Jewish Scene
Neturei Karta: Chabad punished for alliance with Zionists
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 15.12.08, 11:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
88 Talkbacks for this article
1. Well, I hope the State knows who they are
Talula ,   Israel   (12.15.08)
and lists them as personae non gratae. The unsavoury Lovers of the head case in Iran are all mentally disturbed and should NEVER be allowed into our country.
2. neturei karta is islamic, right?
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (12.15.08)
listening to what they say, it's really hard for me to tell.
3. What about the ..
Tuvia Schertzman ,   Betar Ilit   (12.15.08)
Satmar Hasid, was he guilty also? Besides Notori Karta, are there any kosher Jews? What about all the Jews in Charedi Betar? Are we all worthy of death? Even the babies? Even the Rabbaim?
4. Neturei Karta they do not deserve to stay in Israel
Daniel ,   Amsterdam   (12.15.08)
Hearing them I remember people saying Holocaust is a punischment from G-D. Is crazy i really do not like this kind of non sense.
5. where can I find a Neturei Karta version of the Torah?
eli ,   K. malachi   (12.15.08)
Apparently it's a different version from the "regular" one. Maybe I should ask Ahmadinijad for a copy?
6. JEWS AGAINST JEWS
adi   (12.15.08)
SHAMEFUL!
7. Friends of Ahmadinejad are speaking..
Marek   (12.15.08)
8. Neturei karta are not jewish. Jews don't talk like that.
neturei karta   (12.15.08)
9. this is a very not nice article!
(12.15.08)
which leaves me wondering why Y-net felt a need to get itself involved in the internecine battles of the ultra-orthodox world! to TBer #1 you are thinking of the Satmars and not of the Neturei Karta. to TBer #2 unfortunately no they are not Islamic they are Jewish! but you know there are Jews and then there are Jews and then of course there are goyim! but that's a whole other story!
10. Why are you giving space to NK?
Shalom   (12.15.08)
Let them crawl back into their holes
11. Just in case you needed more proof
Danny   (12.15.08)
of what scumbags they are
12. By their despicable behavior...
Rafael ,   Jerusalem   (12.15.08)
the Neturei Karta are proving themselves unworthy to be called Jews. These sick individuals are underserving of being part of Am Yisrael.
13. This is a Zionist State
moshico ,   Jerusalem   (12.15.08)
I want to be sick after reading this artice. They, Neturei Karta should not be allowed to settle in a Zionist state they should be burned at the stake.
14. Dum-da-dum-dumb!
Gideon Reader   (12.15.08)
Nuterei Kardboard had been punished with a cocncept, and personnel that are criminally stupid, and if there were statutes for ignorance, each and every one of these smelly morons would be doing hard time, hoping for a prisoner exchange wherein the receiving party was in great need of disgusting 14th century pudwackers of the onanistic kind.
15. N K
Lex ,   US   (12.15.08)
N K . . . FEH ! shtic drek
16. How disgraceful
Chana   (12.15.08)
Wasn't one of the victims Satmar, also anti-Israel (despite living there)? It just proves how completely baseless these arguments by Nemura Karta are. Only Hashem knows why bad things happen sometimes to good people. We should be grateful, that there are Chabad centers all over the world, offering hospitality in a non-kosher environment (even to anti-zionists). Nemura Karta is only used as a political vehicle by Iran, and I am surprised, that they allow themselves to be manipulated that way. You want to be anti-zionist - fine, but please stay outside Israel and keep quiet without bonding with ennemies,who physically would like to destroy us.
17. God's curse on Jews - naturei karta
jan   (12.15.08)
All races,religions,ethnic groups have their outcasts.To our sorrow, naturei karta is the vermin of the Jews in it's ugliest form. Their grotesque "accoutrements", their obnoxious beliefs, their outrageous kissing of the devil himself,Ahmadino,the Iranian shrimp. While not a religious person,I believe that they are the one who uproot the Torah with their cheap "paperback" version . They represent God's punishment for our sins.
18. #3
Ben ,   Gush Etzion   (12.15.08)
What are rabeim? (raw beiim) raw eggs? the word is rabbanim Hareidi Beitar Illit where a family lives in tents outside of City hall because the big tzaddikim who live there refuse to let them rent an apartment? How do they allow you you to live in Beitar if you have internet? The Rabbanim of the city ruled that no cheder is allowed to accept children whose parents have internet!
19. NK - the Jihad sword of Iran
Joo ,   Eurabia   (12.15.08)
Throw the bustards to their Iranian brothers. Let them continue to hug and kiss each others.
20. Direct line with God
Ruth Rosenthal ,   Ashkelon   (12.15.08)
Sometimes it's Chabad that has a direct line with God, sometimes Ovadya Yosef and this time Neturei Karta. What is wrong with me? Should I subscribe to a different mobile phone provider?
21. Makes me sad reading this stuff!!!
Shaul ,   Tel Aviv   (12.15.08)
22. They need locking up
Stephanie ,   Israel   (12.15.08)
in a mental asylum
23. 9 It SAYS Neturei Karta!!! be quiet!!!
(12.15.08)
24. Chabad....
Miriam ,   Spain   (12.15.08)
irrational trash and filth- not worth the paper it is written on- God must be saving some real punishment for those 'believers'- it is just a matter of time.
25. How many NK in the world? 20? 30?
Freejew ,   Israel   (12.15.08)
SO why is YNet allowing this minority ringe loony group to have a voice?
26. Why is this sick garbage front page news??
Laura ,   Israel   (12.15.08)
This is revolting!
27. SATMAR is pro Iranian! Neturei Karta r just anti-Israel
(12.15.08)
for goodness sakes get your ultra-orthodox world in order cause otherwise y'all sound mighty ignorant! Perhaps Y-net will consider creating a special guide to the ultra-orthodox world!
28. Perhaps . . .
Apt Title ,   UK   (12.15.08)
Having been able to observe some of these characters in my neighbourhood, they are basically renegades dressed in the guise of chassidic Jews. They make out they're holy and only carrying out the will of G-d but there are one or two little problems . . . They tend to set themselves apart from others, perhaps as a "better than thou" click. They fail to adhere to the dictates of most of the World's botei dinim with their behaviour. And worst of all, they are happier to speak, shake hands and befriend enemies of the Jews (and believe me, Zionist or anti-Zionist, makes no difference to our enemies). On the last point, I feel it's worth noting, that there can be no defense - I have looked carefully through our history up until the Gaonic period, and can find no attempt to use outsiders to replace a Jewish king or leadership, however wicked, with non-Jews (which is precisely what Neturei Karta want). Finally, about Neturei Karta, I think it appropriate to apply the phrase . . . "this evil congregation" . . . who bring darkness into the World instead of the great light brought into the World by Chabad.
29. Who'd expect anything else?
eh-oop ,   UK   (12.15.08)
What contortions and distortions wouldn't you expect from those who choose to associate with Holocaust deniers?
30. It is possible the people at Chabad were punished by God,
(12.15.08)
but it is also possible they were glorified by the Lord. There is a special place and reward in heaven for martyrs.
Next talkbacks
Back to article