Jewish Scene
Child circumcision to be banned in Denmark?
Yigal Rom
Published: 20.11.08, 10:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
107 Talkbacks for this article
1. CIRUMCISION IS BEST FOR MALES & THEIR FEMALE MATES BECAUSE:
MOSHE ,   US   (11.20.08)
THE BRIT PREVENTS : 1 ) PHIMOSIS ( TIGHTENING OF THE FORESKIN WHICH CANNOT BE DRAWN BACK ) 2 ) BALANITIS ( INFLAMMATION ) 3 ) CANCER ( NO CASES REPORTED WHEREAS A SIGNIFICANT OCCURRENCE EXISTS FOR THE UNCIRCUMSISED ) 4 ) MAKING A LOW INCIDENCE OF CERVICAL CANCER IN JEWISH WOMEN ACCORDING TO " THE JEWISH CONNECTION " BY M. HIRSH GOLDBERG ( A BANTAM BOOK, STEIN & DAY PUBLISHERS, DECEMBER 1977, PAGE 185 ) MOSHE
2. If they do bring this in...
Juan ,   Spain   (11.20.08)
... either make aliyah or pop over to Israel for a visit with baby boy.
3. A primative barbaric practice shoule be illegal
judge jew-dy ,   Ramat HaSharon   (11.20.08)
Circumcision is a crude primitive barbaric practice and should be made illegal. Did anyone ask that child if he wants to be mutilated? Whats wrong with a symbolic pin prick to symbolize the covenant between man and God for those who actually believe such nonsense. "And God said to Avraham" yeh what ever , and The three bears said "whose been sleeping in my bed" so what. if that child wishes to do so at a legal age then thats his choice.
4. to #3 judge?
Marcelo ,   Eurabia   (11.20.08)
and what is your problem that people decide what to do instead of prohibiting with a law? if you are not circuncised because your lefty ideas, it is your problem. Next step: prohibition of candle lights on shabat and festivals due to "CO2" emissions....
5. judge jew-dy #3
AW ,   Jerusalem   (11.20.08)
You are a classic example of todays shallow pop culture. You are the society who compares the Bible to the Goldilocks, Shakespeare to The Big Brother and Mozart to Britney Spears. You have no understanding of people living a life by a deep philosophical belief...u simply cannot fathom it... I assume you have a TV at home and i assume your kids watch it, probably quite abit. Did they ask to be brought up in this populist and rotten TV culture or did u decide that for them. judge, if i were u I would be more worried about the brainwashing mutilation of the mind that you force upon your kids without either them or u knwing why....
6. This wasn't aimed at Jews .....
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (11.20.08)
The real target are the Muslim immigrants in Denmark who are making themselves less than popular - this is just to make Denmark less attractive to Muslims & perhaps (hopefully) encourage some to leave. Unfortunately, the Danes can't make the law apply only to Muslims. I'm sure the next idea will be to ban Hallel slaughter, which will also affect Jews who keep Kosher.
7. #3 - Boy, are you an extremist.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (11.20.08)
What is so barbaric about circumcision? At 8 days old, as is our custom, the infant doesn't know a thing. But, circumcision at 15 years old, now that's a bit traumatic. Arabs circumcise much later, often as old as 8-10 years old & I think that's psychologically damaging. Circumcision has definite health benefits re: cervical cancer & even the spread of AIDS. But even without any health benefits, it is part of our religious tradition - I'm secular but I don't hate my heritage as you seem to do. Just out of curiosity, do you also feel that body piercing & tatoos are barbaric?
8. CUT is a cut
bjarne andreasson ,   indonesia   (11.20.08)
The danish people live in a democrati and if We blue eyes want that cirumcision first when a boy is 15 years old is just bad for people and special the muslim .-) Danish people love the jewis but the not the muslim
9. To # # Judge Jew dy
Leah ,   Israel   (11.20.08)
Are you a man or woman, perhaps that is your problem. You dont know.
10. #3
Orian Benoit ,   Brussels, Belgium   (11.20.08)
Ask people whom made circumcision after 15! It's very painful and can create unfortunate side affects! BTW many men have this operation without any connection to jewerly, by medical reasons. Are U suffer personally?
11. typical leftistS
JACOBO   (11.20.08)
and this is who our liberal intelligentzia embrace. ANTI- SEMITIC LEFTITS YES TO MERETZ, ARABS & LABOR PARTY. OOPS DID I SAY ARABS? MOST OF THEM ARE CIRCUMSID TOO. WHAT WILL THE LEFTISTS DO? OK, WE'LL ALLOW CERTAIN MINORITIES TO DO IT AT 13!!!!
12. Terry missing the point
DM ,   Amsterdam   (11.20.08)
If I would tattoo my 8 day old child that would be barbaric, yes? But do not forsake the mitzvot, brit mila is the only reason why we are currently living in the land of Israel. The Arabs have had their reward for their covenant with G'd by letting them rule over the land for more than 1400 years. In fact they still rule over a large part of the land including Josephs tomb, Har Moriah and partly the Machpela. If we forsake ALL of the mitzvoth we will lose everything.
13. Not surprised
Arielush ,   Ramat Ha Golan   (11.20.08)
I'm not surprised. Circumcision has been controversial in these so called leftest circles for years. Thirty years ago I was living in Newcastle and a health visitor told me off for having my son circumcised. I quote "Are you aware of what you did to your son. This practice is shameful and primitive. Only primitive barbarians do such things to their children."
14. Circumcision in Denmark
Yiannis Kareklas ,   Athens Greece   (11.20.08)
Danes have to know that Abraham ( the man from the Bible) was circumcised when he was 77 years old. Of course this did not affect his wife : she couldn't care less ( she had a dildo complete with batteries).Now circumcising an 8 day old baby , I believe that the parents should wait for the baby to learn to say yes and no to get his approval.
15. LEAVE DENMARK
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (11.20.08)
Come to Israel. Why they are there I have no idea.
16. In Denmark, Circumcisions are not good for JENSEN.
Alan ,   SA   (11.20.08)
17. The practise is barbaric
Israeli   (11.20.08)
18. PROTESTANTS CIRCUMCISE TOO - WHO STARTED THIS DUMB THING??
andrew ,   miami,fl   (11.20.08)
19.  Abraham was not 8 days
Shlomo   (11.20.08)
Old when he cut his prick. And when he did it, he was old enough to make that decision for himself. So every man should do it at the age Abraham did, by then it is hardly in use
20. Denmark's Chief Rabbi
Joseph ,   Israel   (11.20.08)
Rabbi Lexner says that Jews will have to leave the place where they have lived hundred of years. Is this a surprise to him? For the past 2000 years other nations have made it clear: Jews are welcome nowhere except in their homeland Israel.
21. #12 minor correction
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (11.20.08)
Just a correction of your history. The Arabs did not rule Israel for more than 1400 years, that is just a myth spread by anti-Israel propagandists. The Arabs ruled Israel for only a short time after they stole it from the natives around 635 CE. For the next 1300 years Israel was ruled by many different nations including Christians and Muslims. Most of the Muslims were non-Arabs, especially Turkish people.
22. #7 Terry, Eilat
Said ,   London, UK   (11.20.08)
Most Muslim societies cirumcise their sons at around the same time that Jews do, when they're babies. Not sure though if it has to be on the 8th day. I've only ever heard of Yemen circumcising their sons at the age of 13-14, i.e. when the boy reaches puberty.
23. EXCELLENT !!! Jews Come Back Here.
avi   (11.20.08)
Take this as a WARNING, a peaceful warning before it might turn more aggressive, quit this mind controlled country, maybe, hurry ...
24. Protestants don't circumcise, and it should be illegal
Bethany   (11.20.08)
A symbolic pinprick should be done for babies and then they can choose at 15 if they wish to be circumcised or not. A child should have a choice about their religion. To Andrew, Christians do NOT circumcise.
25. All this talk about sharp instruments and foreskins...
Erastus CoupeDeVille ,   Ong' Hat, NJ   (11.20.08)
makes me cross my legs.
26. #21 learn your history
bob ,   potomac usa   (11.20.08)
The Arabs did NOT invade in the year 634 (without invitation) and steal the land from the natives (most of whom were still Jewish and Samaritan) . It was 634 Learn your history (tsk tsk) Israel was the first country invaded by jihad murderers (after Arabia itself). that's why we piss them off so much.
27. Terry is wrong again in everything he says about Arabs
Palestinian   (11.20.08)
Arabs, in fact, Muslim Arabs circumcise during the first couple of weeks of the child's birth at worst. Many people do it the first week though. I do not know where do you keep coming up with this nonsense about Arabs. Christian Arabs do not circumcise , but some choose to do it too. Muslims that are not Arabs in Turkey for example, circumcise at an age of 5 years or so. Myself, I have been taken care of during the first week of my birth ;)
28. Mohammed and Jesus were both Circumcised
rh ,   Modiin Israel   (11.20.08)
I am sure I read that in a cartoon somewhere.
29. I think they are targeting the Muslims with this law.
Sami ,   Atlanta, USA   (11.20.08)
30. halarious-i think i m a mind reader.
(11.20.08)
i was sure this issue would come up soon in europe-i just expected it to be in Haag or some other ultra liberal place-netherlands, or some other blond country-but never in denmark. Strange-considering how they acted in shoa....dissapointing. ignorance is bliss when u think u r spreading goodness in the name of it
Next talkbacks
Back to article