News
Palestinian woman pours acid on soldier
Efrat Weiss
Published: 22.09.08, 16:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. Lessons
Ricardo Macher ,   KarneiShomron Israel   (09.22.08)
We deserve what we get! Why wasn't this "woman"not arrested and deported to Gaza the first time? Why should we suffer attacks from this "people"who bit the hand that feeds them? Close everything and let them rot till they decide to take action cleaning their streets from fanatics, unluckily, this is the language they understand.
2. Close Down Hawara: Let No Arabs Through
Yishai Kohen ,   YeShA, Israel   (09.22.08)
They can't have it both ways. EITHER they will be allowed through- with no terror, or they will not be allowed through at all.
3. Why was she released the first time? Thanks Olmert!
JAyy ,   Israel   (09.22.08)
4. Do it once shame on you ,twice...
Larry ,   zefat   (09.22.08)
Throw acid once shame on you,throw it at me Twice shame on me.Anyway this woman is obviously off her head.The result of too much acid.
5. Yishai Kohen
Uri ,   Israel   (09.22.08)
I agree with Yishai. Following this attack, we should lock up all the Palestinians in their cities and villages. In fact, the West Bank should be turned into a giant penal colony, with the IDF serving as warden there forever.
6. Why do the Palestinians do this?
O. B. Erliner ,   Washington, D.C.   (09.22.08)
What are the chances of this happening again? How does this impact the coming election? Why acid? Why? Why?
7. I know what SHOULD be done with her
Talula ,   Israel   (09.22.08)
But it won't be printed.
8. #2 I AGREE.
meg ,   israel   (09.22.08)
9. Shut the checkpoints
Steve ,   Australia   (09.22.08)
So the Palestinians want to take advantage of the IDF being more lenient when it comes to checkpoints. Fine. Shut every checkpoint until they learn that their behavior is unacceptable.
10. # 3
Max ,   Oslo, Norway   (09.22.08)
She wasn't released the first time, she just got away...
11. #5 Uri
Said ,   London, UK   (09.22.08)
"the West Bank should be turned into a giant penal colony, with the IDF serving as warden there forever." What are you on about? It already is a prison camp, you just haven't noticed!
12. Enough "goodwill gestures"
Rina   (09.22.08)
The "goodwill gestures" are always on Israel's account, and they are always cynically taken advantage of by the Palestinians. Enough.
13. #11 - you idiot....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (09.22.08)
Who's never been here.
14. My guestures wouldn't be considered 'good will'
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.22.08)
15. WATER MUST ALWAYS BE AT THE READY IN CASE OF THESE INCIDENTS
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (09.22.08)
16. Close them down...
Gershon ,   Kfar Saba   (09.22.08)
Every single checkpoint should be closed hermetically. Let the Palestinians use all the money that the world is pouring in to build an independent economy instead of buying more and more arms and lining the pockets of its corrupt officials.
17.  HUMANITARIAN GESTURES FOR BEASTS
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (09.22.08)
I AM INCENCED AT THE INNADEQUACY OF PROTECTION AFFORDED ISRAELI SOLDIERS AT CHECK-POINTS.THIS YOUNG MAN HAS LOST AN EYE AND WILL LIVE WITH THE FACT TILL AT LEAST 120,THE PALESTINIAN AUTHORITY IS OBLIGED TO PAY COMPENSATION FOR THE DEVIOUSNESS OF ONE OF ITS CITIZENS, UNLESS THIS IS FORTHCOMING HUMANITARIAN GESTURES MUST BE CURTAILED . AND ISRAELI SOLDIERS MUST HAVE ADEQUATE PROTECTION TO SAFEGUARD THEMSELVES FROM SUCH INCIDENTS AS THEY HAVE NOW LEARNT THAT "HUMANITARIAN GESTURES"COULD COST THEM THEIR LIVES.
18. Really, Said?
Cameron ,   USA   (09.22.08)
Forgive the common error of assuming it was a rather large Bedlam, where dead-end pathology was being distilled and perfected.
19. Death on the spot for such a Terrorist
Brod ,   USA   (09.22.08)
The soldiers should defend themselves by shooting such a terrorist on the spot.. Blinding a person with acid is no different to murdering a person. Those female Islamist-Jihadists should be herded to a special room and stripped searched by armed female soldiers.
20. Fear not...Livni will release her next month
Dr. Dave ,   NYC   (09.22.08)
...As a gesture of "good will" to the moderate PA.
21. Navy doctor John Carlisle who was at NAS Miramar
Rivkah   (09.22.08)
(now MCAS) near San Diego in the late 2970's as a Flight Surgeon invented an eye wash helmet that flushes out the eyes immediately if that is needed from fluid in the helmet attachment. It got a lot of laughs; but considering the attacks on IDF at checkpoints, that helmet attachment could have saved the soldier's sight in the affected eye that acid was splashed on.
22. I sent a 'refua shlama' to the soldier
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (09.22.08)
I found the web site of the Rabin Medical Center and pressed Contact and sent an e-mail. Please do the same!
23. I say "An eye for an eye".
Stephanie ,   Israel   (09.22.08)
24. Soldier loses an eye
Ger ,   Raanana, Israel`   (09.22.08)
She will be eligible for early release as a goodwill gesture. After all, it was only her second attempt, and the soldier lost only one eye. Can't keep anyone in jail for that, can we?
25. A punishment for an eye.
David ,   Paris   (09.22.08)
That arab criminal must have her TWO EYES removed by the same exact procedure. Then, a long prison term.
26. All of a sudden, no btselem videos? WHY IS THAT?
Arie ,   BaGolan   (09.22.08)
27. ACID
LARRY ,   USA   (09.22.08)
not untill they israeli gov comes out of there shell and thinks israeli not bitting there nails worring about what the us dictates will this \end end arabs understand force weakness is all they see . world poinion does not matter if there is no israel in the future
28. an eye for an eye!
oded   (09.22.08)
she should be blinded as well to even the score!
29. How I long for the days of an eye for an eye. There was a
real sense of ,   justice then.   (09.22.08)
30. Where is machsom watch or betzelems comment on this???
b. moskowitz ,   chashmonaim, israel   (09.22.08)
Next talkbacks
Back to article