News
4 siblings killed in IDF strike in Gaza
Ali Waked
Published: 28.04.08, 13:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
75 Talkbacks for this article
31. THE ONLY RESPONSIBLES ARE THE PALESTINIANS THEY WANT WAR
(04.28.08)
32. TO the IDF ..............................Am Yisrael Chai
YITZAK BEN SHLOMO ,   TURKEY   (04.28.08)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eo6DNjJ9_Sc
33. This is an example of Islamist "death-ploitation"
Millie ,   Israel   (04.28.08)
The cynical use and exploitation of innocent children is a hallmark of cruel Islamist ideology (so does the "honor" murder of girls and women for that matter). Remember that they regard their dead children as "martyrs". They indulge in the gruesome display of the dead bodies for greater effect (except when it's a hoax, like al-Dura, where there was no dead body). Just take a look at photos of Hamas terrorists in the streets - always with young boys - and with little boys holding real weapons. The terrorists send 12 & 13 year-olds to collect rocket launchers after a strike knowing full well that they can be killed in the process. Their death makes it easier to pin the blame on Israel, who takes extraordinary (even unnecessary) measures to avoid civilian casualties. For these terrorist thugs, it's pure opportunism at the expense of their children.
34. No. 7
NYC Girl   (04.28.08)
For your information, that's exactly what happened to an Israeli mother and her four children. But in that case, Palestinian terrorists deliberately shot up her car at point blank range killing the pregnant mother and all of her kids.
35. Human Shields
Yessir Ibn Badkarma ,   Kanwait   (04.28.08)
Those children should be in school. Not human shield terrorist training.
36. Can anybody believe what Ali Waked reports?
jay3 ,   Israel   (04.28.08)
I have never once seen ALi Waked retract any false reports he has made in the past. Many times his reports have proven to be propaganda and lies. Is this story another half truth? Seems his witnesses always seem to be only Palastinians.
37. #22 do you think you'll get away with it?
observer   (04.28.08)
38. RE NO 24 Hamas Self Inflicted Success ...??
Jude   (04.28.08)
In answer to your talkback.. The Palestinian mother and her four children who were sadly killed Monday during IDF ops in Beit Hanun were not hit by a tank shell but rather were killed when ammunition carried by gunmen exploded, Army Radio quoted an IDF source as saying. According to the unofficial source, the forces operating in the Gaza Strip town identified two gunmen who were carrying large bags. When the soldiers opened fire on them the bags exploded, causing the deaths of the family members.
39. IDF SAYS THIS NOT THE ARMY
(04.28.08)
40. Allah still out to lunch...
Mike   (04.28.08)
...when it comes to Israeli ordnance
41. #9, 11, 25
Zeal ,   Zionist America   (04.28.08)
#9: ((The IDF as well as the IAF does not tagert civileans. If civileans are killed you all should ask why hammas as hizbullah use human shields.)) As far as the news goes it seems that this incursion was, like the last one that killed a fourteen year old, simply an invasion of a highly populated area and resisted by local fighters. Israel does not target civilians? Oh no, it only shoots little girls in the face. #11: ((Unfortunately, the Palestinians choose the cowardly action of hiding behind women and children.)) Yeah sure: go invade a highly populated area and expect the invaded to sit still as their rights are transgressed. Face it: you are the killers. The murder weapon was yours. The invasion was yours. #25: ((If you cannot cry when Israeli children are killed or hurt, stop complaining about the IDF.)) But how often does that happen? Not a single Israeli child was killed by any Palestinian last year and only one in 2006. There were four this year (under age 18), which is nothing compared to the huge numbers of Palestinian children.
42. ANOTHER HOAXED PICTURE
(04.28.08)
43. #34 NYC Girl said it; Pales terrorists deliberately did it
observer   (04.28.08)
but, non-terrorist Israel is doing it deliberately by mistake.
44. #35 kids serving half time job in school
observer   (04.28.08)
the other half-time they served in their house as targets. I've almost forgotten; they had less than half time school job. They were in their preschool age of 1-5 years.
45. THIS IS WAR ??? ARABS DECLARED IT AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN
AND AGAIN AND AGAIN ,   ..............DACON9   (04.28.08)
46. |f the Palestinians want to keep up "armed struggle" and to
Gary   (04.28.08)
continue attacking Israel with the aim of destroying her, then they can expect casualties. They have rejected every peace offer of Israels, including the giving up of Gaza, and carried on with more terror. They refuse to accept peace with Israel, or recognize Israel's right to be, so they must suffer the results of their own 'intifada'. Just as Nazi Germany was to blame for their own casualties at Dresden , so the Arabs are to blame for their own casualties. Why don't the Arabs stop shelling Sderot, if they stop attacking Israel, Israel will not react and their will be no more deaths. You can't keep attacking someone and then howl out in outrage when they hit back.
47. Deceptions
(04.28.08)
What hamas want the world to see is that every time the IDF fire a bullet, a grenade or a missile, that only children are hurt. Well hamas you are sick & you have run out of lies & tricks, it won’t work
48. #43, the blind observer
Jay3 ,   Israel   (04.28.08)
You need to observe the facts more carefully as im afraid these childrens deaths were caused by the terrorists! "Unofficial IDF sources report that Palestinian woman and children were not killed by an IDF tank shell. IDF Givati brigade soldiers engaged 2 Palestinian terrorists in a gun-battle -- the terrorists shooting from within the house of the woman and children. Each terrorist was wearing an over-sized knapsack, apparently loaded with ammunition. When hit by IDF gunfire, the terrorists' ammunition exploded, causing the deaths of the woman and children inside the house. Source: Galei Tzahal IDF radio, in Hebrew)"
49. #39, of course Barak is saying
observer   (04.28.08)
whether in retaliation or by mistake, it IS Hamas' fault. You should always accept his saying as by default. Let's wait and see whether he will or will apologize before or after the investigation.
50. The hypocrisy of these leftist pallie-lovers never ceases to
Gary   (04.28.08)
amaze me. when arab deliberately kill Israeli children, they gloat and beat their breasts in triumph and spit out venomous remarks that the Israelis deserve it. But when Pallies are killed in Israeli retaliation, they howl blue murder. The Palestinians can recognize Israel and get astate and peace in a day if they want but they refuse to stop fighting to destroy another state and another people. If you attack others continually don't howl when they hit back!
51. No difference between this airstrike and suicide bomber..
Rami ,   Nazareth, Israel   (04.28.08)
both kill innocent civilians both are terrorism....on is Islamic terrorisim the other is Jewish terrorisim..
52. READ THE 'RIGHT' SIDE OF THE TRUTH ON THE NET, NOT ONLY YNET
CHILDREN ARE SHIELDS ,   FOR ARABS.....DACON9   (04.28.08)
53. Pallywood
israeli ,   israel   (04.28.08)
How can a tank shell explode two or three times? If it hits a weapons cache. Rami, suicide bombers get to look into their victims eyes.
54. Hamas is to blame for this horrific act
observer   (04.28.08)
55. # 49 Observer
Gary   (04.28.08)
"Let's wait and see whether he will or will apologize before or after the investigation" Israel always apologized when Pallie civillians are killed in the crossfire. The Pallies have never apologized once when they have butchered Israeli women and children.
56. I HAVE A SOLUTION!!!!
Michael   (04.28.08)
All palis should get up and MOVE to egypt right now!!! since Israel has a "peace treaty" with egypt...it's unlikely that this will happen there. What's that? it's against the law in egypt for palis to live there? well...maybe that law should be changed. wacky arabs
57. #48 believes every body having "Imperfect" as first name
observer   (04.28.08)
the problem is that in populated area you have a lot of witnesses and evidence can't be easily hidden. The fighting with Givatis ended hours before. The story is just a cover-up to justify what Barak has said earlier: "We see Hamas as responsible for everything that happens in the area around Gaza, all of the strikes, and the IDF is acting and will continue to act against Hamas, within the Gaza Strip,"
58. how come?
(04.28.08)
the number of those killed mistakingly by Israel far exceeds the number of those killed deliberately by Palestinian terrorists?
59. shame on you
eddi ,   london   (04.28.08)
to be honest I don't knpow when will some people admit that the IOF (IDF) is the problem, how can you sleep at night when you justify the killing of four children? is is the first time? how about the camera man? how about the other families? is it all because of Hamas? stop leing to yourself, your army doesn't mind killing Palestinian civilians. It is veru easy to put the blame on Hamas but till when are you going to live with this big lie? if hamas is your problem kill them all of them but don't kill the children and say it is because of Hamas, be humans and treat us like humans maybe one day there will be peace
60. Rami, I am dissappointed by your reaction
Ruth ,   Beer Sheva   (04.28.08)
I hope that you are writing this under strong emotional stress and will think better of it. There seems to be no doubt that this family was used as human shields by gunmen. It is also possible that they were not killed by Israeli fire but by the secondary explosion of weapons or explosives in their surrounding. If you cannot see the difference between this victims (and I try to grieve for the children and their mother) in the wrong place at the wrong time and the intentionally targeted victims of suicide bombings , then you have lost your moral compass or never had one.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article