Add talkback 
Print talkbacks 
Top cardinal: Vatican botched Shoah affair    Reuters
31. A pox on the Vatican
Ivor Dwatt ,   Johannesburg, South   (02.04.09)
32. No. 22 and 23 , It´s like I said
There is no master list showing the names of 6 million Jews killed in the Holocaust. Yad VadShem has only 3.2 million. So where are the names of the other 2.8 million? How do we know that they were Jews? For once, let´s start being truthful to ourselves. Yad Vad Shem does not have a list of names showing 6 million Jews killed. It´s time we did some research on this for ourselves, without accepting blindly what some self-appointed Jewish leader says. Many of them are crooks and lying. Why should I believe them?
Rich ,   Toronto, Canada   (02.04.09)
33. A perfect storm: Church and Islam Join to Deny Holocaust
Same ole Holy Roman Catholic Church-Mel Gibson style. Forty years of 'moderation' regarding Jews is an historical abberation. Church has killed more Jews throughout the ages than Islam ever did, though that is changing. Ironic thing is that the Church doesn't even realize it will be conquered by its Islamic 'buddies'.
Shneerhere ,   Chicago   (02.04.09)
34. Rich from Toronto, go back to your Bund meeting
shneerhere   (02.04.09)
35. Rich #32: What is your point?
Are you, like Mr. Williamson, a Holocaust denier? Do you like Williamson, believe maybe a couple of hundred thosand (perhaps three hundred thousand at most) Jews were murdered in the death camps in Poland and Germany? But not one by gassing? Do you believe gas chambers, Zyklon-B, etc., were not employed to murder a couple of million or better Jews? Where are you going here? What are you attempting to prove?
Steve   (02.04.09)
36. Germany best country in Europe!
Germans are enlightend and dont care alot for the church, especially the catholic one.Germany has problems with their turks, especially recently. Germany is Israels best friend in Europe. Italy and Spain are so backward. Look at their attitude towards Israel. It bothers me alot!
Chaim ,   Frankfurt/Main   (02.04.09)
37. Pope = Dope with a Robe
Douglas Goodwin ,   Baltimore   (02.04.09)
38. Rich , there were NO population registers
in most east European countries , at least not accurate , and Jews were mostly registered at the local Rabbinate . The six million is approximative , some historians say 5.9 million . This number is widely accepted by all historians , Hilberg , Shachar , Martin Gilbert , who made a serious research on this subject . The names Yad Vashem has are from people who had survivors . Many victims had'nt any family member surviving . Also from lists the nazis made in some countries , Belgium amongst them , of people who were deported . I assimilate people who have doubts about this number to the worse deniers .
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.04.09)
39. #32 Rich, did you even bother reading my reply?
Don't you even know where that death toll estimate comes from? It comes from Raul Hilberg, Sir Martin John Gilbert, Lucy Schildkret Dawidowicz, Donald Niewyk and Francis Nicosia, R.J. Rummel... and on and on and on. The list of names is as extensive as the number of historians who pored over Nazi documents in the aftermath of WWII, who looked up population estimates from the pre-war era and looked at the newer ones of the post-war era... there is a sheer mountain of written works from that period, as the sheer extent of the disaster became apparent. You, sir, just make yourself sound absurd in your nitpicking. "Present me the impossible, and I shall believe in your petty facts!" you say, and we must blindly rush to uncover the conspiracies you have ingrained in your mind...
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (02.04.09)
40. SSPX statement
When I looked on the SSPX website they had information that Williamson had been forbidden to make public statements about politics or historical information. They said that these are not areas of their religious expertise. Actually I guess I wouldn't mind if all religious leaders had the same rules. I'd say that they should choose one-be either religious leader, historian or politician but not trying to be all. Not wanting jack of all trades and master of none.
Marilyn ,   USA   (02.04.09)
41. # 36 Chaim and I still remember Hitler
and 6 million dead Jews. Germany has quite some past. She now has replaced Jews w/ muslims. Not so good for Germany? Europe? Same w/ every place the muslims live.... Also, I see the skin heads are alive and well in Germany. Israel will be the only safe place for Jews soon. Pray for the peace of Jerusalem, Shalom.
Petra ,   USA   (02.05.09)
42. # 39 Roman, TOUCHE' THANK YOU!!!!
forget the idiot, he can't help himself. He comes from a long line of idiots.
petra   (02.05.09)
43. Petra , muslims will not contribute as much
as the Jews did . You can't replace Jews , nobody can replace us . Have only a look at the long list of great Jews who fled nazi germany , and who contributed so much to your country . If the only safe place for Jews is here , what are you still doing there ? Don't talk , act !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.05.09)
44. TO 22 -you have NO FACTS
I expected a talkback like yours-comparing the holocaust to the actions that Israel, a sovereign state must carry out in an effort of defending its own citizens, Jewish and Arabs alike,against blood-thirsty terrorists who have been launching daily rockets at Israeli civilians for over 8 years, is the summit of ignorance and stupidity. Israeli civilians are being targetted by Hamas whereas the civilians who died inGaza were being used as human shields by Hamas. The IDF has done its best to forwarn the civilians in Gaza. What other army drops leaflets and makes telephone calls, the Jews in the concentration camps did not get any warnings. They were systematically and brutally murdered, just because they were Jews. After the Second World War Germany itself has taken responsibility as a country fort the 6 millions Jews who were murdered by the Nazis, and this still stands today . (re-read the article)so who are you and other holocaust deniers like yourself to question it? History cannot be re-written. DEAL WITH IT.
Nancy ,   Canada   (02.05.09)
 Previous talkbacks
Add talkback 
Print talkbacks