News
Report: Most Palestinian claims of IDF abuse don't lead to charges
Ynet
Published: 26.11.08, 08:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. Yesh Din....
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (11.26.08)
Should take on a different project: get a simple compass and lead the "opresses flock" out of the land to their ancient home of Arabia...
2. Yesh din and similar crap
Ricardo Macher ,   KarneiShomron Israel   (11.26.08)
I'm sick and bored of this stupid reports, filled by self haters and even worse Jew haters that are published by the press! Yesh Din should be banned and whoever believes this crap is worth publishing sent to duty service and a course about loving your country. We all have justice ideals, but our country is 1.000 times more important that the feelings of a bored man.
3. GOOD MORNING ISRAEL
Khalid ,   Jerusalem   (11.26.08)
surprise surprise - as if one could occupy other peoples land without violating their human rights. ONLY way to end Israels appardheit is to give all people living in the same land the SAME RIGHTS ! its not: LAND for PEACE it is: RIGHTS for PEACE !
4. 'Human Rights' but only for certain 'humans'
Talula ,   Israel   (11.26.08)
Why should EVERY case result in charges being filed? Surely each case is looked at individually. Some are more severe than others. Sometimes charges should be brought, and sometimes not. The blood thirsty 'human rights' are at it again. They forget that 'human rights' are for every human being, not just Palestinians. Do human rights not apply to the soldier who had acid thrown in his face by some deranged Palestinian woman? SHE also has ‘human rights’. If you can make sense of that, or this crowd of confused Plebs, then please enlighten me because I'd love to know. In the meantime, this sad bunch of do-gooders need to get some sort of directive as to what violates a person's human rights. Because right now - EVERYONE seems to have them, apart from Israelis.
5. Surely, no evidence equals no charges, the media is the jury
(11.26.08)
6. #4 talula
Joseph ,   Israel   (11.26.08)
The Arab woman who threw acid at the soldiers face was not deranged but perfectly sane. Funded by the UN and Europe, encouraged by Machsom Watch and Yesh Din, she fights to exterminate the Jews.
7. did it even occur to them...
oferdesade ,   israel   (11.26.08)
... that the other 94% were unjustified complaints? i mean, i'm not saying they WERE, but maybe? just possibly? the average Israeli citizen (which is what most soldiers are) simply doesnt go in for kaffer-bashing, pogromisizing, putting up death camps, acting towards others in the manner that french, british, dutch and other european colonialists have been doccumented in?
8. NAME CHANGE
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (11.26.08)
Why Ynet does not change its name to (H)amasnet or something like that is beyond me. It is very clear that our Hellenist brothers are totally unaware that we are in a constant state of a lowgrade war, with a deadly ruthless enemy , who wants our total demise. Once upon a time the IDF was a army not a police force, an army's goal is to destroy the enemy , not to police them. In there constant pursuit of instant fame and happiness our Hellenists , have become lazy and weak . Infused with a false sense of justice and morality , to cover up their Hedonistic egotistic self serving ways , they try to portray themselves as superior. With as only result an enormous growth of anti-semitism around the world. The more they try to bow down to the religion of liberalism the more we will be dispised. Why would any young person choose to serve in the IDF , with so many backstabbers ready to pounce on them, just for their own self glorification. Anything negative and unjustly written here by the liberal biased Israeli media , is used worldwide to inflame the already increasing hatred against us. Because unfortanally from the outside the world looks at us as one people , it would be nice if we could do the same for a change.
9. WHAT ABOUT RELIGIOUS ABUSE?!?
John ,   Israel   (11.26.08)
1) not every time that a claim is filed is it legitimate. 2) What about the hundreds of time that the soldiers abuse religious settlers or haredi people?!?!?!
10. #9 Got nothing to say on the subject? Keep quiet.
Talula ,   Israel   (11.26.08)
Do you really want a list of all the vile dispicable things the settlers (aka hippies) - have done to our soldiers. Why don't you just put a sock in it.
11. And 90% of the charges are fabrications or provocations...
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (11.26.08)
... staged for the Islamo-Leftist media and encouraged by "human rights" farces and pathetic palestinian simpathizers like B'Tselem and Yesh Din. So basically, 60% of the "abuses" are brought to justice - a pretty good record considering that the soldiers are harrassed and prvoked daily by the local population and uder constant threat of terror attacks. What the readers are NOT told is that anybody can file as many complaints as they wish - even 100,000 but when they are tested against facts and the law, 99.9999% are exposed as frauds, lies and fabrications. These numbers are yet another malicious disinformation effort by the palestinians and their "human rights" supporters.
12. Yesh Din report = an insulting farce!
The Doc ,   Haifa,Israel   (11.26.08)
"A soldier who chooses to beat up ...[snip] ...knows that the chances of him facing trial or even investigated are slim." What a farce! Lior Yavne is now a MIND READER? He actually knows what each and every IDF soldier THINKS or KNOWS? How much MORE of the Yesh Din report is similarly flawed and maliciously one sided? I'd say that only 6% of this so-called "report" is credible! The rest is pure and simple full of pompous and self-serving libelous statements which serve all enemies of Israel - no matter how you look at it. It is just yet another application of the old Muslim approach that "if you tell the same lie over and over again, people will start to believe it". If somebody believes this entire Yesh Din piece of crap, then he/she needs urgent mental care!
13. Why isn't Yesh Din in Sderot?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (11.26.08)
What? No report on the abuse of OUR civilians? How much damage has been done from the hundreds of Kassams falling on our civilians? What's the psychological cost? Can you imagine what it's like to raise children in Sderot? Not that people like Yesh Din care - they only worry about our enemies, people who want to eliminate us. I can't even begin to fathom the mind-set of people in these NGO's - I actually doubt their sanity.
14. Ynet copywriter needs English classes
David ,   Rehovot   (11.26.08)
It's not "cases", it's "accusations". It's Yesh Din and other terror supporters that assume all accusations are true. Ynet shouldn't follow their line.
15. I'm mentally abused by Palestinians every day
Vicky ,   Ashkelon Israel   (11.26.08)
Who do I complain to? Because UN, HRW, and AI as well as our own Government donts give an ef.
16. Release Shalit and it may not happen!!
telavivit ,   Israel   (11.26.08)
17. Most charges are FALSE to start with, what punishment do you
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (11.26.08)
want for FALSE charges? "palestinians" are professional victims, professional liars and any real abuse goes unnoticed among the false charges. If they lied less, there would be more attention to any real abuse.
18. Palis sob story of the day
m   (11.26.08)
19. #10 Who made you the she-bully of all t/backs?Go get some
self-gratification & ,   chill out wil you?   (11.26.08)
Back to article