News
Doctor who slammed Gaza violence supported 9/11 attacks
Shahar Ginosar
Published: 04.02.09, 10:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. Hamas Fatah Al Quida
MC ,   UK   (02.04.09)
Hamas Fatah Al Quida are all in it together. Wake up world! Israel no 'peace talks' with any of them! Think twice ,vote right!!
2. This is news? This was reported by many during the op!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (02.04.09)
3. Doctors Are Like Actors: Not Experts
Brana Lobel ,   Israel   (02.04.09)
Mainstream journalists, especially Americans and Brits constantly go to doctors for "objective" evidence when it is clear that a number of doctors simply used their medical credentials to advance political views. I surmise that the Hippocratic oath "First Do No Harm" is not used in Norway, or else this doctor is a wild card. However prima facie he is lying and it is obvious. Also his political analysis is really poor; whether people agreed with the American invasion of Iraq it is certainly in no way comparable to 9/11. Iraq was an unhappy country with many factions at each others' throats, a dictator with questionable connections, and possible WMDs. The US, while there are internal disagreements, is a well-run country that gives a voice and aid not simply to citizens but even to aliens, and even to illegal aliens. Look at all the Arabs who want to come to the US. Do they want to come to Iraq? No. Those who destroyed the WTC were acting on behalf of a terrorist group. On top of that, the US has actually had WMDs for around 60 years and has not used them since Hiroshima. Who is a responsible entity and who are the uncontrolled savages? It's obvious. This doctor is a shame on his profession.
4. everyone hates this Israel. please dont be suprise.
atilla karagözoğlu   (02.04.09)
5. Doctor Who works for the BBC
Shlomo Silverstein ,   Maale Adumim   (02.04.09)
"Doctor Who slammed Gaza violence, supported 9/11 attacks " I'm not surprised. The Doctor works for the BBC.
6. Atilla
Gil ,   Tel Aviv   (02.04.09)
Your posts are quite bizarre. One minute supporting Israel at others (like the post above) you sound like you hate Israel. Maybe learn english better or stop writing posts here because you come across as "insane".
7. Doctor Who works for the BBC
Shlomo Silverstein ,   Maale Adumim   (02.04.09)
"Doctor Who slammed Gaza violence, supported 9/11 attacks " I'm not surprised. The Doctor works for the BBC.
8. Israel and the IDF should consider its legal position
Adam ,   London   (02.04.09)
And start filing libel actions against the BBC and others.
10. Zionist hasbara: destroy anyone daring to criticise Israel
Chanalau, Tova ,   London, UK   (02.04.09)
Zionists cannot be criticised: they are perfect, never make mistakes, never intentionally do harm, they are gods chosen people. If any war crimes were shown to have been commited by Israel (i.e. videoed by CNN) then the perpetrators were bedouins and druze. No Jew was or is ever involved. YNET is only obeying orders, you can't blame someone for following orders can you.
11. #4 I have a very great respect for nation of Israel
Ak ,   Bahrain   (02.04.09)
Man, what does this lovely country has to go through ... Can't the world just let them be ... 8 wars in 60 years .. they just can't accept Israel ... Oh, hear the stupid "Pals" sad story ... They stole our land .... Gees, the loser middle eastern countries are so pathetic, and beyond help. Man, I'd venture to say that Japan and Israel were the miracles of the 20th century... Stupid would not accept 1948 UN resolution, 6 loser countries declare war on a tiny nation just started ... the world is big enough, but they prefer to bully the weak ... fortunately, they got a nice tough lesson.... But, what can I say? once a loser, always a loser .... They repeat the same rhetoric, and yeah, very nice, they kicked in their face ... it only took 6 days in 1967. Do they learn? never? again in 1973, the losers try again .... Gees, and you know the rest is history ... finally one smart Arab, learn the hard lesson, and decide to make history with the Nation of Israel ... then every one of the losers states wish they can just get their lost lands back, that would never have been lost if they just stayed home and tried to work their dirty and rusty minds back in 1948. Now we have the Mullahs, back there in Tehran, want to play the same stupid game, instead of focusing on something useful, they want war .... Imagine 70 million Iranians against 7 Israelis! What could have happened if that oily state focused on developing itself instead of playing with toys and weapons, what could they manage to create? After all that lamination, finally the smart@ss Norwegian doctor comes from the freezing north, just to advocate the oppressed Palestinian against the Israeli aggressors... Did not he find something much useful to do, he did not, his mental capabilities only allow this.
12. impartial
frank ,   isreal   (02.04.09)
this will never really make the news anywhere other than israel as the world simply does not care enough about the facts. They are interested in leftist "truth", but rarely are the truth and facts the same. Where is the impartial press and why are they not commenting about this and Hamas stealing food from the UN. Where is the UN condemnation, world outrage...it will be there, just pointed at us rather than at the responsible parties.
13. DOCTOR THAT SLAMMED GAZA VIOLENCE
HENRYK ,   RAMAT GAN/ISRAEL   (02.04.09)
HEI DR MADS GILBRT CAN CAN U GIVE PUBLICLY YOUR COMENT ABOUT THE EQUAL OPORTUNITY OF TRATMENT OF WOMEN IN A ALQAEDA GOVERNMENT OR YOU ARE ONE OF THE MACHO MEN
14. #10
Voice of Reason ,   Here & Now   (02.04.09)
Tova is back & there is gonna be trouble. Not that we do not have enough enemies but also one of our own enjoys jumping into the fray. May your children seek the correct path and make Aliyah,
15. i'm objective 1000 % , try 2
(02.04.09)
If the IDF had acted as other armies do , there would be 13 thousand or more killed , instead of those 1300 . And see how objective i am : there were innocent victims , yes ! Sad to say it were mostly those children hamas used as human shields .
16. 10 chana-lo tova , you are RIGHT
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.04.09)
You are right . Zionists are perfect , they do not wrong and certainly don't kill intentionally people , exept murderers of course .
17. TO NUMBER 11 AND YNET
EISSA ,   AMMAN - JORDAN   (02.04.09)
I KNEW WHY YOU DONT PUBLISH MY OPINION ! YOU WANT TALK BACKS LIKE NUMBER 11 !!!! SURE HE IS A BAHRAINI JEW !!!! AND THE TALK BACKS MUST SUPPORT YOUR METHODS OTHERWISE NOWAY !!! AND FOR NUMBER 11 SEEM YOU DONT READ HISTORY NOR FUTURE !! THIS DOCTOR AND MUCH LIKE HIM UNCOVERED YOUR HEAVEN AND MAKE YOUR UGLY FACE MORE UGLY !!!!! REALY PATHETIC
18. world lost its sempaty to Israel, after the Gaza.
isint this enough ? ,   atilla karagözoğlu   (02.04.09)
19. What a Wacko! Deport him to Siberia
(02.04.09)
20. How did he get in ?
Stan ,   Johannesburg RSA   (02.04.09)
I thought there was a strangling blockage on Gaza ? Did he use a tunnel ? Where is he now ? Did he shoot off to help the women and children dying in East Timol where the government forces have been for the last 6 months fighting and slaughtering?
21. Re: Dr. Mendacious......
The 11th Man ,   London   (02.04.09)
He is either wicked and lying or else he is an idiot. Or both. It is clear to most thinking people that Israel could have flattened the Gaza Strip with no recourse to endangering its soldiers. Instead, they choose to put their sons and daughters in harm's way. Why? Answer: To keep innocent casualties to a minimum. In other words, to give Israeli lives in exchange for countless Gazan civilian lives. And nobody says 'thankyou'. THANKYOU, ISRAEL.
22. Chanalau you are right******
Salvador ,   USA   (02.04.09)
Jews are the perfect people choosen by GOD.
23. the message and the messenger
Lennybruce ,   amsterdam, NL   (02.04.09)
The things the doctor said in his multiple interviews may or may not have been true. But is it such a typically sneaky tactic to undermine the message by undermining the messenger and thereby avoiding discussing the essential point.
24. This guy was so obnoxious and clearly bigoted
Semsem ,   New York, USA   (02.04.09)
This guy was so obnoxious and clearly bigoted.
25. # 11
Ak ,   Bahrain   (02.04.09)
Next time, you'll say I am a MOSSAD agent .. Unfortunately, I am Agnostic, precisely if you want ex-Muslim... Really I am a secular person, but I don't know, those Jews ... I just admire them ... I mean look at what they turned Palestine into! Now you have your nice Kingdom, Libya, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain (My country), Egypt, Algeria, Morocco etc. Man! I believe God on their side this time.... They are just genius ... or we might believe one of the various conspiracy theories about the Zionist...... I mean 15 millions Jew against 1.5 Billion Muslims.... yeah, you'd better believe one of the fancy Zionist theories out there. and the Ynet published your sweet comment, lucky you. Best regards to you and the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan + King Abdulla + Queen Rania
26. No.10 chanalau
Sandra ,   Ra'anana Israel   (02.04.09)
First of all, you should read No.11's talkback. And you, with a name like Tova=good in Hebrew, suggest you change your name to Ra'a=bad in Hebrew. You certainly are a nasty piece of work.
27. #20, I assume Rafah
Danny   (02.04.09)
like the journalists who went in despite being "banned by Israel"...
28. #23, here is the essential points
Danny   (02.04.09)
1) He is being portrayed as "neutral" or "reliable", he clearly isn't. 2) The guy is a documented fraud. Now if Israel really was killing all these civilians why would they need to fake CPR for cameras? Surely they would have enough wounded and dead civilians... PS I note that people will always point out that IDF and Israel are biased - which of course they are - but fail to mention that the UN and "reporters" in Gaza are too.
29. #25 Re: 15 million Jews against 1 billion Muslims is
usa   (02.04.09)
an exaggeration, at best. Jews REALLY AND TRULY have nothing against Muslims; they just don't like being attacked with rockets and suicide bombers. Why Muslims cannot tolerate other religions in the Middle East is another long story. but those who believe the Quran know in their hearts that Israel belongs to the People of the Book.
30. Dr. Mads Gilbert
Josef Szmuda ,   Los Angeles USA   (02.04.09)
Take the "s" of off this guy's first name, and you'll have an accurate description of what this nut case is all about. He's a Mad doctor! josef szmuda
Next talkbacks
Back to article