News
Rights group: Israeli troops broke medical ethics
Reuters
Published: 23.03.09, 07:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
31. #26 you win battles
hakim ,   usa   (03.23.09)
BUT YOU WILL NEVER WIN THE WAR!!!!!
32. # 5 Meir WE'RE IN TOTAL AGREEMENT.
petra ,   uSA   (03.23.09)
the only thing yet to be done is to do unto Gaza as they would do onto Israelis. The pals cannot win any battle so, they lie like rugs.
33. The usual propaganda oversight
Arie ,   BaGolan   (03.23.09)
The FACT that Israel opened up mobile hospitals in gaza and that hamass threatened to kill anyone taking advantage of them. Israel was forced to close them since , under the threats, no one showed up. OOps, my bad.....just another fact that would obfuscate the anti-State histrionics if presented accurately!
34. I believe it was Hamas which did not allow the Gazans..
Daniel   (03.23.09)
to go into Israeli hospitals and be treated by Israelis because they prefer the PR provided by images of suffering and dying children. Just last week a Palestinian girl was killed because Hamas refused to allow her to go to an Israeli hospital to receive treatment. Why aren't human rights groups focusing on that disgusting disrespect for the rights of the sick?
35. #9
Logic Stick ,   Sharon U.S.   (03.23.09)
You're as inaccurate as the Israeli weapons. What was it, 13 Israeli's killed, 7 of which were killed by friendly fire? Proves the IDF couldn't hit anything they were actually aiming for, unless they aimed at their own men intentionally, to drive up their own casualties. Hillarious.
36. to # 30 & 31
ghostq   (03.23.09)
women r also capable to become terrorists. just ask the iraqians people every week you hear on women that explode themselves at mosqs you just have to face it, all your knowleg come from what you hear in your local mosq and is unbased, lebanon war started when 2 soldiers were kidnnapet from Israel teritory, so get you facts straight.
37. to #31
ghostq   (03.23.09)
don't you know palestinians have no archiological avidence of their so call roots in Israel, they never had, or any legal documentaion to prove their claim. so this is just the simple cold fact, deal with it.
38. #5 admission or announcement of ill-principles?
observer   (03.23.09)
39. Human Rts Groups are our enemies
Roy Chweidan ,   Netanya   (03.23.09)
From my own Reserve duty experience, Israeli human rights groups are blatantly anti Israel and lie and deceive to support the enemy. They aid enemy propaganda. Our own soldiers who criticise Tsahal are foolish and do not yet understand the realities of the battlefield. Roy Chweidan, Netanya
40. The morality of the IDF
Spencer ,   Israel   (03.23.09)
The morality of the IDF cannot be questioned....there is no army more moral than Israel's. We don't use women and children as shileds. We don't set up rocket launcers in schools and hospitals. We don't use houses of worship to store and manufacture munitions. It would be nice if the PHR investigated for once the actions of Hamas and other Arab terrorist groups and laid of with there barrage of lies against Israel' armed forces.
41. an ugly truth
will edwards ,   Dallas TX USA   (03.23.09)
From personal experience I can tell you what happens when an army loses it's conscience. There are many among you still who bear the evidence of this fact. No military is immune from it, no people excused from it... no matter how valiant and true. If this matter of abuse and disregard proves true there is only one solution. Remove all field commanders and replace them. The sooner you do the more time you will have to properly train them. Remember this if you question such action.... you can't put the genie back in the bottle. Repair and move on. Israel is a shining star in a field of chaos. Don't let it fall, especially from the inside.
42. #41
Cynthia ,   USA   (03.24.09)
How easy it is for you to point your finger at the IDF from the comfort of your home. "Israel is a shining star in a field of chaos". Israel went to war with terrorists who had bombarded Israeli civilians with 3000 missiles while they hid within civilian populations so that a response from Israel would harm the Palestinian civilian population. Israel showed great restraint and responded militarily when Hamas launched 55-60 missiles per day at Israel. Interesting how you don't hold the Palestinians responsible for harming their own people and causing this war. The IDF did an excellent job and because of their pinpointed efforts, more people weren't killed.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article