Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
Sukkot strife in Meah Shearim over modesty    Neta Sela
1. Miriam, is this a result of the decadent secular education?
I thought that this sort of thing never happened when one received a religious education.
Aharon   (10.20.08)
2. Ehm... Acutally, Messiah has never been so far away...
It is said that Messiah will come when good deeds will be many. So, by multiplying good deeds we draw Messiah closer. This is exactly the opposite. We are invoking the rise of Amalek, the new shoa and, G-d forbid, new destruction of Israel.
John ,   Europe   (10.20.08)
3. WOW -- I can just imagine the future...
As fast as the haredim are growing in numbers, through high natural birthrate and immigration from abroad, I can only imagine how they will treat the rest of us sinners who don't dress like our ancestors of hundreds of years ago. These Meah Sharim people hate their own, imagine their hatred of the "goyim" in Tel Aviv and their not Jewish enough citizens throughout the country. And then people wonder why the rest of the country doesn't want haredim infiltrating into their neighborhoods!!!
Aviv Benedix ,   Jerus. -- soon T.A.   (10.20.08)
4. Meshigeh!
Shulem   (10.20.08)
5. Once again the religious light the way for everyone else
Such fine examples they are.
amnon   (10.20.08)
6. And they want people to become religious - like them!!
This only serves to turn people off to becoming religious.
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (10.20.08)
7. Jews Should Be Fighting Arabs Instead of Each Other
Ben ,   Canada   (10.20.08)
8. I tell you they behave just like goyim
Or worst still they behave like hilonim and that is just not cricket.
Roni ,   Bat Galim   (10.20.08)
9. How my heart longs for the Land.
And Jews throughout the world sigh and shake their heads. They wonder why all the criticism from their brothers in Eretz Israel because no one wants to make Aliyah. What an embarassment when others ask: are these your people? This must make HaShem very sad and very angry. Will HaEretz once again vomit?
David ,   USA   (10.20.08)
10. What have we become?
The extreme subordination of women by these religious fanatics is deeply concerning. What are we becoming - Islamic fundamentalists??? Never in our history have women been so demeaned and forcibly segregated. This goes against the essence of Judaism and the rabbis from these communities should intervene immediately. We are a cilivised people - start acting like it!!!
Tanya ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.20.08)
11. HaShem must have cried millions of tears over this.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.20.08)
12. The festival is HaShem's - these people blaspheme
This is a time of joyous celebration - around the Torah which was given freely to all the Jewish people - what a way for these people to be entered into the Books of Life and Death
Russel ,   Tlv   (10.20.08)
13. To#8 Roni
I am one of those "hilonim" married to one of those "goyim". There are no orthodox Jews, nor devout Muslims and very few Christian zealots in this liberal town. We all pretty much treat each other with respect and exchange pleasantries when we pass on the streets. Is it possible that the Haredim in the Mea Shearim quarter could actually be acting like " the Haredim that they are? Just wondering....
Mike ,   USA   (10.20.08)
14. Antisemitism and Jewish Suffering
This behavior is not new. It is, however, sadly, a fundamental component of Jewish suffering. While they make meaningless noise, and cause a meaningless distractions, the enemy plots. They need to be contained before they cause additional suffering.
shrinkDave ,   Miami USA   (10.21.08)
15. I hope this won't stop those considering aliyah
This type of meshugas is limited to the cloistered ultra-orthodox neighborhoods. (Other meshugas exists in Israel, but still better than the Galut). We NEED sane Orthodox and non-Orthodox aliyah. Come, it really is awesome here!
Vered, Israel   (10.21.08)
16. Roni , 8 , they act as "religious" fanatics
They behave in the same way that we have already seen so many times . Did you forget those hatefull faces throwing stones at police officers ? do you forget the quantity of cars stoned ? Well , this is the behaviour of a part of the "charidim" , not true believers for me .
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.21.08)
17. Power corrupts!
vered ,   israel   (10.21.08)
18. Does the name Hirsch ring a bell?
Could this be the same Hirsch family as Moshe Hirsch Arafat's Jewish Minister in the PA? If so , can a Hirsch be a credible source?
Meir ,   Beit Shemesh   (10.21.08)
19. Police action necessary
The police should step in in force. Bust some shtreimels already. The religious give Israel a bad name and they are worse than the arabs. Any Charedi that acts this way should have his house bulldozed. I am just as Jewish as them and know what I am talking about. They have no Jewish values and keep up these worthless antiquated customs that have nothing to do with being Jewish. Get rid of them.
Ron Morris   (10.21.08)
20. Too much time on their hands
If they had real jobs then they wouldn't have the energy for this nonsense. If they did the army, then they wouldn't be so into senseless violence.
Ron Morris   (10.21.08)
21. Too bad they don't have jobs
If these guys had to work to support themselves and their families, instead of receiving welfare payments from law abiding and hard working Israeli taxpayers, they would have a lot less time and energy for fighting. They might also view women more as human beings with minds and feelings rather than as as temptresses and the source of sin to be either scorned or avoided.
Ken Besig ,   Israel   (10.21.08)
22. #7 Ben - Jews should live in Israel
So will you be making aliah and joining the IDF?
Simon ,   TA Israel   (10.22.08)
23. #21 Amen Brother !
Exactly !
Simon ,   TA Israel   (10.22.08)
24.  Ladies.Say thank you to ynet
for warning female talkbackers addicted to100 shearim to stay away.
o mama   (10.22.08)
25. animals
Isn't it time we stop the nonsensical and totally arbitrary insistence that there's a pubic hair's worth of difference between these freaks and the taliban? This has nothing to do with authentic Judaism, and the time has come for mainstream Jews to acknowledge that fact. Here's what we should do: we should throw representatives of the Black Hebrews from Miami and the Jews for Jesus in the ring with these freaks for a Texas cage match, and we can give the winner a certificate that allows them to pretend they're real Jews for a month at a time.
david ,   new york, USA   (10.24.08)
26. JESUSALEN
JESUSALEN.go to your people.say to them,you will hear but never understand.you will see but never know what you are seeing.these people“s heart have become stubborn.they can barely hear with their ears.they have closed their eyes.OTHERWISE THEY MIGHT SEE WITH THEIR EYES.THEY MIGHT HEAR WITH THEIR EARS.THEY MIGHT UNDERSTAND WITH THEIR HEARTS.THEY MIGHT TURN,AND THEN I WOULD HEAL THEM (isaiah 6:9-10).
cristian ,   bs as arg   (10.28.08)
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks