News
Hamas: Shalit stipulation just 'Israeli procrastination'
Roni Sofer and Reuters
Published: 15.02.09, 01:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
31. Shalit and Truce
Hillel Green ,   Modi'in, Israel   (02.14.09)
PM Olmert should make it Government policy that Shalit must be returned to Israel for any truce. Israel should not release any Palestinian prisoners or open its boarders with Gaza.
32. HE"S SHOWING ABILITY TO BE P.M. AGAIN
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (02.14.09)
33. Olmert finally shows some balls on the way out the door.
Bennie ,   Jerusalem   (02.14.09)
34. Israel is not the same
Amro ,   Ramallah   (02.15.09)
what i am saying, how does israel approach an end of hammas negotiations with shalit not on board ? what is government thinking ? this a clear lack of an effective dialect in israeli politics domestic, regional and soon international. israel has started the 21st centuary with a very poor performance starting from the unorganized evacuation of lebanon in 2000 ending with the acceptance of coexistance with hamas and accepting hamas dialect in the truce by considering shalit as a sole issue.
35. Remind me why Israel didn't...
Adam ,   USA   (02.15.09)
make Shalit's release a precondition of withdrawal? Oh, yeah, then Olmert wouldn't have been able to release terrorists...
36. Israel should Procrastinate until...
Edward ,   New York, USA   (02.15.09)
Leiberman becomes defense minister... then Hamas will be eradicated and there will be no need to negotiate with anyone.
37. Time to destroy hamas and abandon cease fire
Bernard Ross ,   st anns bay jamaica   (02.15.09)
38. Peace with Hamas
Patrick ,   Israel   (02.15.09)
Call me simple minded and someone please help me: I assume that 99% of human beings prefer living in peace and prosperity and I further assume that 90% of people will have to do what it takes to achieve such a life. Hamas falls into the 1% group of human beings that prefer war: Why would you want a time limit on peace? This must be a joke. What after the time runs out? Why would you talk peace with your mouth and lob missiles and detonate bombs with your arms? I can see the first couple of missile after a truth to be “lobbed in error”. But that’s about it. Why would you continue to dig tunnels smuggle arms or sneak components to build arms into your hands? The operation in Gaza is not done and has not archived its military and strategic objectives I am sorry for the brave IDF solders to say that, but what I see ongoing now is the same s**t different day. While I am at it: What a rookie move by the U.S. to send Mitchell to the Middle East a few weeks ago: We did not have a government to talk to and will not for another few weeks.
39. Giving Hamas anything before the release of Shalit is just
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (02.15.09)
supporting them and making them stronger in the end. They have no reason to keep Shalit, other than using him as a political pawn, trying to boost support for their terrorism towards Jews. Let them all starve if they won't give him back. Drive their government into the ground.
40. If Gilad get free I will give Olmert all the credits........
Asher ,   Ny,USA   (02.15.09)
41. :/
Aj ,   Hillsbro US   (02.15.09)
I have an erie feeling the Shalit may already be dead. With Hamas killing and torturing fellow palestinians, i Highly doubt they would keep an Israeli alive :(
42. People need to understand. JUST STOP A SECOND!
NO HUMAN RIGHTS ,   FOR SHALIT   (02.15.09)
WHY? Why has Hamas treated this individual , obviously harmless person like this? WHY! Not even visiting rights, let alone release him. They bleat incessantly about their 'rights' and about compassion - BUT look at what are doing to another person- JUST TAKE LOOK! WHERE IS THE UN!!!!!! WHY ONLY ISRAEL!!!!! YOU B........TARDS MAKE ME SICK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
43. Push for an end to this: Alive or MURDERED
Nudnik   (02.15.09)
44. Shalit
Avraham ,   Israel   (02.15.09)
If Hamas really wanted the crossings open (since they claim that Gaza is in a humanitarian crisis), then realse Shalit. Is one Israelu soldier so important to them that they are willing to sacrafice the "well being" of the residents of Gaza? Maybe Shalit is dead,God forbid, and Hamas is trying to copy what Hizballah did in negotiations for prisoner releases. Avraham
45. To make the deal fail? That means hamas won't let Shalit go
rachel ,   usa   (02.15.09)
no Shalit , no deal .....Lets stop the bull.....
Previous talkbacks
Back to article