News
New group offers alternative to AIPAC
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 30.03.08, 10:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. Extremists form lobby.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.30.08)
They don't represent the views of the vast majority of American Jews. They don't even represent the views of he vast majority of non-Jews. This is just a small group of extremists on the far left, vocal to be sure, whose views have been rejected in Israel & throughout the Jewish world. The fact of the matter is that their views have become so marginalized here in Israel, so overwhelmingly rejected, that they are attempting to manipulate American Jews & American politicians - this is the "rape Israel" crowd who want American pressure to impose the ideas that they failed to sell democratically here in Israel.
2. America is puke
Zion   (03.30.08)
America is no friend of Israel, cut all relations with it, leave the leftists to rot on their sofas, encourage Jews for a Jewish State to return as quick as possible.
3. Since when is AIPAC "right wing"? Are they insane?
Antonio ,   Haifa   (03.30.08)
4. More far-left drivel
Millie ,   Israel   (03.30.08)
Ugh! We do need an alternative to AIPAC, but definitely not this "sell-out Israel" group.
5. in other words...American Friends of Fatah
aaron ,   ra'anana   (03.30.08)
Just like Yossi Beilin, and just like Meretz, these misguided, self-loathing, jews will work tirelessly, day and night, towards the destruction of the jewish state.
6. Who the J-Street People Are
Dan ,   Titusville, FL USA   (03.30.08)
When Communism collapsed in Russia the Left wing radicals had no where to go. Most ended up in the environmental movement but a few got the idea of forming PAC's or other fringe radical groups thanks to the internet. Code Pink is a good example. These are anti-Democracy, anti-Freedom, pro Communist radicals who belive any political philosophy other than freedom and self-determination is superior. These people are in truth babies who are not capable of caring for themselves and want the Government to control their lives but like most infants they fill up their diapers and want the world to clean up their mess. These people do not understand the world as it is and think if we all sit around a campfire singing "Kumbaya" we'll all get along. The defy what Jews have known for 3,000 years and that is that evil exists and must be fought.
7. no shortage of leftist jewish organizations!
Nadav ,   tel aviv   (03.30.08)
this is rediculous, there is certainly no shrotage of leftit jewish organizations in america; leftist jews dominate the political landscape in Jewish mainstream NGOs and organizations. They may feel their "narrative" and ideology is not heard largely because anyone semi-literate person with internet access can see that they have nothing to offer! With whom is Israel to make peace?! Israel is at war against a tsunami of eliminationist anti-semitic Islamo-fascists; it is the most severe threat since Nazism. Even Soviet Anti-semitism did not have another Holocaust on its agenda as Iran and the Arab League does (they don't sat it, but they are working hard to accomplish it). Until I moved to Israel from NYC and saw first hand how B'Tselem and other lefist organizations actively aide those who wish only to see our annihilation, I realised that the Left in Israel his completely and utterly ideoological dishonest and morally bankrupt. I am a secular jew, i have worked at the Federation and other Jewish organizations, and I can say that the Left threatens the very future of the Jewish people in Israel and the Diaspora!! Stop them now!
8. Millitant Muslem group
John ,   Chicago   (03.30.08)
This is a millitant group, supporters of Muslems like Obama and his mentor Write.
9. Like every left wing nincompoops
Ivri   (03.30.08)
before them....eventually these losers will show their true Bolshevick nature and start spewing their Kumbaya drivell,and expect us all to nod in agreement and tugg along.But.....since we werent born yesterday,we know where they are heading....at the end of the day,they are all Stalinist/bolshevicks,anti anything that doesnt conform to their twisted world view AND their FAILED world view of apeasement and dhimitude. And BTW....THERE IS NO J ST IN DC.( How fitting...to be named after a non existing street on the road to nowhere)
10. TA Leftists running scared
Reality Check ,   BaGolan   (03.30.08)
Like their hamas allies, the leftists have realized that we will no longer tolerate their attacks on the Jewish State. So now they seek new forums. They should however note the polls in the US also: over 75% of Americans agree that Israel is in the right in our resolve against arab tyranny.
11. Growing Like Weeds
David Feldman ,   Lake George US   (03.30.08)
Leftwing "Pro-Israel" groups in the US are way behind the dominant influence their Peace Now counterparts have in Israel, and these guys are just trying to play catch-up. I doubt they'll have much success because USA Jews aren't nearly as suicidal as Israelis.
12. It's good to see American jews against zionism
Shulamit   (03.30.08)
It's good to see American Jews willing to stand up and say we are Jews not Zionists and don't support the racist zionist ideology. When Obama becomes President he will have strong Jewish support when he takes action against Israel.
13. To #12 LOL!! Why dont you change your zionist hebrew name?
(03.30.08)
LOL What a poser & faker you are!!!
14. How dare they? Why not equality in the USA first?
Sheila ,   Jerusalem Israel   (03.30.08)
15. GOOD NEWS and FINALLY
(03.30.08)
Aipac has given the jews such a nasty "israeli firster" reputation. thank god for a new group. good luck.
16. J-Street is good but we need more gay involvment , peace.
Yaakov Sullivan ,   NYC   (03.30.08)
17. J-Street Office in S'derot
Michal R. ,   S'derot, Israel   (04.15.08)
I would gladly contribute to helping J-street establish their offices in Sderot. They might get a different perspective of their goals for Israel.
Back to article