News
Israel begins pulling troops from Gaza; soldiers say 'could have done more'
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 18.01.09, 18:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
31. #8 Really Sad
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville, USA   (01.18.09)
If you really think that Israel will tolerate further shelling of any of their towns by Islamic fundamentalists - whether Hamas or Hizbollah - you need to see a shrink. Unfortunately, any further terrorist rockets will be fired over the corpses of dead Gazans. Now that's sad.
32. could have crashed Gaza? but you did
observer   (01.18.09)
33. ISRAEL suxks. USA is not with you
(01.18.09)
you're awful irresponsible murder of innocents will forever be blood on your hands. cowardsw. USA is not with you.
34. Once again the politicians betray the army and the people
Avi ,   Geneva   (01.18.09)
Olmert, Livni and Barak - please leave the stage of history forever. you have done enough damage to Israel. please go!
35. sorry idf guys but olmert never read about vietnam
yahn goodey   (01.18.09)
he was too busy bankrupting jerusalem and now israel besides buying/selling real estate to get a profit from friends to find time to learn about history and the real world that he likes to fly over for more kickbacks? he found time apparently to read what henry kissenger thinks about the military(expendable pawns?)but never found time to read the tanakh on how to love Hashem above all and his brothers as himself ?
36. Proud Palestinian
Mike ,   USA   (01.19.09)
Great to be proud, but your leaders and those of you who follow them are just plain stupid!
37. ISRAEL IS VICTORIOUS.
Leon ,   Los Angeles   (01.19.09)
Let us all celebrate, Stop wining.
38. if it is the promissed land
momo ,   japan   (01.19.09)
god .. how you make it hell . if it is the hell why not to leave it america do it in heroshema but they leave the hell they did but we stay becouse its our land oh god help you
39. don't blame your leaders !
ziad ,   lebanon   (01.19.09)
first they are simply trying to save what is left of israel reputation if there was any to start with ..second to save your troops who tried to get inside gaza but were face by ghost martyrs who are ready to jump on any mirkava and explose it ,,it happened twice but your goverment will not tell you this off course ..then that incident when hamass fighters killed 8 of your comondos in a house and the list goes on ...usa and israel tried get democracy to the middle east but they got a surprise when hamass leaders won the eclections in short they want to install leaders not to ellect them .
40. We love you, hayalei tzahal!!
Esther ,   netanya   (01.19.09)
Soldiers of the IDF, we love you and we thank you! YOU are our heroes!!
41. 18
Igor ,   Munich, Germany   (01.19.09)
you do not actually believe what you wrote in your comment, do you??? Those 2 wars were the worst losses Israel has ever bore!!!
42. #33... You Idiot
Mike ,   USA   (01.19.09)
Who are you to say the USA is not with Israel? Idiot.
43. # 36 Mike: anybody who blindly follows
Rudi ,   NC USA   (01.19.09)
any leader is plain stupid.
44. Don't pul out
Don ,   Michigan United Stat   (01.19.09)
Olmert and his band of idiots will make life in Israel even more difficult. You had the chance to eliminate Hamas and you blew it with a pull out. Listen to the soldiers--they are saying it was too soon. Do you think Hamas will just sit there, realize they made a mistake and go away? More Israeli lives will be lost in the future to Hamas because the Israeli leadership are idiots and cowards. Elect leadershthat know what they are doing and save yourselves. Ranger Don
45. The Ehudim are guilty of Perfidy to the Jewish People
Joe K ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.19.09)
Save the Yehudim from the Ehudim. It is unbelievable that such treacherous political leadership is tolerated in Israel. My blood boils at the thought of these traitors undermining the safety of the jewish people with their continued tolerated pandering to the opinions of the European left. The whole Oslo process has confused the friends of Israel in America, the continued pusillanimous behavior that snatches defeat from the jaws of victory is disgusting and intolerable. A generation should arise in Israel, if it lives, that puts Ehud Barak and Ehud Olmert on trial for treason to the Jewish people of Israel.
46. Re: Proud Palestinian
Merrill ,   New York, NY   (01.19.09)
You're right in some way. We did not destroy Hamas completely, we beat the hell out of it, while it was squealing like a little pig to the world "What about the children? Save the children, the ones I am using as my portable, walking-talking body armor". Yes, the world had to pull the Israelis away from your bloodied, broken-bones body. And while Hamas is in charge, it wouldn't care how many innocent Palestinian women, children and men would die - it will shoot rockets or send brainwashed teenagers to blow themselves. Look what you're left with, however. You will continue to be sealed off the rest of the world instead of becoming a true member of the world community. While Israelis enjoy full benefits of living in free, independent state, travel around the world, spending time with family, you will surrounded by hate, fear, anguish and despair. Many more your fellow innocents will die. Look at what happened in the West Bank where suicide attacks stopped - people live more or less good life, and their situation will only get better once they become an independent state. You will be stuck with fellow haters in Gaza, without reliable water, electricity or food, forced to rely on humanitarian aid the world community sends you. Once Iran runs out of money (and that will happen faster than you think, definitely in your lifetime) you won't be getting anymore weapons to attack Israeli civilians with. You will rise against Hamas, but it would be too late, because every one round you became one of them. Good luck, and enjoy your "victory".
47. Duhhhh!!!!! When are Israeli leaders start leading?
Joe   (01.19.09)
48. The solution to terror.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (01.19.09)
Victory is the key word not peace, because peace is not an option in this part of the world, and because there is only one solution to terror : a military solution. You do not talk to terrorists, you fight and defeat them. Victory is needed to prove to the Muslims in general and the Arabs in particular that against their ethos of death stands the ethos of life, protected by the arms of democracies that are resolved to punish them where it hurts most as explained at : http://xrl.us/biz8x
49. Proud Palestinian
beverly ,   Toronto Canada   (01.19.09)
Wake up and smell the roses. At every turn you have been betrayed by your co-religionists. You can start in 1948 with the invading armies telling you to leave your home - where you have sat for 60 years because they use you as pawns. The PA leadership starting with Arafat, who stole you blind and the continued corrupt leadership under Abbas. Then you have the brave courageous leadership of Hamas sitting in Damascus saying they won. Their decision to violate the truce and not extend it brought all of the upon you. So you need to decide who your real enemy has been.
50. Talking cosmetics
sam ,   AUH   (01.19.09)
"It's been pretty quiet. Then why did u not go to "phase 3" and ended Hamas and freed Shalit?! "The army used a lot of fire power to cover our backs," Is that why you had the " friendly fire incidents" "Unfortunately, the ones paying the price are the Palestinian civilians, many of whom have been left without homes or infrastructure." I think u have missed the so many lives!!
51. a few days more
Kidon 77   (01.19.09)
Of course teh war should have bben prolonged for a additional week to let Tsahal get rid of the last Hamas elments and in a way to eliminate or arrest Zahar and the other Hamsa leaders. Even if thi swar ended on a isreli succes, it could be more complet if we had givenwar the full chnace
52. hey #28
Rick ,   L.A USA   (01.19.09)
After that song England was never a contender again for any championship. May Hamas share such a fortune.
53. #38 momo
shmulke ,   w coast usa   (01.19.09)
America was attacked and it did what it had to do. So must Israel.on a much smaller scale of course.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article