News
Meretz MK wants Israel to give gay Palestinians sanctuary
Amnon Meranda
Published: 15.05.09, 16:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. Where do these guys come from?
Malone ,   Hfx   (05.15.09)
Another pathetic bleeding heart. These people are nauseating.
2. Great idea!
Observor ,   Ramallah, Palestine   (05.15.09)
Please take them all and do whatever you want with them, play, have fun, tickle, or even enroll them into your army. And don’t forget to take Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazin-أبو مازن) and his gang as well. Am Yesrael hai ;-)
3. Is this really fair to gay Pals and their families?
William ,   Israel   (05.15.09)
Letting homosexual Pals into Israel for asylum is an act of kindness but what will be the long-term result? Many currently sneak into Israel to take part in the Gay Pride parades but don't dare expose themselves or their name for fear of retribution by their own family, their neighbors. If they get asylum in Israel, they will be outed, lose any chance to see their family again, and their family might be threatened. So who did it help? The world must work to bring coexistence to the Arab mindset not take in everyone the Arabs deem unworthy to life - gays, infirmed, non-Arab, B'hai, etc.
4. Just the overt ones? or also the closet ones?
Brucie ,   Fire Island   (05.15.09)
If he also means the closet ones , that will solve Abbas's demand for the return of their "refugees"
5. LOL!
Matityahu ,   Slovenia   (05.15.09)
How about palestinians provide for themselves, their homosexuals and mind their business? Besides, Israel is an evil entity, remember?
6. How disappointing
Frank ,   Canada   (05.15.09)
This Leftist clown must be consistent and ask Palestinian gays to start a peace process with Palestinian fanatics. Gay Arabs must withdraw to the 1967 lines, they must dismantle their implantations and accept the bisexual right of return.
7. What? Pals are human rights violators?
JPS ,   Efrat   (05.15.09)
Duh! Funny how Meretz wakes up and takes note of Palestinian gays, yet (aside from ex-MK Yossi Sarid) is pretty much silent about all other Palestinian war crimes and human rights violations. Go to Google images and search for "palestinian collaborator"... warning! The pictures of lynching victims are pretty gruesome. And that's just the Pals against themselves, not to mention their war crimes campaign of suicide bombings, knifings and shootings all aimed at Israeli civilians. No wonder Meretz will probably disappear from the Knesset after the next elections.
8. Yasser Arafat would have qualified for asylum
(05.15.09)
Yes, barmy idea.
9. yasser arafat needed asylum along with the other arab homos
Yoni   (05.15.09)
10. PA Gays Assylum
M. Duvduvani ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (05.15.09)
Horowitz doesn't seem to get it that we are in a war with the Palestinians. As much as I recognize that Arab gays in the PA are not free to be openly gay there, that doesn't obligate us to bring them here. They will just be free to be gay and anti-Israel within our borders. There are already plenty of gays from E.Jerusalem living in Tel Aviv and Yaffo, and yes, they are still anti-Israel with the exception that they can now be openly gay without the risk of being beaten or forced to marry, while they encourage far left elements within Israel to fight for our demise. We would be foolish to offer asylum to PA gays.
11. hey ho
chase me chase me   (05.15.09)
im a pretty fairy called roger cover me with jam im a jammy dodger ooooooohhhhhh ali ahmad
12.  Every Palestinian will "come out of the closet"
Daniel T ,   IsTel Aviv, Israel   (05.15.09)
and this includes Hamas and Islamic Jihad fighters. What an idiotic idea.
13. Yet another Clever Idea from the Leftists who gave us Oslo
Tomer ,   Herzeliyya   (05.15.09)
14. Nitzan Horowitz is gay and must have an arab friend hes.....
Israel has enough   (05.15.09)
trying to save. Please take your friend and move to Europe.
15. population swap or right of return?to no 2
dodik   (05.15.09)
and we'll send you ours?
16. So a gay refugee can return ?
So So al wahsh ,   Pink Pinkland   (05.15.09)
Let me understand this, a refugee cant claim right of return if he/she is not gay? And by the way,,,gay is not new and was known in Palestine thousands of years ago, mainly boys coming from other countries..if you know what I mean !
17. Why????? Call attention to their plight ... yes but ...
EST ,   Miami USA   (05.15.09)
why does Israel have to become their sanctuary? Raise a stink about it at the UN and NGO's around the world. Show the UN and NGO's for what they are, bigots; help publicize their fight for rights but do not make Arab/Muslim gays a burden or a danger to the State!
18. There must be 100,000 / 5% of the population
Liliane ,   Brighton, SX, UK   (05.15.09)
If 5% are gay, there are 100,000 gays to give sanctuary to. This is a stupid idea.
19. doing things like this open flood gates for gays worldwide
zionist forever   (05.15.09)
How many thousands of gay palestinians are there right now? What about lesbians or even straight people who are being persecuted for some reason conected to sexuality? What about the rest of the rest of the arab world where homosexuals are persecuted. if we take arab homosexuals then what about ones from all over the world. You have to be careful what kind of precident you set or else your opening your doors to an influx. Israel can be famous for being the world sancturay for anybody facing persecution over their sexuaity. He is also inviting people to come take part in gay pride parades, does he want Israel to start advertising itself as capital of gay tourism? This is supposed to be the Holy Land not a gay Mecca. He is right to condem persecution by other governments but he has no right to push for Israel to provide sanctuary to gay palestinians. Yossi Belin, Nitzan Horowitz what is it with Meretz do any of them know how things work in the real world?
20. confusion
Ellen ,   Israel/USA   (05.15.09)
I don't get it. The Koran prohibits homosexuality and ask any Arab leader--there are no homsexual Moslems. Besides-even if they were they would be allowed total freedom of choice! The whole world knows that the only country in the World to persecute people different from the mainstream is Israel. Just ask the UN. How can homosexuals feel safe in Israel, which is after all an apartheid state!! What a bunch of hypocrites and fools.
21. Let them in
Maomé ,   Amsterdam   (05.15.09)
YEAH DO IT! Let them in...half of them terrorists will turn Gay. Silly person this Nitzan!
22. He contradicts himself by saying come to Israel
zionist forever   (05.15.09)
If you want governments to stop persecuting their gay population then you don't say Israel should take in the gay palestinians because they are being persecuted because of their sexuality. The message that sends is don't persecute your gay population send them to Israel which will accept anybody who is gay and being persecuted. Ahmadinijad claims there are not gays in Iran, .. he would be right becase he would have had them all rounded up and sent to Israel. If there is a backdoor to dealing with the problem in the form of a place for unwanted gays to go then they will take it, they won't change their attitudes just pass on the problem.
23. Ah-Ha!
Shaul ,   Sheboygan   (05.15.09)
This tolerance for homosexuality is why all the Arabs want to destroy Israel!
24. So, if all Arabs say that they are gay?
Stevie ,   Frisco   (05.15.09)
What is nexst? Move Arafat's grave to N. Tel Aviv? How about moving Meretz and all non-religiuos gays to Ramallah , from S. Francisco - under the rights of return.
25. No problem with gays - but let Egypt take them
israel   (05.15.09)
Gay Jews are welcome in Israel
26. One third of Meretz MK's are openly gay ..
redbourn ,   tel aviv   (05.16.09)
27. Let's get it straight:
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (05.16.09)
We (Israel) have enough to do to support Jews emigrating (and sometimes fleeing) from their own countries into Israel. Also, it's unwise to let the Arab countries off the hook. Let's give them as many reasons as we can to evolve into democratic republics. Accepting their own kind, including their homosexual populations, would be a start.
28. Why stop at palestinian gays?
:-)   (05.16.09)
We should bring all gays from all muslim countries! This way there will be no need for "the right of return". The country will be swamped with muslim gays and we can hold marches 24/7. It'll be a riot!
29. I must have heard wrong...
Jasmin ,   Haifa   (05.16.09)
I could have sworn Israel was the Jewish homeland. I suppose Nitzan Horowitz would prefer it to be the "Gay Homeland" instead. Ben Gurion must be turning over in his grave!
30. My dream is to have a day of solidarity within Islam
Yaakov Sullivan ,   NY   (05.17.09)
with its gays. We Muslims need to open up to homosexuality within us. Homosexuality within Islam is the most beautiful thing. A ver famous Imam in the West Bank is a homosexual and the late Yaser Arafat was a homosexual. Unfortunately he needed to cover it up and even to get married. Hopefully in the future Palestinians can be proud to have a first gay president.
Next talkbacks
Back to article