Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
'Assad ready for peace, if he gets what he wants'    Roee Nahmias
1. That's why he built a NUCLEAR reactor, you idiot!
Barbara   (11.17.08)
2. Sack Amos Yadlin
Zion   (11.17.08)
3. That's what they said before Yom Kippur War.
Anybody remember that one?
Yacov ,   Chicago   (11.17.08)
4. The dude must be removed at once
He should work as a chief in a restoran -- if somebody hires him. Where did you get those guys?
Gerry ,   Boston   (11.17.08)
5. AMAN IS THE WEAK PART OF THE ISRAELI INTEL COMMUNITY
(11.17.08)
6. this guy is a joke ! remember MI job in 1973 ?!
(11.17.08)
7. What Syria wants and what Assad wants are 2 different things
Any agreement signed with Assad will be worthless when he gets ousted from power (I personally believe it will be worthless even while Assad is STILL in power). Peace with Assad is not peace with Syria because what Assad wants and what Syria wants are two completely different things. Assad wants to stay in power and Syria wants to oust him from power. Mark my words, the Golan is just the first of many demands Syria will make of us in the decades to come. Giving up tangibles like land for intangibles like peace is a bargain only a fool would consider...
Joe ,   Ramat Gan   (11.17.08)
8. Just like hitler - This is called Military INTELLIGENCE?
Fran   (11.17.08)
9. I was there in '73 and do remember
The same stupid statements were made then and are as valid today as they were 35 years ago. Sack the idiot already.
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (11.18.08)
10. Assad is ready?
We already have Golan Heights and there is a peace and quiet on Syrian border. We have what we want. Who cares about what Assad wants?
Boruch ,   Golan, Israel   (11.17.08)
11. "I have a dream that arabs are ready for peace." What BS!!!
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (11.18.08)
12. More crap
Assad the new peace partner of the Left will prove to be like Arafat. Even Egypt will become hostile again because the Islamist ideology is transforming the country and Israel will have to fight in a desperate position because of Leftist idiots.
Frank ,   Canada   (11.18.08)
13. Tendencies to delusion, wishful thinking.
Can Israel overcome its own dangerous tendencies to delusion, wishful thinking, and appeasement that have been encouraged by its mostly incompetent leaders since 1992. In March 2006 Israelis, after all, elected the incompetent government they now so lament being saddled with. The fortitude of the Israeli army and citizenry during last summer's Lebanon war showed the other side of the Israeli psyche, which remains strong, tough, and determined. Israel will not cope well with the military and terrorist dangers it faces until and unless this government is removed and replaced by people who understand the Middle East, security, and world politics and are capable of coherent and effective action. We should be prepared to any eventuality : http://xrl.us/bi5de
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (11.18.08)
14. Syrian president Assad is neither willing nor able to ...
Syrian president Assad is neither willing nor able to give Israel genuine peace. Syria has demonstrated no moderating of its alliance with Iran, its support for Hezbollah, Hamas, and other terror organizations, its aggressive designs against Lebanon, or its dedication to Israel’s destruction. This as there are myriad reasons why Syrian president Assad is neither willing nor able to give Israel genuine peace. This as the Golan Heights controls Israel’s major source of fresh water. In addition, the Heights are perhaps the most strategic piece of real estate in the Middle East and, despite overly sanguine claims by some Israeli military officers and others, Israel has no way of compensating for the strategic damage that its surrender would entail. (Nor can Israel create an equivalent of the 100 mile wide demilitarized zone that has existed between Israel and Egypt since the Camp David agreements.) This also as Israel has an excellent claim to permanent sovereignty over the Golan Heights on the basis of international law and precedent. More about the dangers of abandoning the Golan Hights at : http://xrl.us/bmazn
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (11.18.08)
15. "palestinian moderates"?
the "palestinian moderates" are NOT fatah or hamas, but those who were never affiliated with any terrorist group, and who therefore have never been able to play a role in palestinian politics. the only way to escape from the seemingly inevitable creation of two new states, "of the terrorists, for the terrorists, by the terrorists", is to hold to the moral principles of not dealing with terrorists, rather than the immorality of the present government, where everything is negotiable. it is rather disturbing to see the head of military intelligence present such a deluded misrepresentation of the situation.
tom ,   toronto, canada   (11.18.08)
16. what iran wants
even though this assessment was delivered "for public consumption", it fails to deal seriously with iranian intentions. iran's behaviour cannot be explained with the idea of "testing", but rather "provocation" - bragging about weapons which they don't yet have. and "deterrence" only works against an opponent who hopes to win; iran seems determined to start a war and lose, so yadlin's "deterrence" will only backfire. instead of relying on military "deterrence", israel's goal should be regime change in tehran.
tom ,   toronto, canada   (11.18.08)
17. #9 I was there in 73 too
I was there also sounds familar.
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (11.18.08)
18. Compare Golen Heights to Sinai no not possible RIGHT ???
i realize Assad may blow all he wants to but the brick walls of brick layer America Caucasian Pig no not going to be blown in meaning translation no not return of Golen Heights to assad no not today January 2009 and or ever EVER E V E R ??? get the message Assad DUMKOPF DUMKOPH NIEN ??? N I E N ??? of course they would DENY IT OF COURSE ??? alas though Assad is paid to ask and ask and ask ask all you want to Assad exactly same answer NOOOOOO NEVER NIENNNNNNNN ??? of course I hope this message makes Assad Syria Arabs so mad they attack Israel RIGHT ??? Thank you... M. S.
M. S. ,   mpls america   (11.18.08)
19. I will like to try what this guy just smoked
Moshe   (11.18.08)
20. u really think its still isreal time ??
i dont believe that u still believe that isreal has the power to do anything??i think isreal could fight hamas in gaza sothing small lol..the thing what u didn't realize the middle east is changed that what ur army know and so ur goverment..do not balme the army coz this is the truth
saher ,   palestine   (11.18.08)
21. Is this guy Meshugah?
He sounds like a complete crazy man....where did he come from....never heard of him! Maybe a relative of Olmert or Peres? What is even more amazing, is why is YNet putting so many of these ridiculous leftist articles up?
JAy3 ,   Israel   (11.18.08)
22. YADLIN HERO OR TRAITOR?
Yadlin it is embarassing that you among many who have served your contry well when you yourself have bombed the Iraq Reactor got so corrupted that you dont want to admit that wars are comming. I hate to see a hero like you to become one of those traitors like Olmert and Livni. Please join me and others at the new blog in which you can make your voice heard without censoring. You can comment, suggest, vote. Tell everyone about this blog. http://israelactnow.blogspot.com/
Jewish Refugee ,   U.S.A.   (11.18.08)
23. Obama's idea of putting pressure on Iran is to
turn tail and run for the United States border, with the United States military. He is a pascifist. The entire Democratic party is a bunch of pascifists. They hate oil companies....gun owners....and anyone consuming meat or wearing fur, or leather coats. They can't manage to fight for a childs life.......how will they save Israel from Iran. When you don't care about children's lives.......what the heck do you really think is worth saving? Obviously it isn't the Jews. Sad but true. This guy ran on a get the troops out of Iraq campaign. Then the economy tanked. He changed the campaign to a, save the poor little americans from the banking fiasco. This guy inherited a mess he can't deal with anymore than the Republicans could. He isn't anyones saviour. He's just another cat spinning news and financial numbers, to confuse the world at large. You can't fix a problem that is bigger than the world's Gross Domestic Product. Dirivative Obama. Selling us out to make the world feel better. He's the world's new psychiatrist. Do you feel better already?
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (11.18.08)
24. There are not much Inteligence in his statements.
Asher ,   NY,USA   (11.18.08)
25. Yadlin
B"H Another general without kippah and without G-d, another general with an extreme-left political agenda. He clearly is a danger to the Jews. To Jewish Jews, that is.
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah   (11.18.08)
26. Syria ready ...
Seems we have all heard the absurd before in this regard. Syria will give us peace just as we have a "truce" in Gaza. Syria will continue to support Hizbullah, strengthen ties with Iran, control Lebanon, sponsor terror while Israel is pressured to make all the concessions. Nothing changes
DT ,   TA Isr   (11.18.08)
27. Intelligence? Delusion and negligence!
Yadlin has swallowed taqiyya whole. This is the same foolishness that preceded the nearly disasterous 1973 Yom Kippur War. Here are some points to consider: Syria and Iran recently pronounced their alliance as unshakable. The Syrians possess large quantities of nerve gas smuggled in the waning days of Saddam's Iraq. (That is obviously not for peaceful purposes.) 4 divisions of Syrian forces line the entire border with Lebanon to the Israeli border. The Syrian 4th Division is stationed along Lebanon’s northern border and the 10th, 12th and 14th Divisions are posted along Lebanon’s eastern frontier opposite the Hermil mountains and the Beqaa Valley, down to the Hermon Mountains facing South Lebanon and northern Israel. Syrian army intelligence has occupied abandoned buildings in Kuneitra. Hizballah has be rearmed thanks to Iran and its sock puppet, Syria. Syria continues to house Hamas and other Palestinian terror leaders. Syria is about to arm itself with a "missile shield" from Russia, not to mention the purchase of a large amount of Russian heavy armaments. (Against which the ever-delusional Olmert abased himself and Israel by groveling before the Russians, begging Putin not to send such arms.) As for "moderate" Palestinians: Abu Mazen continues his "slow jihad" 2-step with the gullible West and wishful-thinking Israelis, while pronouncing his commitment to destroying Israel in his Arabic tirades. The PA media, especially their TV, continue to broadcast inciteful programs against Israel and the Jews. The newspapers abound with anti-Israel, anti-Jewish editorials, cartoons and drawings. The PA "Pallywood" propaganda machine churns out accusations and libels against "settlers" (well, they consider all Israelis to be "settlers") and the IDF. The PA educational system continues to use textbooks saturated with anti-Israel material - even in math textbooks. This is not how you educate the next generation for peace. Yadlin is one more of a sorry bunch of misinformed individuals in Israel's political and military echelons. Their blindness will, at some point, force ordinary Israeli citizens to pay with their lives.
Laura ,   Israel   (11.18.08)
28. IDF Chief of Unintelligence Yadlin.
This is what you get when promotions are based on politics rather than military competence. Wishful thinking replaces objective & sound analysis.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (11.18.08)
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks