people or arabs; ant that the authorities lie by wondering if it is antisemitism or not ! we are in a country of hyppocrits and they are ashame to admitt that they brought thousands of barbarians in france so they deny evrything even if it's obvious. but don't worry that if an arab is just pushed by someone the authorities will immediately condemn, they will say that this is an " unbearable racism " ,they will lick the boots of the arabs, because they are afraid that if they don't act that way, arabs will burn thousands of cars...
14. Retard
A ,   Jerusalem   (03.05.08)
"Philippe Obadia, president of Bagneux's Jewish community, told Reuters: "It's incredible. We're all shocked." He said the reasons for the attack were unclear" Hey Phil, why don't you pull your head out of your ass and realize what's going on here....it's quite simple. ...North Africa Muslims are savages and they beat up this kid because he's a Jew. Instead of being all laze-faire and pretending that this is one big Jerry Lewis movie, you should unequivocally denounce the attackers as Arab thugs, the French gov't. as anti-semitic charlatans, and tell your community that it's high freaking time to pack up and come make the State of Israel their home. We need you, you need us. It's as simple as that. Let the French deal with their old colonial hound dogs without using us as pawns.
15. Reply to #8 re: Anti-Semitism
Giuseppe ,   Milano, Italy   (03.05.08)
http://www.inspiration.net/thinkitthru/ There is a video on Anti-Semitism by Dr. Michael Brown a Messianic Jewish Man. I find some of his findings and perspectives on Anti-Semitism to be quite thought provoking. Ciao, Giuseppe
16. #14 - Amen.
Nathan ,   Hoboken, NJ   (03.05.08)
17. Make Aliyah!
sarah   (03.05.08)
Yet another reason to MAKE ALIYAH NOW!
18. 14 - Another Amen from me!
(03.06.08)
19. Take Note Shas Supporters
Simon ,   TA Israel   (03.06.08)
As Silvan (posting # 2) pointed out on the victims face they wrote dirty jew and dirty fag. As in the hollocaust the ashes of 6,000000 jews and 500,000 gay people were mixed together, yet Shas continues its campaign to incite violence towards gay people. The Nazis wanted to elimainate any group they considered different. Here in Israel only last week it was reported that 2 teenagers in Rehovot were involved in a homophobic attack, the attackers were apparently inspired by Shas.
20. Got to be kidding!
lisa ,   Israel   (03.06.08)
Not sure if it was a racial incident?!!! Writing 'dirty Jew' on a Jewish teenager's face is actually questionable in this instance?! I think the act speaks for itself. That poor teen must felt extremely traumatized. If this is not an anti-semetic act of Hitlerism then I don't know what is! It should be treated as racial, anti-semitic....treat is like it is instead of hiding behind a wall of deceit.
21. #14 exactly
Yehud   (03.06.08)
22. Of course it's not antisemitic!
val   (03.06.08)
It's only hatred to Dirty Jews. The Clean Jews don't need to worry!
23. leave
debbie ,   nola   (03.07.08)
time for Jews in France to get the hell out and leave the ugliest country there is- it is filled with anti-semitism and not only from the Arab country it is now but by the French themselves who are as disgusting-I hope they self destruct in their hatred.
24. Sue the Frech authorities for "A Hate Crime"
petra ,   usa   (03.08.08)
Nothing like a law suit to help clear the air. SUE THE BASTARDS!
Back to article