1. arabs will never accept a jewish state in the middle east
they even go so far as inventing another arab nation just to counter the jewish nation, and arabs that came in the past 100 years to palestine claim their ancestors are from there. how long will it take before israel shall have to cut itself in half again (after giving arabs the west bank) because arabs shall start making claims on israel again?
|
|
2. how long will it be before WB get weapons like gaza?
|
|
3. Two state is fiction,one dual rate is okay
so sooner or later jews they have to share land and governament with palestinian in one state Israelo-palestinian nation and all these talk about 2 states solution are useless .
|
|
4. Wrong again.
The 2 state "solution", is not "currently a pipe dream". It has always been a pipe dream, and it always will be a pipe dream. It is a tool for Israel's enemies to eventually destroy Israel. The arab muslims put crack in the pipe, and the rest of the world smokes it. PUT THE PIPE DOWN! Got it?
|
|
5. one state solution, then
the writer is stating the obvious and a reality that we, the Palestinians, had known for almost 100 years: the Zionists European colonists would do anything, everything, and whatever it takes to control the land of Palestine.
the issue here is not who you put your trust in? nor who we, Palestinian, trust either? rather the question is: Do the Israelis, indeed, want peace with us? the answer is yes, but not based on justice rather in their demands and psychological disorder of wanting it all, yet the Palestinians must obey.
dream on
|
|
6. dont waste your ink
ITS OBAMA TIME ! and the only agenda is the one he gave you, peace and 2 state solution . geez its so obvoius that israelis never wanted peace, obama knows israel will try all types of diversions and stalls thats why he gave them an altimatum , make peace or we will send american soldiers to protect gaza. we dont want terrorism and another 9/11 because jewish holy warriors keep attacking their neighbors.
| ben77 , |
baltimore usa |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
7. OBAMA IS PLAYING FOR THE 'OTHER' TEAM
so why would he reexamine anything, his moves fall in line with his destructive and suicidal plans for the region
| David P. , |
Capitola, CA |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
8. Two-State
If Israel does not accept the two-state solution,and the US position,
Israel will lose what little support it
now has.In the US Jewish community,supprort for Israel will
drop.Israel ruling over a majority
population of Arabs is looked up
on with disgust by the majority of
our US Jewish community.And the
majority of US Jews support Pres.
Obama on this issue.
| Yochanan , |
P.R./Yasur,US/IS. |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
9. the palestinians will create their own state
the palestinian people through struggle and democratic processes will create their own state. they alone will decide their future and the shape of their society. palestinians must realize if you are to be a nation u must decide on your interest and be ready for the repercussions that might come from those decisions. it was the palestinians excercising their god given rights that brought hamas to power, hamas is a palestinian entity and not a foreign force. all hamas has to answer to is the palestinian people, and now that they are the majority in the govt. they should equip their country with all the necessary tools of defense every other country has. p.s. hamas if israel chanllenges ur sovereignty with f-16 fly overs get some tools that can stop that, thats what every other self-determined nation does to defend its people. hamas buy tanks, aircrafts,guns,bullets,and whatever else u need to defend your people. palestinians declare your own statehood and run your country like a country, who cares what the rest of the world thinks, this is your god given right. declare your state and acquire all that comes along with statehood.
| chilem , |
arlington, usa |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
10. #6 It will be a cold day in hell....
Samantha Powers, one of Obama's top advisors gave a taped interview in 2002 where she advocates that the US should invade Israel to force Israel to stop Israeli genocide against Palestinians and protect Hamas and Fatah.
http://tinyurl.com/ch6adj
But, it will be a cold day in hell before that would happen. The American people will always be friends to Israel, no matter how much Ben and the other nutters wish otherwise.
|
|
11. #8 Two-State
Dear Yochanan,
With all due respect to the USA,Obama,American Jews,who some are my family and friends and the supporters of Obama,this is our life,the ones of us who live in Israel, we should not base our ways,just to please all of the above mentioned,it is us who will live or die on what happens in Israel and not you.
| Don Saliman , |
Nahal Oz, Israel |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
12. Reply from America
Was this guy supported Oslo? Was he supported Baraks intifada in 2000? was he supported Olmert's Lebanon adventure? Was he supported "disengagenets"? Was he supported establishment of Hamas in gaza?
If answers are "YES" then he is real lover of Peace.
| Ruth , |
New York |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
13. 3 STATE SOLUTION
AT ONE TIME, A LONG LONG TIME AGO, BEFORE JUNE 1967, THERE WERE 3 STATES, ISRAEL, JORDAN AND EGYPT. WHAT WOULF BE THE POOSIBILTY OF RETURNING TO A 3 STATE SOLUTION, JORDAN TAKING THE WEST BANK, EGYPT TAKING GAZA AND ISRAEL/ I'D BET THAT JORDAN AND EGYPT WOULD BUY IT. WHAT SAY YOU?
|
|
14. Two State ??
Someone has forgotten there history. For 1400 years the terror of Islam has been spreading around the world like a cancer. Countries once Jewish and Christian now 99% Muslim. One of its latest victims, Lebanon. When the Palistinians can't find an infedel, they kill each other. How can you live in peace with a people not even at peace with themselves.
They've had 60 yrs. to build a country in Gaza. Half of the worlds UN aid goes to Gaza. Yet they chose death and destruction.
| Blue , |
Florida, USA |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
15. Go after the real culprit, Saudi Arabia
The rush for a Palestnin state is to please the Saudi diplomats in Washingrton. Meanwhile, the Saudis fund Ham and even Hizballah too. It is nonsense for Israel to have a "Sauid PeacePlan" that is a wa plan. Saudi Arabiias tll at war with Israel even since 1948. If the Hams attaks d not cease, then bomb Saudi military installations on their northern border with Syria. Wtc higs change, bu get no worse for Israel. There mus never bea Palstinian terror state and that iswhatIsael facilies now forthe US asSaudi agent.
|
|
16. Another dreamer... the better choice is the Sanai Option
Relocate all the palestinians to all of sinai, the world can build them a beautiful new country... and they will be next to their brothers in Gaza. Problem solved.
| LV , |
Jerusalem, Israel |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
17. #5 THE ARAB INHABITANTS OF PALESTINE DIDN'T KNOW THEY WERE A
SEPARATE NATION IN 1948, OR 100 YEARS AGO.
THATS BECAUSE THEY BELONG TO THE ARAB NATION
ALL ARABS SHARE SAME LANGUAGE, SAME CULTURE, AND SAME ANCESTORS AS OTHER ARABS. MANY ARABS CAME TO PALESTINE IN RECENT HISTORY, AS DOCUMENTED DURING THE MANDATE.
TO SAY YOU HAVE DIFFERENT ANCESTORS TO ARABS IN JORDAN
IS SIMPLY NOT TRUE. GOING FURTHER IN HISTORY, YOU HAVE THE SAME ANCESTORS AS ARABS IN SYRIA AND LEBANON AS WELL.
YOU ARE DESCENDENTS OF THE ARAB TRIBES THAT INHABITED THE AREA AND MIGRATED AT SOME POINT TO PALESTINE, IN RECENT OR LESS ECENT HISTORY, & UP TO THIS DAY.
THE PROBLEM IS THAT NOW YOU ARE INSINUATING JEWS HAVE PLOTTED THIS ARAB HISTORY ABOUT YOU, WHICH IS STUPID.
ANCIENT ISRAEL & ANCIENT JUDEA WERE IN JORDAN AS WELL. JEWS AGREE YOU SHOULD HAVE JORDAN, THEY MAKE NO CLAIMS ON PARTS OF THEIR ANCESTRAL LAND IN JORDAN.
SO TO SAY THAT JEWS WANT IT ALL WITHOUT LEAVING PARTS FOR PALESTINIANS IS ALSO NOT TRUE
|
|
18. #6 you saying jewdaism fights islam in a holy war?
first most idf fighters are not religious. second jewish nation are fighting to keep a jewish country for jewish people, most none religious. they are fighting the arab nation and not islam. palestinians belong to the arab nation. they have recently decided they are the palestinian people, to counter zionism, but they are still arabs of the arab nation.
actually ancient israel and judea have extended into jordan, but jews gave it up for the sake of safe borders. that means israel and west bank included in israel.
holy war means to make others followers of a certain religion by force. jewdaism is the only religion set not to convert others to jewdaism. people must accept jewdaism from free will, and even then, jewdaism questions their motives.
| jewdaism &holy war |
|
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
19. the usa nor israel will bring about a palestinian state
the americans, the israelis nor the british can give the palestinians anything. Just like the vietmanese had to create what they wanted so too will the palestinians. You guys can talk about america and israel and what they want to do with the palestinians but nationhood is created by those who are willing to sacrafice all for the sake of the nation. it is only hamas or fatah if they decide to join hamas' national liberation movement that will bring about the palestinian state. and this will be done not by begging or asking, but by taking
| chilem , |
arlington, usa |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
20. No, #18...
All Benn77, aka #6, is doing is expressing his hatred of Israel and Jews. Luckily, the American people do not hold his views.
|
|
21. LET PALESTINIANS GO HOME!
TO JORDAN, THEIR RIGHTFUL HOME!
| Aaron , |
SF, USA |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
22. No, no, no, not America!
YOUR liberals. Congratulations. But rest assured abortion and gay marriage are more important, right?
|
|
23. #13 3 STATE SOLUTION
This is the only solution that could work. Israel wouldn't have any problems, but Egypt and Jordan surely would - since they would then be responsible for their "brothers" (with all consequences).
| Albrecht Klein , |
Germany |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
24. #6 9/11 A HOLY WAR on capitalism, islam is against capitalis
|
|
25. There's no Palestinian people and there shouldn't be a state
Israel should return territory to Jordan and Egypt, not to some artificially created "Palestinian people"
|
|
26. there are arabs in jewish parties, and arabs vote for jewish
parties in israel as well, because some of israel's parties concentrate on issues that involve all citizens. had there not been a resistance on the arab side, jews would involve more arabs in everyday life, namely arabs of WB .
if jews shall leave west bank, arabs shall leave israel. territorial exchange and population exchange are a big problem
if jews are to remain in WB , and WB shall become palestine, would there be more then one dominent arab party? will there be a parties consisting of jews and arabs in WB LIKE IN ISRAEL?
most likely it will be hamas, cause giving up land would give most of them a signal of israel's weakness, and jews shall not become members in it.
|
|
27. Two State "Solution" another "Final Solution?"
Obama is a Greek bearing "gifts." Not to be trusted. He'd sell his birthright and Israel's right to exist for a bowl of porridge.
| Bluto , |
Cincinnati, U.S.A. |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
28. jews are not from palestine go read your tora
The jews descendent from abraham are not from present day israel( israel was created by britian and america alongside the imperialist europeans, they alone created the state of israel so this notion that jews originated from present day palestine is false) go look in the bible and you will see abraham is not from present day israel, he's from iraq. Abraham was born in iraq so for u fake jews who claim that this is your land you need to read your own scriptures and you will see abraham is not from this land, and when abraham got to present day palestine there were people already there so the zionist claim to israel is b.s. pure b.s. i want one of you loyal zionist to dispute the fact that abraham was born in iraq. the zionist claim to israel is b.s. if anything you should be in the ore, iraq looking for the land of your fore father.
| chilem , |
arlington, usa |
|
(04.18.09) |
|
|
29. JORDAN IS PALESTINE - GOOGLE THE HISTORY & EDUCATE YOURSELF
It is 78% of Palestine. mandate (which included modern day Jordan and Israel ).
The term "Palestine" was forced by occupational Roman Empire on the Sovereign Jewish nation within 100 years after Jesus , and after the second massive Roman genocide of the Jews. in 135CE "Palestine" is the latin word for the biblical "Phillistines", an ancient and extinct people and culture that was the an enemy of Israel in even more ancient times (3000 years ago). Furthermore Rome forbade the Jews from resettling there, both when Rome was pagan and when it turned to Christianity. To take over your home's ownership by force, butcher most of your family, sell the remainder into slavery, and rename the street the old enemy of your family is essentially what Rome did.
That said, JORDAN is ruled by a microscopic minority that is from Arabia.; the Hashemite clan that rules Jordan's is less than 0.1% of populace. Whereas "palestinians are 80%!
Its only logical that Jordan return to being "Palestine", and the "2 state solution" be resolved. But of course palestinians will reject this as they have since the United nations offered them a state in 1947., and for the same reason. You see its not them getting a state that is the issue; its the Jews' having one at all. This goes against the fundamental idea of machismo Islam- which ultimately seeks a global caliphate that governs humanity, Islam style. Israel is in the way of that even on their "home turf". So there can be no compromise,and the minority, mostly secular, "moderates" know their children will be shot in front of their eyes by their fellow "palestinians" and they willl have their legs shot, at best, if they dont tow the hamas, hizbollah, arab league, line.
|
|
|
|