Opinion
We didn’t mean to kill them
B. Michael
Published: 04.05.08, 10:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
71 Talkbacks for this article
61. #59 Jon give back Oz to the Aborigine
andy ,   orlando,u.s   (05.07.08)
Israel by birthright belongs to the Jewish people for 3 thousand years & 47 UN partition plan,so quit with your occupation and rape of land bs.Why would arabs encourage their children to become combatants by throwing stones at the IDF? .The arabs are completely responsible for their own civilian deaths as they use civilians as human shields.They are too cowardly to take on the IDF in the open!!!
62. Palestinian children killed by Israeli forces
Michael G.P. ,   Perth Australia   (05.07.08)
The Israeli government regards non-jews as sub-human and without rights. Ye shall reap as ye sow.
63. The terrorists are trying to get us to kill their children.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (05.07.08)
While Israel has built a shelter system in Sderot in order to protect lives, Hizbullah did the opposite in Lebanon in 2006 - because Hizbullah wanted to increase the amount of its civilian deaths. That's because our culture is one of 'choose life', while the Imams encourage them to look at their children as martyrs. This is what makes it so difficult for the democracies, the terrorists are trying to get us to kill their children. We should be prepared to fight them with no other consideration than beat them as explained at : http://xrl.us/bi9r6
64. Having read all 63 talkbacks i see . .
michael mazur ,   brunswick australia   (05.07.08)
that 10 are child protectors and 53 just don't care, as it seems they don't mind losing 11 Israeli kids over the next 8 yrs if it will bag them another 1,000 Palestinian kids. And why should the next 8 yrs be any different, as any Israeli govt knows it has to provide spectator and participant blood sports to this unique kind of electorate if it is to survive ? How does the 81% small sample here extrapolate to the 5.5million Israelis ? Anyone ? Seeing as no harvest of death can be large enough for the 53 who just don't care, i doubt very much if their psychopathy will be sated when millions of Iranian kids are likely incinerated in the very near future. When Ynet reports on those mass deaths in Iran i wonder if that 53 and others like them will have woken up to the enormity of the fact that their pathological way of thinking had a indirect bearing on that genocide ? They cannot absolve themselves of the responsibility just because they put those bozo Americans up to it. Everyone will know Israel was behind it.
65. Children, non-combatants and combatants
Itzik ,   San Francisco, USA   (05.07.08)
B. Michael raises profound moral questions, but the answers he provides are less than profound, and are actually rather simplistic. Questions he leaves unaddressed include the following: Of the 1000 Palestinian children killed in the conflict, how many were combatants, how many non-combatants? Does B. Michael forget that Hamas recruits children as young as 12 to be suicide bombers? And uses children to gather Qassam rocket launchers after they are fired, knowing full well that after a Qassam launch Israel will strike the area of the launch? Is a 14 y. o. child throwing a molotov cocktail, or firing a rifle, a "child" or a combatant? Where is B. Michael's condemnation of Hamas for recruitng children for war? If Islamist terrorists are willing to place sleeping babies in cars loaded with explosvies to fool U.S. soldiers into thinking the car is harmless, then blows up the car with the soldiers, baby and all, is it not also plausible that the Islamist terrorists of Hamas or Islamic Jihad would also use children in such a murderously callous manner? The awful tragedy of this conflict is the deaths of children. I do wish Israel would take more care, and admit more responsibility, for those non-combatant children killed in the crossfire. Israel should indeed be held to account for such tragic and in most instances preventable deaths. Yet, those such as B. Michael and his supporters in this talk back who ignore, or dismiss, the questions I pose are themselves guilty of a kind of selective and flawed morality, and a perverse sort of demogoguery.
66. Killing Kids
Jan ,   California, USA   (05.08.08)
I am sickened by how many of the posters seem to have no problem with killing Palestinian kids. Shame on all of them. You blame Hamas but do not ever lay blame on the 40 year brutal occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. Gaza, BTW, is now the world's largest outdoor prison and the prisoners are not happy with their jailers. It is past time that those who justify the murder of Palestinian kids because of Hamas should understand that were there no occupation there would be no Hamas which was born as a resistance movement. The Palestinians have every right in the world to resist the occupation and the theft of their lands and water resources. Israel must get out of the territories lock, stock and barrel.
67. No.65 what is sickening is your sanctimonous piety
YSL ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.09.08)
To you and the rest of these self -righteous pecksniffians who come here and tell us how we should behave and protect ourselves. If these miserable cowards didn't hide and shoot behind their children and their wives skirts then their kids wouldn't get hurt.This is a war and the code of the Marquess of Queensberry rules do not apply here.
68. This is war, etc.
andrew ,   St. Louis, US   (05.10.08)
If the Arabs are so dangerous, why are Israelis so anxious to live among them? This 'war' is about Israel conquering land, not protecting anyone.
69. To 68 study history and then post
YSL ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.10.08)
Jews were in this area since ever,every time some idiot comes over here and spews his ignorant rubbish,We have to straighten him.And we have to repeat to them the simple facts again and again and again.Nothing wrong with conquering land from jackasses who insist on starting wars and losing them.
70. What history do you want?
andrew   (05.11.08)
The one where all Jews are genetically descended from the Israelites? And have a genetic entitlement to the Holy Land even if they're atheists? That's the history of Zionism.
71. Funny to see the inhabitants of the penal colony that is Oz
Alex ,   Haifa, Israel   (05.12.08)
lecturing us about morals and such. And GTFO of there you land theiving bastards, leave it to the Aborines!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article