News
Prof. Sternhell: I'll continue to voice my views
Aviad Glickman
Published: 26.09.08, 16:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. We know what the French values are like
Dan ,   USA   (09.26.08)
They capitulated to Hitler in a matter of hours.
2. French FM Bernard Kouchner
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah   (09.26.08)
B"H French FM Bernard Kouchner should consider the nature of attacks on Jews in his country and not the nature of attacks in this country. He is French, not Israeli FM. This is one. Two, in order to have peace we need to win the war our enemies force on us, not to sell out our country, people, history and values as Sternhell advocates. There is nothing "right wing" about being Jewish and there is nothing "peacefull" about being a traitor.
3. Attack on the Professor
eli berkovits ,   kfar Saba   (09.26.08)
By what he writes and by what he represents, he appears to instigate attacks on Israel. He should not be surpsrzed . Shalom Achshav has other interests the Israel. They are well funded by enemies of Israel.
4. They let him out?
Ariel ,   Not there   (09.26.08)
Without checks being done in Mental Health Department? How truly outrageous!
5. To the Honourable Mr.Kouchner
Larry ,   zefat israel   (09.26.08)
Please mind your own business ,or as the Russians like to say:Who the @%#$ are YOU to Lecture US?
6. Some "Champagne" my Dear?
Gideon Reader   (09.26.08)
What has the criminal investigation progress shown to date, to disabuse me of the notion bolstered by past performance and history; of a "Champagne" style effort of an Agent Provocateur, other than the reflexive anti rightist general suggestions and allegations, so far unsuported by actual fact and evidence.
7. TBers on this thread...
Robert Gardner ,   Washington, DC   (09.26.08)
...are irresponsibly unreasonable. This attack IS an assault on peace (not to mention Sternhall's privacy) by some lunatic (whomever that may be) and by rationalizing it because of his political views, you are a HUGE part of the problem in this world. Read what Rav Kook had to say about harming another Jew...especially during the month of Elul...
8. Making a mountain of a molehill
Mike ,   Jerusalem   (09.26.08)
You are giving Sternhell more publicity than he deserves. He is out of teh hospital he is whole, has all his lombs, no lasting effects. Why don't you make such a tzimmes for the kids from Gush Latif who lost legas or the lawyer who lost a leg in the tractor attack? Why didn't you make such a big tzimmes over others that got maimed for life? This story has all the fingerprints of a leftist shabak planned operation. I feel bad that Sternhell was betrayed by his own and that the left sought fit to make a korban out of him. This incident will not silence him nor change his mind, so it would have been a waste for the extreme right to do this it is not to their benefit I bless Professor Sternhell with a full and speedy recovery and may this Rosh Hashana provide him with a ime of reflection to repent for calling for the murder of Jews. May Hashem have mercy upon him!
9. good advertising for a leftist has been, sounds no kosher
(09.26.08)
10. "Settlers" don't like him
(09.26.08)
Sternhell claims that "settlers" don't like him. Is this dislike for no reason? Is it because Sternhell has called for the violent extermination of the "settlers" using tanks? Or is it because he explicitly called for the Arabs to concentrate armed attacks against Jews East of the Green Line? Indeed it seems logical that "settlers" would dislike a man who supports the blinding of an Israeli soldier with acid, the stabbing of the 9 year old boy in Yizhar and supports the BMW attack in Jerusalem.
11. Violence begets violence
Ben ,   Gush Etzion   (09.26.08)
Those who call for violence against others usually end up as victims of violence. His call for violence against other Jews boomeranged and bit him on his tochas. No other leftist professors advocate violence against other Jews. He needs to do some soul searching. How would he have acted in the holocaust towards his fellow Jews whose opinions he disagreed with? Would he have sanctioned their being sent to Concentration Camps, ghettos and torture?
12. LEFTISTS WAKE UP !!!
Alon Frank ,   Beth Shemesh,Israel   (09.26.08)
The extreme rightwingers wouldn't waste it's time to kill or injure you. This is a setup by the leftists so they can continue to tell their lies to poor unaware jews and turn them into self haters. The goal of extreme right is to protect the land of Israel and not to kill it's citizens. want to bet that the extreme left did it?
13. Refuah sheleimah
Larry ,   zefat israel   (09.26.08)
Even though Mr.Schlemiel ,I mean Sternhell is a very nasty Man ,may he recover and repent for hating his fellow jews.We are all in the same Boat,so to speak.
14. Sorry this happened, I wish him a speedy recovery
Leah   (09.26.08)
In other news,which was not published by this newspaper. An 8 year old hero named Tovia who was stabbed 7 times in the back while confronting an armed terrorist who tried to burn down his neighbor's home was released from Schneiders Children's hospital today. I noticed in the article is says Peace Now has dedicated itself to an ideological struggle against violence and hate. Well,I think it would take a pretty hateful and violent person to try and burn down a family in their home while they slept or to try and knife an 8 year old boy to death. I sure hope this peace group will grow a backbone and condemn all violence even if it's against hateful,violent settlers like the 8 year old boy who ran to his neighbor's home to try and warn them that their home was on fire, and was almost stabbed to death in the process.
15.  The Jerusalem settlement will bring peace to the world
sam ,   USA   (09.26.08)
16. What a joke it all is
Kim ,   Israel   (09.26.08)
The extreme right wingers are not Jews. They are a joke. They are a bunch of lost losers who have nothing to say and no direction in life. They seem to think that attempted murder and infact murder is the only way to deal with getting their way. This just goes to show what a hopeless bunch of misfits they are. What happened to 'thou shalt not kill' ? If anyone gets in the way of their ideology, they try and kill them. What a bunch of sad nobodies they really are.
17. # 16 you are a Fool who knows nothing
larry ,   zefat   (09.26.08)
You are brainwashed and hateful.crawl back in to your hole.
18. # 16 The lost Loser is you
larry ,   zefat   (09.26.08)
You are the joke,Look in your Mirror.
19. Why does this man get a pass?
moriah ,   sacramento, USA   (09.26.08)
He has been inciting violence against "settlers" for years. He has given permission to kill Settlers by stating emphatically that Palestinian violence against Jews is justified. What do you call that , YNET, LOVE LETTERS? Accusations of the Rightwing being responsible is MERE SPECULATION! It is incitement without a shred of evidence.
20. Remember Arlozaroff
(09.26.08)
He was aledgedly killed by right wing Jews but history has shown that it was committed by Arabs. This seems like another left wing attack on the right before elections.
21. The Professor Looks Great Considering
Bill ,   US   (09.26.08)
he's in his 70s and just survived a targeted bombing. Is this the first production of Israeliwood?
22. #17,16 and you are the crooked mirror to look at
George ,   Canada   (09.26.08)
23. Israel is rthe only dimocracy in the Middle East.
George ,   Canada   (09.26.08)
make up your mind Mr settler,some say he is funded by Arabs other say killed by Arabs.
24. and I wish you a long life to do it in
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.27.08)
No matter how stupid, how vain, how moronic your actions are, I support your right to be a jack*ss. Too bad all you want to do is stifle all desent. Guess what stupid we are the majority and you are a petty little dictator type.
25. sternhell
gavriel ,   maoz zion   (09.27.08)
brilliant brains do not make a man great, but how you use them. sternhell seems to use his to agitate people to hate. "settlers" are not violant, they have to protect themselves against arabs
26. israel= democracy? very funny really...
ich ,   Deutschland   (10.06.08)
Israel defines itself like this: Israel is a democratic country and land of the Jews. According to what I know about democracy (correct me if am wrong) is that all citizens are equal and there is no difference and no discrimination everyone is EQUAL. How come it’s called the land of the Jews? Is that democracy? It’s just lies and normally simple people believe these things without investigating them. Try getting more info. About Israel and then say it’s democratic.... Because u have no idea what is Israel.
Back to article