News
Olmert listens to Karnit, and weeps
Roni Sofer
Published: 30.06.08, 01:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
31. So, in short...
YMBMY ,   Modiin, Israel   (06.29.08)
Against the advice of our DEFENSE establishment, our leaders have agreed to a trade in whch we receive two (unfortunate) corpses and in return we release an unrepentant cold-blooded mass murderer who will be received as a hero by our enemies and who will encourage future murders. Well done, Olmert - your legacy continues to only worsen, just when we thought it could not. The sad part is that other than on a spirtual level, the people who made this decision will not be affected by the repercussions of this decision as they have additional protection at our expense.
32. A Hamas-Fatah favorite
Reuven ,   New York   (06.29.08)
If Hamas & PLO members and supporters could vote to select an Israeli prime minister, Olmert would be their overwhelming choice. He helped throw out thousands in Gush Katif, single-handedly lost the Lebanon War ( but was stupid enough to claim it was a victory), has given arms and moneys to Abbas which has ended up in the hands of Hamas, is willing to throw out thousands of more Jews from the West Bank and Golan for an illusory peace, has agreed to give amnesty and not pursue some of the most dangerous Fatah murderers, has watched Hezbollah and Hamas arm themselves to the hilt and done nothing, and will now apparently release more terrorists to show what a nice guy he is. And that's in addition to him (the former mayor of Jerusalem) agreeing to split Jerusalem with Abbas. The one thing Olmert has demonstrated is his willingness to stoop to anything and get away with it because of his enablers in Labor and Shas. Ehud Olmert- "Bad for the Jews. Good for Hamas."
33. Olmert JUST LOST HIS 2ND WAR against Hizballah
Miriam ,   Hizballh   (06.29.08)
Just shows how WEAK the "leaders" of Israel are.
34. truly dismayed
joe ,   france   (06.29.08)
Eight israeli soldiers died during hezb cross-boarder raid in 2006. Would've been fair enough to have their families' opinion over this "deal".
35. #28, the non-existent "4million" cluster bombs
Danny   (06.29.08)
wierd given the saturation claimed that the UN only found 970 odd.... Israel handed the maps over immediately after the war, the fact the UN keeps lying about the number isn't Israel's fault.
36. did terrorists pay Olmert for this ?
Charles   (06.29.08)
quite possible.....
37. Nothing but Kreplach
Avi   (06.29.08)
I don't believe they are going to go through with it. What if after we gave in this monster back to the Arabs, that they gave us in exchange a wooden box with kreplach? They are clearly not to be trusted, so why are they even talking to them? That they went against the defense establishment's assesment shows they've lost their compass.
38. exchange brain dead olmert for the two dead soldiers
chaim ,   brooklyn ny   (06.29.08)
wonder how much cash was in this envelope,recieved from hizbollah by this criminally insane traitorous gangster, citizens of israel get rid of this piece of humam garbage now,or you will find yourselves without a country
39. OLDMERDE TRAITOR
Mike Cato ,   USA   (06.29.08)
It is very clear now that Oldmerde&Co are traitors. They must be treated as such in the following manner: the general staff of the IDF must arrest Olmert. He must be tried and imprisoned. In the interim, the iDF must make all military decisions, macro as well as micro.. There is now no getting around this. A traitor is, by definition, a lethal danger. Painful decisions must be made and extraordinary steps taken. There is no other choice,--there really is not..
40. #14-Stay in the US! You're pathetic
Arie ,   BaGolan   (06.29.08)
Although I am totally and unconditionally opposed to this exchange, knowing full well that the olmert gang has probably received monetary compensation for their parts, the comments by sidney are abhorrent. One can only feel compassion for the Goldwassers and Regevs. Their sons have probably paid the ultimate sacrifice for the State and its people! To have a foreign moron like sidney lambast them for basic emotions puts him in the same league as the islamofascists, olmert, livni,vilnai, barak and meretz
41. #6, among others, is absolutely right!!!
me ,   here   (06.29.08)
What a sad thing to think that we would release live murderers, who are likely to commit the same crimes again once let out, for the remains of the kidnapped soldiers... May they rest in peace and G-d be with them... Deepest sympathy with their families and loved ones. And let those stay behind bars, who will only return to killing if let loose!!!
42. Is Olmert an enemy agent?
Israeli ,   Israel   (06.29.08)
He must be. I wouldn't put it past him to pay off his spineless cabinet to vote his way. Remember this: Bar On, Friedman and Boim didn't fall for it. They should be rewarded for their moral strength.
43. Israel will release dozens of bodies
observer   (06.29.08)
Omert: this decision deals with the repercussions on our lives in the coming years. Yes, Dead Jews are becoming new currency in the Middle East. But, don't forget that Israel sets the rules by holding dozens of bodies for bargaining.
44. Israel is the Laughing Stock of the Planet
Dave Levy ,   Burbank.CAUSA   (06.29.08)
It seems to me in the USA that Jews do not value their lives or the lives of their families or others. I mean, get real., perhaps they are not alive, according to Olmert. Why in heavens name didn't he DEMAND the status prior to this so-called deal. Again, the Pals come out the winners. First, the disengagement from Gaza and those 4 small settlements in the W. Bk, AFTER relinquishing Lebanon to Hez, then talking about E. Jerusalem and 97% of the W. Bk, and NOW it's on to the Golan Hts (Syria demands all of it, with no guarantees of anything approaching peace). Iran says it will produce nukes, if attacked (because it's headed towards nukes anyway). Bottom line: Olmert, Livni and Barak are jerks, fools, and dangerous to your survival. Bring in capital punishment for convicted terrorists, like Kuntar (who smashed babies heads). Israel, wake-up, you are the laughing stock of this planet.
45. Mike Cato: Hundreds of Thousands of Children Will Die
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (06.29.08)
To Mike Cato: I am an American born Jew and a dedicated (proud) Zionist. I fight for Israel wherever and whenever I can. That said: Israel MUST declare either a total or partial marshal law..with the military governing this small state. Olmert, Livni and Barak should be banished..let them retire to Miami Beach, with the other leftist, rich, naive, gullible Jews. This conflict has grown deplorable. Israel HAD the high ground after 67, and now is the victim. I ask, who won those wars of extermination? Syria emasculated IDFers, and Egypt had gas vans in the Sinai. Fatah struck all over Southern Israel..yet Kuntar, Barghouti, and others are freed or nearly free to kill more of you naive Jews. Wake-up Israel before Hez is in Tel Aviv, as threatened by them and Iran. Your children will die by the hundreds of thousands, and no one will come to your rescue, no one.
46. Death certificates
Leah ,   Israel   (06.29.08)
They have just signed the death certificates for hundreds, if not thousands, of Israelis that these Hizbullah dogs will return to killing...
47. Risks encouraging the murder of Israeli hostages
Howie ,   Toronto, Canada   (06.29.08)
Israel risks encouraging Hizbullah to murder Israelis they kidnap (in the future) because Hizbullah knows they will receive their terrorists back alive whether they kill the Israelis or not. Olmert and his Kadima sycophants are fools to trade dead Israelis for live terrorists. If Hizbullah knew they had to keep their Israeli hostages alive, they would not kill them. If Hizbullah insists on returning all Israelis only as dead bodies, then Israel should only return Hizbullah prisoners as dead bodies. They can always volunteer for this type of fair trade.
48. to 12
c ,   Israel   (06.29.08)
if we only have dead prisoners the next time there will be a kidnaping we won't have strong cards to put on the table
49. Pro-Islam TERROR Enabler Israeli Leaders Unfit to Rule
Linda Rivera   (06.29.08)
Where are the leaders to protect Jews? Devoid of ALL conscience. How dare these evil men give live terrorists in exchange for dead bodies? G-D have mercy on precious Ron Arad because Israel's extremely cruel, pro-Islam, pro-terror government has not one shred of mercy for Arad who has endured great agony for many long years. RETURN RON ARAD and the other Israeli POW/MIAs NOW! Take to the streets in mass protest Israel! If you are kidnapped, the government does not care if the terrorists kill you-they will eagerly give many live terrorists in exchange for your murdered body.
50. 5 Ministers are still undecided on the deal
observer   (06.29.08)
of course Livni is also.
51. The unbearable shame
Gideon Reader   (06.30.08)
The goverrnment of the alleged PM, Olmert the most failed and disgraced is neither a serious nor competent one. Possibly his rotten and corrupt style of governance could be overlooked IF he was marginally competent. Sadly, he is not. And never will be. A shame for the nation and the world.
52. #14Shame on you.You have no idea what it means to be a Jew.
Straighten out you ,   own country.Rueben   (06.30.08)
53. The familes should have been told immediately when the IDF
knew they were dead. ,   Why wait till now?   (06.30.08)
54. What I'm seeing here is that Olmert buckles under pressure
matter who it's from ,   Maurie, Israel   (06.30.08)
55. Olmert's Peace Plan
Dan ,   Titusville florida   (06.30.08)
Olmert's plan to bring peace to Israel is to set free every Arab terrorist to murder 3 Million Israelis. Olmert is saying "If every Jew gets killed Israel will have peace and I will be a hero in all Arab Capitols". Did the Doctors really mismange Ariel Sharon's medical care?
56. Olmert wept - was he cutting an onion?
Rami ,   London   (06.30.08)
57. WOULD ISRAEL SWAP A LIVE EICHMAN FOR 6 MILLION BODIES
Jorge ,   Tegucigalpa   (06.30.08)
iT IS THE SAME AS SWAPING A CHILD MURDERER FOR DEAD SOLDIERS
58. karnit
colin   (06.30.08)
The corrupt olmert wept LIE Were they crocadile tears?? Where they the swet from the pressure?? Olmert does not cry for any Jewish Israeli !!! Maybe an arab -never a jew.
59. this government, are criminally insane traitorous gangsters-
(06.30.08)
these two ehud's,had they lived 60 yrs ago during the holocaust,i have no doubt they would have been kapo's colaborating with the nazi's in sending the jews to the gas chambers, these two traitorous swines,if not stopped and deposed,will g-d forbid turn all of israel into a one big auschwitz and bring another holocaust on the people of irael
60. over-reaction
Doron   (06.30.08)
first of all, hezbollah will actually think twice about abductions because of the last lebanon war. secondly, the families deserve everything to be done. thirdly, the release of kuntar is good. he is worthless and israel is just paying for his lodging. its laughable that hezbollah is 'celebrating' the release of a child killer, and it will make many arabs think twice about what they stand for, especially when the exchange is for two young men, outstanding and loved by their familes who were actually human beings (even if they are now dead). when looked at from an outsider perspective, this deal benefits israel and puts closure to the lebanon war.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article