News
Protestors support targeted Sternhell
Ronen Medzini
Published: 02.10.08, 21:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Too bad the other 99% of the population
jason white ,   afula,israel   (10.02.08)
does not hold a demo outside sternhell's house demanding that he and his kind be tried for aiding the enemy and inciting against Jews. And demanding that we have a death penalty for treason.
2. The Problems just might be caused by leftwing ideals
non thinking ,   in bad.   (10.02.08)
3. Dumb goes clear to the bone
Gideon Reader   (10.02.08)
The Left rallies for Herr Professor Sternhell? "Son, going through life fat and stupid aint no way to live." These bolsheviks have a crying NEED to rent a video of forrest Gump. They can then see what is meant by: Stupid is as stupid does.
4. M,P.CHAZAN, DO NOT TEMPT THE DEVIL
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (10.02.08)
SUCH ELLOQUENCE IS NOT NEEDE AT THIS PARTICULAR TIME.BESIDES HE IS SPREADING LOSHON HARA AGAINST THOSE OF THE RIGHT WHO ARE PREPARED TO ABIDE BY THE POPULARITY OF THE VOTE.WHO I BELIEVE ARE THE MAJORITY AND DON"T WANT TO SPLIT THE COUNTRY BETWEEN A GOVERNMENT,AND A GOVERNMENT IN EXILE.THER HAS BE3EN AMPLE OPPORTUNITY FOR MEMBERS OF THE RIGHT TO EXPRESS THEMSELVES WITH GREATER PHYSICAL FORCE AFTER THE WITHDRAWAL FROM "GUSH KATIF".THIS DIDN"T HAPPEN.THE LEFT IS TOO ALARMIST OVER THIS INCIDENT, PROPAGANDISING,AND TRYING TO MAKE CAPITAL OVER THE ISSUE.BECAUSE ONE PERSON HAS USED VIOLENT METHODS MUST BE EQUATED WITH THE BRUTE FORCE THAT RESIDENTS OF "GUSH KATIF" WERE EVICTED FROM THEIR HOMES.IT COULD BE CLAIMED AT THE TIME THAT ELEMENTS OF THE LEFT WERE ATTEMPTING TO SPLIT THE COUNTRY.BUT THIS DIDN"T OCCUR..I SUGGEST" LESS VERB ,LESS NERVE" AND LET THE INCIDENT SLIP BY FOR THE BENEFIT OF ALL
5. The Left's hands are dripping with blood
Jake   (10.02.08)
But they just got others to fight their battles for them, and do their dirty work. It is a great Mitzvah to expose their talebearing, their lies, their conspiracies, and above all, to defeat them in the forum of ideas and debate. The bankrupcy, emptiness, and wretchedness of their ideas are clear to me as never before. Mr. Sternhell, who is so full of self-importance, you have much to ask forgiveness for on this Yom Kippur. Show some humility, for a change.
6. Deport to gaza all machsom watch and neutri karta.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.02.08)
7. 150 out of 7 million! This is support? A joke article!!
redmike ,   Tel Aviv   (10.02.08)
I have added Ronen Medzini to my don't waste time reading list which now lists .. Ray Hanania, Sever Plocker, Ron Ben-Yishai, Nahum Barnea, Gideon Samet, Shmuel Gordon, Yoram Meital, Ronen Medzini. Do these people really get paid for writing what might kindly be called superficial garbage? If Ynet needs readers it must hire writers. Mike
8. 150 traitors support him
freejay ,   Israel   (10.02.08)
9. Talkbacks 1-8 are horrible
Awake   (10.03.08)
I'm amazed that you psychos actually believe the BS that you spew. These people desire peace and you call them traitors?! They're not the ones inciting violence, you twits. It's you right-wingers who are shedding Jewish blood moreso than Sternhall and those at this rally. It's your actions who have made Jewish blood less important than the dirt under your feet. It is you who are the traitors not only to your country by selling out to irrational thought and broken logic but you are traitors to your fellow Jews by being so willing to send them off to die for your future housing. And not their present homes. Yeah, such brave Zionists you guys are. Good job.
10. 150 ?! wow ! all his family came !
(10.03.08)
11. "Fortuitous" fast of Gedalia?
JPS ,   Efrat   (10.03.08)
Has Rabbi Gilad Kariv ever asked about Sternhell's articles encouraging the Palestinians to murder Kariv's fellow Jews. Just curious what the Israel Movement for Progressive Judaism has to say about the infamous Sternhell article in Ha'aretz. I hear the right wing and others calling for Sternhell to be tried for treason, but not to kill him. Sternhell, on the other hand, called on the Palestinians to come and kill me and my family. If Rabbi Kariv doesn't think Sternhell is a dangerous zealot, then there's the real trouble.
12. BIG question still unanswered
Arie ,   BaGolan   (10.03.08)
Did it really happen, or was it staged by the lefties to garner sympathy for their lost cause
13. Is Horrible really so bad?
Gideon Reader   (10.03.08)
Wassup Niner? Talkbacks 1-8 are horrible? So what? Not a thing to take all that seriously. There IS life after writing a talkback opinion, doncha know? Get a grip. Get a drink. Chill. It is NOT healthy to let your anti-Jewish brain farts let you slip into that bad and gloomy state of darkland of the mind. OK. You don't like; you hate Jews? So do many others. You are not the first silly and unaware fool to adopt such a childish and narrow viewpoint. You are a lefty? It is not the end of the world, but do not let it consume you, or,... it WILL consume you. And spit out the nasty bits, of which I precieve there are many. I believe you would not know a "right winger" if one bit you on the butt.
14. #6 "Deport to Gaza all machsom watch and neutri [sic] karta"
eric ,   jerusalem   (10.03.08)
What a novel idea! deport people opposed to your ideals... or did you get the idea from somewhere else?...
15. When people wrongly take the law into their own hands.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (10.03.08)
Sternhell wrote an article in Haaretz on May 11th, 2002, in which he called for Palestinians to carry out terror actions beyond the green line, which constitutes a clear case of incitement to murder. Indeed, this would be an appropriate time for Israel's law enforcement system to summon Sternhell and question him about his calls to violence which violate Israel's laws of incitement. The sad reality is that when the Israeli law enforcement system does not respond, people wrongly take the law into their own hands. About political correctness : http://xrl.us/bi5da
16. #13 - Braindead
Awake   (10.03.08)
See, here's more of the typical BS that the Right loves to drop. Such inept scramblings by a turd who could not be bothered to read my post and actually try and create a valid counterpoint. Instead, he tries to play up some emotional BS about Jew hate despite the fact that my ire was directed not at Jews but at those who would gladly bite my ass, according to Gideon Reader. Oh typically inept, waste of time space and sperm, who instead of being aware of his own causes for destruction towards Jews and non-Jews alike, can do nothing but curl up into his feeble little fetal position and cry "Jew hater!" because he's too much of a retard to actually hold a valid discussion. Yeah, I'll let that "consume" me. If it means forcing a retard (Along the lines of Gideon Reader but hopefully someone with a brain cell to exercise) to actually defend their position and maybe come to grips with reality, then that is a noble cause worth working towards.
17. And the million dollar question is
Meir Weinstein ,   Toronto, Canada   (10.03.08)
Who did it? The police have not caught the person or persons responsible. Was it a set up or was it not. Who knows. But we do know about the Arab Terrorist that stabbed the 9 Year old Jewish boy on a settlement. Where is the out cry? What is going on here?
18. #9 - Neville Chamberlain also said, "peace in our time".
redmike ,   Tel Aviv   (10.03.08)
The really silly thing about the article is that because only 150 people protested, the demonstration was a complete failure. The major FACT that many well meaning people fail to grasp is that there is NO chance of peace with Arabs in the foreseeable future - NONE. Do you think that you and the jokers in Meretz can cozy up to Hamas? Please answer the above with a 'yes' or a 'no' and without waffle. The only kind of peace that Abbas might be able to deliver would be a piece of pizza. Peace would be great but anybody who believes that it's possible in the foreseeable future needs to take a reality check. Mike
19. No...misquoting is misleading!
rachel ,   chutz4now   (10.03.08)
The Fast of Gedalia is the only Jewish holy day that does not center on foreign enemies"....Nooooo What about the time between Pesach and Lag B'Omer...you know the sinat chinam thing? every child knows this.
20. Typical Leftist Tactics
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (10.03.08)
1. Act hysterically. 2. Demonize the Right. All else is commentary.
21. Do these demonstraors also demonstrate
Michael   (10.03.08)
when men and women are wounded by arabs or by a mafia hit that goes bad ? If not, than these people need a lot of soul searching. To pick and choose whose life is worth protecting is a very dangerous type of thinking. Professors and layman both have the right to live. To differentiate between people s' lives based on politics puts the demonstators on the same immoral level as the ones who planted the bomb.
22. Sternhell supporters
Oskar Prager ,   Petach Tikva   (10.03.08)
As I wrote before, the pipe bomb was placed in my opinion by agent provocateurs of the Shin Bet with the help and advise of all Left wingers who would simply hate that the right wingers and Netanyahu would win the next general election. Thus I blame Sterhell's supporters for the action, and to punish them for what they did, send them all to Gaza to live among their beloved friends.
23. Resistance and the Left!!
szamuel ,   budapest   (10.03.08)
The leftists for years have referred to every atrocity by Arab terrorists against Jews as "resistance," so why are they not describing the attack on Sternhell, possible by someone on the Israeli Right, as resistance to the hegemony of the Left in Israel?
Back to article