News
Man shoots sister then congratulated by family
Sharon Roffe-Ofir
Published: 11.03.08, 14:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
92 Talkbacks for this article
31. 15 - are you kidding?
Jon ,   Beer Sheva   (03.11.08)
"people should live according to their traditions..." Are you kidding? Since when is murdering acceptable as a tradition? What impartial court of law reviewed this case and deemed her to suffer death? Democratic countries need to ensure basic human rights and freedom against harm for their citizens. Accepting social customs of honor killings denies this right. Individual family members have no legal right to carry out any murder against another citizen. If you don't like the rules of the State, then leave for another place that lets you do whatever you want and hurt anyone you want with justice and court rulings.
32. # 12, Khamzir Saleh IS NOT A MUSLIM.
Atilla Karagözoğlu   (03.11.08)
33. reinstate death sentence for premeditated murder
yoni ,   jerusalem   (03.11.08)
If the country was run by any leader at this point they wuld reconsder the laws in place and ammend them to meet the cruelty of the arabs. arabs should be in jordan
34. National Public Radio and ...
John ,   Saint Louis, Mo, USA   (03.11.08)
First I would like to say that I hope the young woman recovers fully. Next. Yesterday on National Public Radio they had a story about religious Jews in Israel who had put up signs at the local mall informing people to dress in a decent manner. Lasted about 15 minutes. Point was to inform us on how terrible these religious Jews are for trying to suggest a dress code for the public. (I don't think they should have put the signs up, but I do not think it should have gotten so much air time, it was cleary religious Jew bashing). Now, will they do a story as long and as critical about this? I mean come on, killing and trying to kill women in such a brutal manner. If they did do a story they would try to spin it so that the fault somehow laid with Israel.
35. Atilla Karagözoğlu is a .......
A. Turk ,   pi kerem   (03.11.08)
sherfsis pezevenk, yahud hater
36. Attila is an oppressor
Khamzir Saleh ,   Um el fahm   (03.11.08)
..how dare you say I am not a moslem, you must be a zionist, I totally reject this oppressin on my people and my sons and my sons sons and my father and my fathers fathers! I am a holy moslem I pray 5 times a day and beleive in the koran, which says... "if you see a Jew behind the rock then kill him"..... this is the truth of the koran from the holy prophet mohamed and I will t hank you to keep your oppressive judgmental views to your self shukran!
37. Arabs like killing things . . . even other arabs
sam   (03.11.08)
38. what is there to comment on 13th Century savages ??
Charles   (03.11.08)
39. #12 you got that right
Yehud   (03.11.08)
40. #12: Why did the shooter call the medics?
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (03.11.08)
41. VERY GOOD
Bolud Al Kotur ,   Isratina   (03.11.08)
VERY GOOD HER JUDGMENT IS DEAD, TOO BAD THE BROTHER DIDN'T MANAGE TO KILL HER. ALL INDECENT ARAB WOMEN SHOULD BE EXECUTED, NOT THE DECENT ONES ONLY THE ONES THAT DON'T RESPECT OUR LAWS AND TRADITIONS ALLAH HUAKBAR
42. It's Tough Being A Muslim
Not Jewish ,   USA   (03.11.08)
First, all those prayers five times a day, it's hard thinking of new things to say to Allah and it's rough on the knees. They have to marry their kin folk to keep the family name alive even if they can't stand their chosen mate, uncle, aunt, cousin, etc.. They have to tote AK47's and explosives 24/7 and these weapons are so heavy and tiring to lug around.. Muslims have to stay very busy because there are so many Jews to kill so that Israel can be destroyed. The Jews don't appreciate this and they shoot back. Then there are the honor killings, Muslims have to kill their sisters,aunts, mothers, female cousins, etc. to please Muhammad and Allah. I tell you, It's tough being a Muslim
43. #41 Your hatred of women is so sad !!!!
rachel ,   usa   (03.11.08)
44. sick in the head
Nick ,   London   (03.11.08)
45. to Family and #12
ilan ,   Ashdod   (03.11.08)
You know, every culture has something in it, that seems so extreme to other cutlures. Eating dog/cats, consuming Pork, etc. Its all about Modernaization and acculturation (the process of adopting the cultural traits or social patterns of another group). Kapara, you live in Isreal, murder is not an accepted social pattern here, for ANY REASON! To us, this sort of behavor is primitive. Not to say we ourselves are a stranger to the concept of family honour. The Buhari/jews for example, are very strict about family honour, they go to lengths as far as disowning childern, throwing them out on the street. as backwards as it may seem, its still a step up from killing ur own family members.Most buhari families ike my family, have addapted to israeli culture, im sorry but premarital sex is becoming more and more common, womans clothing are becoming smaller and smaller, especially in western culture. Shot Yourself, blame yourself for exposing your daugther to our civilization, if you had stayed in yours, this would have not happend. We ALL give in to temptations at least once in our lives, its human nature. follow the norms,follow the leader. how many of you stopped wearing hijabs? how can u take it to apoint, (stop wearing hijabs) and kill someone else for taking a little bit further( or alot further, i dunno) i dunno how it is in Naura, but do men go around shooting women who dont cover up? would that also be acceptable to you?
46. PLURALISTIC SOCIETY
ABSHALOM ISSEBERG ,   RAMAT HASHARON, ISRA   (03.11.08)
AS A SUPPORTER OF A DEMOCRATIC AND PLURALISTIC SOCIETY, I THINK IS THEIR PROBLEM IF THEY KEEP THE HONOR OF THE FAMILY THAT WAY. WE HAVE NO RIGHT TO JUDGE, AS THEY DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT TO JUDGE US. I HAVE LEARN TO ACCEPT THE DIFFERENT COSTUMS AND TRADITIONS OF THE M,NORITIES IN ISRAEL. THEY ARE ENTITLE TO THIS AND IS NOT OUR PLACE TO JUDGE THEM
47. DEFECTIVE AMMO
HARRY CALLAHAN ,   SAN FRANCISCO, USA   (03.11.08)
I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHAT CALIBER AND WHAT KIND OF AMMO WAS USED IN THE SHOOTING. TWO BULLET IN THE HEAD AND NONE PENETRATE? HE SHOULD SUE THE AMMUNITION MANUFACTURER
48. Ynet is no more respectfull news site
Atilla Karagözoğlu   (03.11.08)
49. #31 Jon in Beersheva
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.11.08)
Of course I was kidding - Ynet wouldn't print my original comment. But read #12 - if he represents opinion in his community, oy vey.
50. What Family Honor ?
dennis ,   chicago   (03.11.08)
We here in the USA see this periodically from arabs that have immigated. This behavior is in the same catagory as those crazy Indiians (from India) who "douse their women in gasoline and set them on fire". I want to know WHO HAS MORE HONOR FOR THEIR FAMILY ? HEY ?
51. About talkback 36, Khamzer Saleh, I don't think he is
(03.11.08)
an Arab from Umm ul-Fahm... He spells Jew with a capital J and the Qura'n with a small k... and most of his PRblaha is copied from some leaflet he wouldn't ever be able to write that himself, whoever he is Probably some bored person who is trying to pull of a prank on us. Hey, we are too busy for you!!! Get off that couch and do some useful work, will you!!!
52. #12 KHAMZIR SALEH IS NOT AN ARAB, NOT MORE A MUSLIM
Anna ,   TLV   (03.11.08)
I BET SOMEONE IS TRYING TO FULL US: He is not a Palestinian citizen of Israel. He is not muslim. He doesn't live in Umm Al Fahm. Honor killing has nothing with the way of life of "Arabs" or "Muslim"! For people who still don't know, for you "Mr Saleh", honor killing is nowhere in Islam and has nothing to do with it. This barbaric and unhuman pratice existed in non-muslim societies too... And the Jihad "Mr Saleh" talks about at the end of his post is also not in Islam.
53. @12 Khamzir saleh , umm al fahm, Israel
ben shlomo ,   singapore   (03.11.08)
Khamzir you are a KURAFAT MUSLIM. Yes it the kind of Islam you KURAFAT arabs live. In your Islamic History your Arab moslem life style is called JAHILIAH !! Yes you Arabs get confused with family honor with humanity, love, compassion and civilization.You Muslim bury female babies and it has been a honorable practise which even you Mohammed denounced.You Mohamed judged you Arab way of life long ago so we know.You Arbas are the biggest rapist, an you talk about that girl deserve bullets and beating. You ARab Saudi king once punished the victim of a Rape than the Rapist. The world saw the Arabi Moslem way of life, so babaric an uncivilised. I judge youe ways as KRAFAT and SATANIC practise. Harlot call that girl, ? I agree YOU ARE NOT MUSLIM, YOU DONT PRAY FIVE TIMES and YOUR ARE FATHER OF YOU OWM HARLOTORY, EXTREMIST ISLAMIC TERRORIST KURAFAT SOCIETY disgraced and no holi name or honour you arabs have anyway !!! ben singapore
54. If this girl makes a good recovery, and I pray she does...
Adamush   (03.11.08)
...she needs to be granted a firearm licence for protection for sure. She'll never be safe with a family like that about. Anyone want to organize a whip-round for a handgun + training?
55. Way to go Terry
Libneniyyeh ,   Beirut/Canada   (03.11.08)
spread that venom. Like u dont know he's an imposter.
56. @35 Khamzir Saleh , ABOUT ATILLA ANOTHER POINT
ben shlomo ,   singapore   (03.11.08)
Atilla Karagözoğlu is nothing like you accuse of, I know him,he is a better Muslim than you Kurafat.He will never be a zionist, well we fight like cat and dog always on this zionism but we can agree on many things.If I see an Arab and a SNAKE. I will kill you Arabs FIRST! The Arabs are even more dangerous than the snake.As for you koran truth, you acn shuff it down the drain. You want to learn about Islam, you learn from the Turkish People. Atilla is not an oppressor but an agreessor for CORRECT RESAONS HE BELIEVE IN. EVEN I CANT CHANGE HIS MIND, THIS MUCH I CAN SAY !!! Khanzir salleh first you learn to live with RESPECT and STAY WITH RESPECT !!! salamia ! ben singapore
57. HONOR KILLLING & CULTURAL HATE
Dennis ,   Chicago, USA   (03.11.08)
Comment to #12. I realy wanted to THANK YOU for this explaination on "Honor Killings" and the hatred that comes from pals against the yahud. I ONLY WISH THAT YOUR ARTICLE BECOMES HEADLINE NEWS IN THE CHICAGO "SUN-TIMES" OR "TRIBUNE" Americans need to understand why we have such a different set of cultural values, especially about human life. The last time Americal encoutered such behavior was when TV showed an Afghan taking out a women to a deserted soccer stadium and shooting her. also an honor killing. THANKS, AGAIN for the clearity of your thought.
58. #36 Hey Khamzir ...
NilsG ,   Helsingborg, Sweden   (03.11.08)
... youze in BIG trouble now, youze fergot to write "Blessed be he" after the name of mohamed ... with lowercase m, even ... dat is SOOO bad ...
59. Disgusting islamic ethics, murdering own sister
Johnny ,   Stockholm Sweden   (03.11.08)
Is it time to start the discussion about outlawing islam? This type of murdering is very common in Sweden. It is always muslims who perform these acts. The most common way in Sweden to kill muslim female relatives is to throw them down to the ground from a balcony. They muslim men then claim she fell. This has happened approximately 10 times in the last 12 months.
60. Tame Compared to USA Feminists
bill ,   nv, usa   (03.11.08)
This is minor compared to how Feminists in the USA are destroying families. Read Taken Into Custody by Baskerville and the Reviews to understand the evil, illegal, criminal acts the Feminists in the USA are doing to destroy Fathers & Families.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article