News
Families of terror victims against release of killers
Daniel Edelson
Published: 23.01.09, 12:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
17 Talkbacks for this article
1. give hamas prisoners the same
rich ,   france   (01.23.09)
benefits they give to gilad and it will work !
2. ISNT IS NICE AN ISRAELI TERROR VICTIM HANDS A PALESTINIAN ..
...TERROR VICTOM ,   Atilla Karagözoğlu   (01.23.09)
3. Shalit has become an election ploy.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (01.23.09)
You better believe that Kadima would do anything to claim credit for Shalit's release just before the elections. They would release literally anyone just like they released Kuntar. The right opportunity was lost when they declared the unilateral ceasefire without Shalit's UNCONDITIONAL release. It's exactly what they did in Lebanon. But Shalit's captors are unlikely to be cooperative - and why should they be? If he's still alive, they could kill him today, knowing full well our rotten politicians would still exchange prisoners for even a dead body, anything for political gain. What bothers me most is the whole collection of bleeding hearts who have turned the whole thing into a reality TV show, supported by a brain-dead media. They are one of the reasons a Hamas goal was to capture other soldiers ...... The whole thing is nauseating.
4. Kadima rewarding Hamas by freeing hundreds of murderers
Seth ,   ashkelon israel   (01.23.09)
Kadima wants them freed so the EU and Hamas can then have control of rafah crossing. Kadima wants to sell out Israel's security. Kadima are traitors. Kadima also wants EU at all the gaza crossings. Kadima wants turkish troops in gaza. Kadima does these operations so they then can sell Israel security out to unifil and EU. Freeing murderers causes more kidnappings. If Hamas knew Israel wouldn't award kidnappings they would do them in the first place.
5. What proof do we have that he is even alive?
Pete ,   Bat Yam   (01.23.09)
Will we be sending healthy educated happy unrepentant murderers like that fat bastard Kuntar back to kill more people in exchange for yet one more dead body? With all do respect for the Shalit family and will all the hopes and prayers that Gilad is alive, one must be skeptical from past experience that with out proof all we will get back is one more dead body. The politicians are playing on our good will for votes in return for empty promises of a pig in a poke!
6. #1 Rich the frog: move to gaza, join hamas
KB   (01.23.09)
7. Maybe It's Time to Offer a Nuke for his safe return!!!
ASM ,   Australia   (01.23.09)
8. Free Gilad
Jan ,   South Africa   (01.23.09)
I'm very sorry to say this, but Ze'ev Rapp your daughter is dead. Why do you want to torture Gilad for that ?? Set him free & let him live!
9. One for one.
A voice   (01.23.09)
No visits for their prisoners either.
10. you will exchange killers with killers .
(01.23.09)
11. Do whatever it takes.
david ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.23.09)
Sorry, but this family has suffered enough. Release anyone now to get Gilad back home. There will be other opportunities for Hamas to pay for this crime.
12. Why free murderers?
Marc ,   Israel   (01.23.09)
Some people seem to be missing the point. So we free a slew of convicted terrorist murderers to get Gilad back. Within a few years, those murderers will be back at their trade and we'll have five more "Gilads" in captivity and 50 more Israelis murdered. How can that possibly be a good deal?
13. 11 david
Rachel   (01.23.09)
While my heart totally goes out to the terror victim's families. I agree with what you said. If Israel was willing to release an unrepentant murderer of an Israeli policeofficer and an Israeli family, to get back the corpses of Israeli soldiers. They should have no problem releasing other terrorists to get a living Israeli back. The IDF and Mossad can always come back and hunt down these murderers. The only thing is I think Israel should have done this over 2 and a half years ago,when he was first kidnapped. Galit may not even be alive anymore, and even if he is will he ever be able to get his mind back? I hate to be so morbid, but God only knows what torture both physically and emotionally the Hamas people inflicted on him.
14. Shalit free, or expect the worse!!
Albert ,   Buenos Aires Arg   (01.23.09)
bomb them downnnn
15. shalit
sas ,   israel   (01.24.09)
needs to come home. but no one mentions that he was doing the wrong thing (sleeping and left the tank door open) at the wrong place at the time of the kidnapping. same thing with goldwasssr n company.............. rabin MADE A BIG MISTAKE hen he refused to pay a million dollars for the release fo ron arad. for him it was too expensive. he and his family (rabin) should feel "sorry" now. it was his stupidity that we never got arad back but no one seems to care or is prepared to dwell on the truth and look for the truth. where is family goldwasser in their demands to keep the shlait issue alive. they go their bodies - that is all that they are interested in. everyone in this country is selfish. a sad country/world that we live in - no values and no meaning to our words.
16. Bereaved families should NOT run Israeli Diplomacy
(01.24.09)
17. Zeev is a crazy jew. Dont listen to him
Shalit   (01.24.09)
Back to article