Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
UK: Jewish school accused of racism     Modi Kreitman
31. 300 years ago it was the father's religion which counts
300 years ago because of the russian pogroms where jewish women were raped the rabbis changed the law so that the child's religion is recognized by the mother rather than the father, but b4 that it was the father's religion, read the bible.
israeli   (03.07.08)
32. i'm confused - explain this to me.
they are allowed to have jewish schools, but are not allowed to say who is a jew?? so if some goy says "i'm jewish", he's allowed to go too?? how then is it a jewish school?
david ,   new york   (03.07.08)
33. To # 28 , not your business
charles ,   petach tikva   (03.07.08)
34. And these arrogant judgements are coming from . . .
"Jewish rabbis" who, after two thousand years of exile, would rather be found dead in a ditch than make aliyah to Israel . . . . . H-m-m-m-m !?! And they have the brass balls to pass judgement on those who willingly took on the mantle of Judaism ????? Even Hitler wasn't that discriminatory. . . . !
Arieh ,   Carmiel   (03.08.08)
35. i agree with school
as far as i am concern you have to be BORN Jewish from a Jewish Mother...all these what i describe as PROXY JEWS who describe themselves as Jewish, perhaps in this case the father should have thought long and deep about the contraints he has put upon his children and other mixed marriages that put constaints on their children by having mixed marriages...they knew what they were doing when mqarrying so should accept the consiquences
rj ,   england   (03.08.08)
36. Decision Unfair, But Not Racism!
The decision by the Chief Rabbi was totally unfair, but in no way does it constitute racism. Judaism is a religion, not a biological distinction. The boy should be admitted, but let's tell it like it is, shall we?
Danny Maccabee ,   Portland, OR   (03.09.08)
37. Reply to #31 - Matrilineal Judaism in the Talmud
Where did you hear this myth?! The Talmud defines a Jew as a child of a Jewish woman (or a halachic convert). This is not some recent rabinic invention to deal with Polish rape victims...H"V.
Yaakov R ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.09.08)
38. Shame of these Small minded people
There needs to be a change . What is the reason ? Proof that the mother passes Jewish DNA? ..to be part of the tribe ?...In modern society you can now prove that the children of a man is his ,through DNA testing , so let's modernize a bit .
rachel ,   usa   (03.09.08)
39. Re #28
Rivkah: With all the arguing over who is a 'REAL JEW' that takes place, I think you have a good idea with your example from Ruth. I feel bad when I read about Jews who feel rejected because they don't have the 'approved' background. However, I think the current requirements, although they may make some (real) Jews feel bad, are necessary for the times we live in. I believe their purpose is to prevent Fake Jews from ultimately taking over Israel. I can well imagine that there are people who would pretend to be converts & join with other pretenders to influence Israeli law, politics, etc.. I can see this would be a way for Israeli's enemies to try and take over.
Christy ,   Boston, US   (03.09.08)
40. Britian should outlaw Jewish schools
How racist is it to seperate children based on if they are Jewish. It should be illegal to have a Jewish school. Children should all go to public mixed schools where they will socialize with children of all religions races and sexual orientation. School should be where barriers between people are broken down not where bigotry is taught.
Shulamit   (03.11.08)
41. 18 % of British schools
do not obey the new admission regulations [ BBC teletext ] This school , a private one , has the right to have preferences in the matter of admissions .
charles ,   petach tikva   (03.12.08)
 Previous talkbacks
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks