Jewish Scene
Report: Obama to visit Buchenwald
Ynet
Published: 08.05.09, 08:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. SO WHAT! BOY IS THIS MAN CHEAP
dmgold ,   Pardes Channa Israel   (05.08.09)
Israels want to live with security and peace. We live in a rough neighbourhood where what appears to be, may be the exact opposite. Obama has been aggresively pushing for the submission of Israel and its restructuring. US- Israel security and defence contacts are strained the frenetic pace Obama is pushing his peace plan along at has become dangerous to Israel. Does Obama and his aids really think the Israeli public are that dumb??? What do they think ? If Obama visits Burchenwald the Israelis and Jews will see him as their freind and someone who can be trusted. Obama wouldnt even offer basic respect and visit the US military Graves at Normandy on D Day this year. THIS MAN IS THE ULTIMATE PRODUCT OF BRANDING AND MARKETING IN THE 21st century. Obama is a phoney and a fraud.
2. He should focus on Busheir, not Buchenwald
(05.08.09)
Does he want the Jews to pat him on the back or something. This guy is unbelievable.
3. why is he going?
Danny   (05.08.09)
so he can get a clear picture of what his policies will acheive in the middle east?
4. Wow!-Seders,Buchenwald, Rahmele...Obama is the Jews friend!
Alan ,   SA   (05.08.09)
5. so he can see first hand how to exterminate jews
Mendy ,   Brooklyn   (05.08.09)
see hoe to run the FEMA camps
6. Stay home Obama, focus on stopping Iran instead!
Mike ,   Raanana, ISRAEL   (05.08.09)
This president is insensitive and stupid to say the least. As he appeases Arab nations against Israel's interest, and shows no backbone (balls) to stop Iran, he is guilt of colluding with the most totalitarian anti-semetic and clearly annilate Israel driven country since Hitler. Enough Mr. Obama. You are not Israel's friend!
7. Typical lefty
Jane   (05.08.09)
Only sympathetic to dead Jews.
8. Obama, the shining left mirage
Gerard ,   Raanana, Israel   (05.08.09)
Each day to come we will regret more and more GW Bush policy. Concerning muslims and meadle east, Obama is going to complete his education on jews account. I hope he is still a smart student. If not, it will be hard time for israelis. It's well known that leftists are always calling the others to pay for their mistakes.
9. obama is a joke. an enemy of america and israel
mira ,   israel   (05.08.09)
2 bad so many jews voted for him.
10. Your guys' hostility towards Obama is unfair.
Aaron ,   SF, USA   (05.08.09)
Is he not allowed to simply visit the place his great uncle went to without having some comment on how it is just him making an image for the Jews and how evil he really is? Oiy, stop being such fanatic reactionaries!
11. Aaron, 10, If Tony Blair pressured Obama to
Darren ,   Oakland, CA   (05.08.09)
give half the US, including Washington, DC to Al-Qaeda, all in the interest of "peace in our time", how would you react? The Jewish people is faced with Churban #3 and our "friends" in high places want us to burn down our own temple so they can drive Hummers and Priuses for $3 a gallon. American interests in the Middle East revolve largely around oil and have very little to do with human rights, if you haven't figured it out already.
12. Is he going to Normandy to apologise to the Germans for WW2
(05.08.09)
13. #11 everything you said is besides the point...
Aaron ,   SF, USA   (05.09.09)
...that he is just visiting the camp his great uncle was at!! This isn't even a piece about his policy! Shouldn't talkbacks be relative to the article?
14. Obama needs to keep Jews calm after his anti-Israel actions
Sue ,   Los Angeles   (05.09.09)
After a week of Obama telling Jordan that UN flags should fly over Jerusalem holy sites and the PA should control the Temple Mount, and Gen'l Jim Jones, Rahmbo and Biden threatening Israel to commit national suicide in exchange for US cooperation on Iran, and treating Israel like an enemy (snubbing Netanyahu, criticizing Israel's nuclear program)...Obama had to think of SOMETHING to calm down those of his Democrat Jewish supporters who, like blind sheep being led to a cliff, don't understand what's happening. Obama thinks this announced visit to Buchenwald (and other little tricks like having a seder at the White House) will be music to Jews' ears.
15. ignorance = wrong reactions
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.09.09)
buchenwald was not a extermination camp as auschwitz was . It was more a camp for political prisoners , inmates died from the harsh work conditions . More than 8000 Russian POW's were shot , "medical" experiments occured . Jews were also inmates there of course .
16. Let us hope such a visit is not a substitute for...
Jehudah Ben-Israel   (05.09.09)
...Israel's demand of its neighbors to recognize its right to exist - and not only the fact that it does - as the nation-state of the Jewish people, an act they have refused to do for the past nearly 62 years and instead have called in their Charters to annihilate the national home of the Jewish people, expel its Jewish population, or worse, and decimate all traces of Jewish civilization of which Israel is its cradle. Will Obama end by paying a visit to the killing fields...??
17. Aaron, give away Yreka-Sacramneto-Fresno to Terrorists!
David P. ,   Capitola, CA   (05.09.09)
you don't understand geography, history if you did you wouldn't support Obama suicidal course of action
18. #10
Jane   (05.09.09)
You are apparently blissfully unaware or uninterested in his evolving policies toward Israel. He is not good for us, which is putting it quite delicately.
19. #13
Jane   (05.09.09)
Relative to the article, taking the article in the context of the whole. That's a good talkback.
20. It'll give him nice cover right B4 he squeezes Israel by the
Ravenswood   (05.10.09)
...throat. Appoint Jews like Axelrod and Rahm, talk sweetly about death camps and 'never again', then enable Iranian mass-murderers and put Israel in range of outright extermination... NICE GOING, JEWS. 78% of you voted for this guy. And you don't have a CLUE as to the danger and blood he will bring to your table. Shame!
21. Nasty Talkbacks About Obama
Christy ,   Boston, US   (05.10.09)
I can understand that people may be nervous about Obama and his relationship to Israel & the Jews. However, I can't understand the nasty comments about his visit to Buchenwald. Obama's great uncle was there and helped to liberate this camp. Seems quite reasonable for him to want to visit the place. I had 4 uncles in WW2 that saw some interesting action in certain places. If I had the money & time I'd visit places I associate with my uncles. I bet many people would like to do the same thing.
22. Obama's telegraphing his moves
moriah ,   sacramento, usa   (05.10.09)
He is easy to read. Obama's going to Buchenwald - he'll look somber, make a comment on feeling for the Jews plight, "never again" , bla bla bla. Then he'll come back and make a comparison of the Shoa and what is happening to balistinians and state "I know the Jews don't want a legacy that has haunted the Germans for the past 60 years." Beace in our time...
23. buchenwald visit
elliot ,   usa   (05.10.09)
obama can compare notes with pope on his visit to yad vashem--it is a mistake to expect the powerful to be toched in a too positive way --perhaps the reverse is more likely. they do not see themselves as agents of evil but power corrupts the mind as well as the wallet.
24. To #21(Christy) and #10(Aaron) - wrong
David ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.10.09)
Obama is in his 40s. There has been nothing to prevent him from visiting until now. The reason he has chosen his presidency to visit is that it provides cover for hostile policy to Israel. Note that later in the same day he'll be delivering a speech in Egypt!!! The reaction to the content of a hostile speech, in Israel (and the Jewish world) will be damped by a picture at a death camp (which he associates himself as a liberator of -however tenuous that connection) Your assertions that visiting Buchenwald isn't policital is false. It's politics at its worst.
25. Give him some slack
Anna ,   Be'er Sheva, Israel   (05.10.09)
I'm not that fond of him myself, but come on, let him visit the concentration camps in peace. He might learn something.
26. Nobama
Craig ,   USA   (05.13.09)
Yet more untruths emitted from this racist socialist. He simply put, cannot tell fact from fiction and I'm sure his "facts" after visiting EU will render yet more untruths.
Back to article