News
Report: Gaza detainees held bound for days
Aviad Glickman
Published: 28.01.09, 13:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
31. "WE ONLY TRIED TO MURDER JEWS, & THEY TREAT US LIKE THIS?"
dp   (01.28.09)
a great injustice
32. Worst than Hamas is us
baruch ,   paris   (01.28.09)
I think the we should urge these people and their organisations to move out of Israel : they should move to Rafia or Damas
33. What???
Amanda ,   Ashdod, Israel   (01.28.09)
Bitter cold? I live 30 km away from Gaza, it is definitely not bitterly cold here, this is the warmest winter we have had since I have been here. Give me a break. Anyone can look up the temperatures for Gaza at that time, it was definitely NOT bitter cold. But maybe Hamas members live in such extravagant conditions, it was such a hardship to be POW's....Whiny babies...
34. what about israeli human rights
vashDi ,   israel   (01.28.09)
these pallies came in with the idea off killing some innocent jews so why the f@#k are these stupid leftist bastards standing up to them , if i caught them i would have shot them dead so that they wouldnt be a threat to the israeli community, if you ask me the bastards got off lightly. and as for the leftists , well they dont have the right to call themselves israelies, they are backstabbers and they should all just ship out of here and go to gaza to be with their supportive friends hamas...
35. sometimes we are wrong
m ,   jerusalem   (01.28.09)
another stupid move by the government , we have to show the rest of the world that we are better than barbarians. especially when the whole world already watches every move israel makes. i do believed that they were tortured because no one here would like to be treated like that. no matter what they are or what they are trying to do we must show everyone that we are better than this
36. Better reporting needed
Sidney ,   USA   (01.28.09)
The article starts with "Israeli human rights groups". How big are these groups? Who are the members? Do these groups constitute different memberships or are they the same people under different names? Are some of them Arab groups? Do they have any independent evidence or are they relying on testimony by people who may be Hamas members or Hamas proxies? Surely an Israeli newspaper does not need to play the blame Israel game.
37. HR ? what about Galid?
Salvador ,   USA   (01.28.09)
What is the complaint. Galid is ignored by this IDIOT good for nothing organizations. UN and Human Rights are bias and pro-terrorist , and anti-israel.
38. To Sidney- they are paid by Iran
Salvador ,   USA   (01.28.09)
Yes this organizations are trained and paid by Iran.
39. Fadi: Love will triumph
JC ,   USA   (01.28.09)
Dear Fadi, as long as you follow Mohammad and hate jews, you will not know love. Consider for one minute to love thy neighbor and even your enemies! Love triumphs. YHVH loves you but you must follow Him. Jesus Christ is Love. Mohammad is not. May YHVH bless you.
40. When will the leftists start talking about "honor" killings?
David ,   israel   (01.28.09)
Peace begins at home. No peace with Arab Moslems until they abolish "honor" killings of their closest female relatives, and jihad killings of "the infidels." Why won't Israeli leftist "human rights" groups speak out about the "honor" killings and the jihad killings? Cause they're scared. And they prefer blaming Yehudim (Jews).
41. hypocrites
arthur ,   jersey city usa   (01.28.09)
Regev,Goldwasser Schalit Ron Arad where are these bleeding hearts when Israeli boys are tortured and killed. When they are held, dead or alive, with no info to the families.
42. G-I-L-A-D S-H-A-L-I-T
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.28.09)
Let us know what you are doing for him. Then we'll get back to you.Until then.....f*^#$ off!
43. yea ok
Alex ,   USA   (01.28.09)
BULLSHIT
44. NOT LIKE THEY HAD GASOLINE POUR ON HEADS & SET FIRE TO THEM
dp   (01.28.09)
which is how it would have gone if the roles were switched
45. oy, cry me ariver!
oded   (01.28.09)
what about the israeli victims of sderot, ashdod and all the surrounding towns and cities around gaza, who were subjected to daily barbaric attacks by hamamstan? what about the scores of traumetized childeren who wil never be the same after the 8 years of missles barrages? start there ,nd then maybe we can discuss the""arab mistreatmnt""
46. In two words.
Uzziel   (01.28.09)
Gilad Shalit.
47. #6 fadi
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (01.28.09)
1. 90% of the Palestinians have supported Hamas ever since Fatah turned out to be so corrupt. Nothing to do with Israel 2. wrong. Egypt, Lebanon and Saudi Arabia support Fatah and want to destroy Hamas 3. Since 1948 Israelis have been considered subhumans that should be exterminated by the Arabs. There is nothing Israel can do to make it worse. 4, 5, 6 please send your analysis to Israelis who support Kadima and Labor who want to give Hamas all of Judea and Samaria to make your fantasies come true. Your analysis proves that the "National Union" is correct.
48. BRAVO, LOTS OF GOOD PRO ISRAEL AND RIGHT WING OPINIONS..
YNET,,,YOURE OK? LOL ,   ..............DACON9   (01.28.09)
49. israel is treating them badly??!!
dave ,   moscow   (01.28.09)
waht is happening to the israeli soldiers that have been kidnapped?? it would turn your stomach if you knew all the ways they are being tourtured and how they are being treated, when will the world wake up!!!???
50. What do they expect in war, a pat on the back. Come on,
JO   (01.28.09)
Are they victims? Did they not choose to carry a gun and kill? Their actions have consequences. What about Gilad in Hamas hands, no international rights at all. Weeping men - maybe it is their age as I read that Hamas recruited mostly 17-22 year olds. What do they expect, soldiers to risk their lives for them so that they could have a blanket? War is war and never cosy. There lot was a few days of roughing it, something expected of combatants in war time.
51. oh, man up, ya wimps!
lw ,   London   (01.28.09)
they're pathetic, honestly. after everything Hamas hs done to Israelis.
52. Israeli Human Rights Groups
Rosie   (01.28.09)
Where are they when Israeli children are murdered and Israeli citizens are killed. They should go to Gaza to do a comparative analysis and experience the human rights Hamas style. Maybe, the human rights activists will not be able to return and tell their story. Jews and ISRAELIS WAKE UP.
53. "human rights" groups, TA style
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.28.09)
All of them are funded primarily by the US Ford Foundation, a group known for its routine anti-Israel stance and named for a close personal friend of adolf hitler who, even after knowing what he was doing to the Jews, advocated a US alliance with and support of hitler. As for the Israeli physicians, over the weekend they admitted they never got further than the field hospitals set up in Aza (now closed because hamass threatened to kill any pali that seeks medical help there to which there are no international condemnations) so where is their FIRST HAND knowledge
54. detainees?
observer   (01.28.09)
either they would have been killed during fighting, or their human shields had been killed and they had miraculously survived the kill. But would Israel expose them to be killed by Hamas and weather, so it would have lost precious stuff for interrogation.
55. But these guys are willing to blow themselves up for their
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (01.28.09)
cult. If you are willing to commit suicide for a cult.......why would you complain about the right to live.....even if it were in a hole where you weren't being shot at? These guys can't decide who has the authority to kill them or treat them with the dignity of not being killed. If it's a Jew....then it is inhumane treatment. If it is their cult leader.....then bombs away. Blow up some infidels. Why don't they complain of inhumane treatment by the Mullahs and their cult following, that tells them to blow themselves up. That's not inhumane?......that's a cult fanatics decision? You don't have the balls to complain about that request by your nutty religious leaders? Give us all a break.
56. inhumane
yakov ,   ashkelon israel   (01.28.09)
where are these groups when hamas shoots fatah in the knees, or when daniel pearl is beheaded, or when gilad shalit is not allowed visitation by the red cross?
57. underwear
yakov ,   ashkelon israel   (01.28.09)
at least they werent forced to wear any underwear on their heads like the 'horrible' US army does to iraqi terrorists -- comparably these terrorists who shoot rockets aimed at kindergartens are treated rather well
58. Be grateful they're not shot dead.
Avraham ,   NYC   (01.28.09)
59. Want humane?
world gone mad   (01.28.09)
go to Iran where the Gays (Who they don't have) can "hang out".
60. indirectly did they tried this time
observer   (01.28.09)
Aryeh Yitzhaki of Bar Ilan University, who had worked in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) history department, said in an August 1995 interview with Israel Radio that a reconnaissance unit, known as Shaked (Almond), headed by Binyamin Ben-Eliezer, had killed hundreds of Egyptians who had abandoned their weapons and fled into the desert during the 1967 war. Yitzhaki said he had investigated six or seven separate incidents, in which approximately 1,000 unarmed Egyptian prisoners of war had been killed by IDF units. isn't it Talmudic instruction to kill gentile indirectly; " if gentile fall in a ditch, take the ladder away" . The little difference is he was pushed, but not did he fell.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article