News
Yaalon: For Arabs we're all settlers
Amnon Meranda
Published: 22.11.08, 22:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
43 Talkbacks for this article
31. #5
Dani' El ,   SF USA   (11.23.08)
Maybe you have no problem with dhimmi Jews, but I DO! No more second class status for us in the Jewish homeland. We will rule ourselves. Problem is, you cannot stomach that. So out you go if you cannot live in peace in Israel. Why not go and "settle" in Saudi Arabia? Oh yeah, they don't want you either.
32. To all the Arabs living on the Land of Israel !
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (11.23.08)
'This is OUR COUNTRY, OUR LAND, : We are the legitimate owner of this land. Once you are done complaining, whining, and griping about Our Flag, Our Pledge, Our Anthem, or Our Way of Life, I highly encourage you take advantage of one other great Israeli freedom :'THE RIGHT TO LEAVE'. If you aren't happy here then LEAVE. The Arab occupation has lasted long enough. We didn't force you to come here. The Land of Israel is the land of the Jews as explained at: http://xrl.us/bi5c6
33. The Arab minority in Israel.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (11.23.08)
Israeli Arabs are not Israeli, and how could they be? Israel is a name set aside for the people of Israel. Arabs who live here can be called "Arabs with citizenship of the State of Israel", but they are certainly not 'Israelis'. Ask them and they will tell you the same thing. Israel is the country that we have built. We the Jews, the Children of Israel, have returned to our land and have built a prosperous and healthy country in which Torah flourishes alongside advanced farming, life-saving medicine and computers. As to the Arabs living in Israel consult the declaration of the US congress in 1922 : http://xrl.us/ou89o
34. Everybody knows you are settlers & occupiers
GD ,   USA   (11.23.08)
Jews were less than 5% of the people and owned less than 2% of the land in Palestine in the 1930.
35. #5
(11.23.08)
you arabs claim that you "had no problem with the native palestinian jews before israel was born????? HOW DARE YOU LIE LIKE THIS! you surely created many problems for the native palestinian jews before 1948. does haj amin al husseini ring a bell? does husseini invoilvment with hitler for the final solution to the middle east jews ring a bell? does the hebron massacre in 1929 where you arabs slaughtered jews un mass ring a bell? does the many riots by arabs who killed jews and rabbis in jerusalem prior to 1948 ring a bell? does the hanging, murder and terror on the jewish yeshuv prior to 1948 ring a bell? does the 7 arab army war against israel ring a bell? do terrorists attacks by marauding bedouin and arab clans against jerusalem jews prior in the 20's, 30's 40's where you tried to starve the jews of jerusalem that have lived there for centuries ring a bell? does the fact that jerusalem was full of palestinian jews living there for centuries (80,000 jews to only thousands of arabs at that time where the jews were a majority in jerusalem) and you tried to starve them by attacking jewish food trucks on the way to jerusalem, burning jewish synagogues, rioting in jewish neighborhoods and killing jews on order from your haj amin al husseini ring a bell??? please stop your historical lies and untruths. we have the historical evidence to show you that you are liars and bigots.
36. #5 additionally
(11.23.08)
when you say that most jews that live now in israel are from russia, europe, etc.. and not from the arabian countries, YOU ARE WRONG! again, 70% of israelis living now in israel are the DESCENDANTS OF THE JEWS IN ARAB LANDS LIKE YEMEN, EGYPT, SYRIA, LEBANON, JORDAN, IRAQ, OMAN, ALGERIA, TUNISIA, ETC... that the arab leaders EXPELLED form all arab cpountries. these jews lived in these arab countries in fear, in poverty, without rights and as fearful dihimis. your leaders expelled them after israel was born in 1948 in anger and anjustness. they expelled them and stole everything from them and threw them out without a penny. the arab leaders confiscated all their property, bank accounts, treasures, furniture, houses, businesses and threw them out. they came to israel and were taken care of, not like you arabs putting the palestinian in dirty refugee camps and denying them citizenship and using them as pawns in your battle against the jewish state. 70% of israeli citizens today are descendants of these jews who were expelled from your arab lands by your arab leaders. so, don't lie and say that only european jews and russian, whatever are the majority in israel because it is simply a lie and you know it. look at the native statistics and you will realize that 70% of israelis have originated in arab lands from which you expelled them.
37. #16
(11.23.08)
sir from natzeret, i agree with you partially here. yes, i do believe that some of you would like to ciexist in peace and harmony. however, the arab parties you choose to represent your communities, citizenship and interests in the knesset are working 100% against arab interests. they are fomenting dissent, hatered, they are not encouraging coexistance, but separatism. they compali and encite you to rebel and revolt. they are a problem to you more than they help you. they do not have your best interests at heart.
38. #17
(11.23.08)
arabs like you have always operated under dellusional principles. the distance between reality and fantasy in the arab world is very very minute. this is why, dellusional as you arab are, you never were able to win wars, to exterminate us jews and to cause israel to dismantle. there will never be a one state solution because it will never be in our interests. israeli interests and security rules as a number one factor in debates and conditions and negotiation. do not play games with us. do not piush too much because you know that while we unleasehd only 5% of our power against you in 2006, we will be forced to unleash 100% and give you a big slap on your cheek habibi. do not play with the iaf or idf. we will do what is good for us first and them may consider your needs. forget annihilating us, forget the one state solution. forget all this because your dellusion is very far from the reality on the ground. we do not need your patience and we will take our time without haste to ensure our country and citizenry is safe, secure and protected. what you want is not a priority for us. what we need is. so, while you obey nasrallah, we obay our intelligence, preparation and incredible brain to make sure your nefarious plans for a one state solution is 100% garbage. as we say in hebrew CHARA! kaka poopooo.
39. #5 - please take a look at US history and your own
redmike ,   tel aviv   (11.23.08)
I'm sure that I don't need to explain US history and to put it into your context. You are not and never were a Palestinian and you know it and the question of 'who am I?" never arose until after the 67 war. Were you Jordanian or Egyptian before that? Do you want the WB returned to Jordan or Gaza to Egypt? Israel would love to return Gaza and Jordan doesn't want its displaced Arabs returned to it. Jewish history in the area is documented and you only have a problem with 'new Jews' coming here. People emigrate to countries all over the world. Only 30% of Angelinos are white now and the immigrants dominate political decisions there. How would you like to see the situation resolved? Mike
40. right to an independent Jewish state
observer   (11.23.08)
>>Right of Return which only is a right for Jews ! >>Family reunification laws= which denies Palestinian Families to live together with their loved Israeli owns >>Present absentees = internally displaced Palestinians (who are today Israeli citizens) who are not allowed to live and go back to their original homes they were forced to flee in 1948 >>the fact that land in Israel is controlled by the Jewish National Found in which its constitutions is written that no Land of Israel is allowed to be sold to non Jews !
41. The Arabs are smarter than Jews
Harry ,   USA   (11.23.08)
The Jews are too impatient while the Arabs have a lot of patience. They play backgammon, socialize, procreate and watch the Jews fight among themselves. The impatient Jews need to repair the world and fix everything right now. The Jews are also eager to trade the precious Jewish land for a piece of paper with the Arabs called agreement. The Jews will adhere to it while the Arabs will laugh at it. They will violate it as soon as they become strong or if they perceive themselves strong. The Jewish impatience is a prescription for a disaster.
42. what number 5 is saying is..
mordechai ,   yerushalaim   (11.23.08)
that someone from abroad that came to "eretz israel" but does not live according to the laws of the "am israel" as stated in "torat israel" does have difficulty explaining his connection to the land after all... and in that he ain't that far off from the truth...
43. Mordechai #42: You make an important point.
Steve ,   US   (11.23.08)
You wrote: "that someone from abroad that came to "eretz israel" but does not live according to the laws of the "am israel" as stated in "torat israel" does have difficulty explaining his connection to the land after all..." What do you consider "fundamental" to living according to the laws of the "am israel" as stated in "torat israel?" Shas for instance, is a thought to be a Torah-observant party. Shas and her rabbis support "land for peace" (excluding Jerusalem). Shas remains in the Kadima government. Kadima is committed to establishing a Moslem state in Eretz Israel. Is Shas and her supporters, in your view, living according to the laws of the "am israel" as stated in "torat israel?"
Previous talkbacks
Back to article