News
Soldiers charged with beating Palestinian senseless
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 04.05.08, 09:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. brutal
po ,   haifa   (05.04.08)
brutal thing to do if correct
2. You mean they acually had to lay a hand
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (05.04.08)
on him?! I thought 5000 yrs. of inbreeding just made them all that way naturally.
3. Daily Duty
sameer ,   Jerusalem   (05.04.08)
This is a daily work for IDF, so what is new? This is what the occupation means.
4. if is true...
Giuseppe ,   Italy   (05.04.08)
I read often on Ynet about IDF soldiers beating poor palestinians... are you sure they are absolutely guilty? It seems to me that Ynet take always the same point of view, not so balanced
5. Giuseppe
huh?   (05.04.08)
What are you implying? That he wasnt beat or that there was a good reason for three armed mean to kick the shit out of him?
6. To number 5
Giuseppe ,   Italy   (05.04.08)
both. maybe there was a good reason and soldiers was tired and maybe exagerated their reaction, or maybe is not true that sodliers did what palestinians say they did. Remember jenin or al doura cases... Wht we must believe every single word palestinians say?
7. Surely the IDF Wlll Absolve The Terrorists of Wrondoing
Johan Odin ,   Oslo, Norway   (05.04.08)
The IDF, being the most moral and ethical [sic] army in the world will find the jack booted thugs responsible for this crime not guilty of the crime and instead promote them and highly praise them for their actions as the victim after all was merely a Palestinian and not a Jew. I'm sure the IDF will do its normal thorough investigation that in the end will blame the naked victim for daring to live and absolve the thugs of any wrong doing as any moral and ethical army would if given the opportunity to judge itself.
8. I don't know who are the biggest losers
Smith ,   TA, Israel   (05.04.08)
.... us, as the occupiers, or the Palestinians as the occupied. Either way we're all losing our humanity.
9. kol hakavod lzhal!
sara ,   israel   (05.04.08)
10. To #8 - TA leftists will find any reason
Reality Check ,   BaGolan   (05.04.08)
The TA leftists will use any excuse to condemn the Jewish State, and this is no excuse. If the soldiers are found guilty, they will be punished. But TA leftists, like Smith, will look to blame the residents of Sderot for the qassams; will blame our children in Ashqelon for daring to be in kindergartens when katyushas hit; and will surely condem the security fence since it makes it more difficult for homicide bombers to hit us. I am only trying to understand why people like Smith don't just leave to States more to their liking, like Iran or Zimbabwe
11. They will be found innocent, they always are
Rabbi Clive Rosenber ,   London   (05.04.08)
This happens all the time and they are always found innocent. I have seen much worse. As long as Israelis see all Goy as Amalek. Zionism will destroy the Jewish People. Israelis should think twice before tolerating this. Some day the boot will be on the other foot. When Palestinians obtain a position of strength what will they do after Jews treated them like this while Jews were in a position of strength?
12. HOW do you beat a palestinian enemy SENSELESS???
hymie zoltsveis ,   NYC USA   (05.04.08)
To beat someone senseless, they must first have some sense. By its terms alone, "beating a palestinian senseless" is an absolute impossibility.
13. Number 7---from Oslo---where our suicide pact began
hymie zoltsveis ,   NYC USA   (05.04.08)
Number 7, from Oslo, should know loads about thuggery. that is where Israel's weak, secular leaders were forced to give away Holy land to the enemy. Actions that have been WELL-PROVEN to be acts of suicide. Israel must cancel ALL OF OSLO> Remove enemies from Jewish lands---given to us by G-d----and re-build the Holy Land of Israel, that was given to us IN ETERNITY by G-d. Say NO to Oslo!
14. Sounds reminiscent...
G ,   US   (05.04.08)
Sounds much to much like the case of several US soldiers in Iraq who were accused of crimes. Even the Congressman Murtha got involved saying how Guilty they were. The press all over it. But, come to find out All the charges were dropped. The last person charged was finally acquitted just the other day. When will the news media "Learn" that Arabs are habitual Liars!!
15. #11 makes sense, which prompts . .
michael mazur ,   brunswick australia   (05.05.08)
me to ask whether Israel will text Iranian Jews to stay home on the day the United States of Israel obliterates all of Iranian infrastructure much like they did Lebanese nearly 2 yrs ago, but this time with nukes ? Iranians will later piece together that the Iranian Jews knew of what was about to happen, and took prudent measures, but did not notify their fellow nationals; and so you will be hated there too.
16. Sorry Hymie, God's conventant with Abraham covers all
Johan Odin ,   Oslo, Norway   (05.05.08)
... and not just Jews. Most European Jews like yourself claim a religious right based upon Gods biblical promise to Abraham whom they selfishly believe was a promise to Jews alone, when in fact no religious sect (Jewish or otherwise) was even mentioned in God's promise that was given to all of Abraham's descendents. Most Palestinian Christians and Muslims are direct descendents of Abraham as proven by modern genetic research and have a stronger genetic link than most European Jews who are descended from Khazar converts and have no direct link. So even in one accepts that at best Jews have equal rights as the Palestinians do to the land of Palestine, the two cancel each other out and the since the Palestinians were already living there, their rights win out. . Sorry Hymie, I guess you better stay in New York.
17. These Arabs use deception/lying as a form of warfare
David ,   Houston TX   (05.08.08)
The reporter lists the Arabs claims as though they where facts, they are not, they are allegations. If the soldiers are found guilty, they will be punished. Alternatively, the Arabs celebrate and worship as heroes those terrorists who slaughter civilians.
Back to article