News
Clinton: No official Bush-era deal with Israel on settlements
AFP
Published: 06.06.09, 07:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. like da, why don't they just ask bush if he agreed or not !?
phone the ranch   (06.06.09)
2. AMERICAN LIARS
(06.06.09)
3. Israel needs to stand firm and look out for its own ...
Dave Ronen ,   Haifa   (06.06.09)
Israel needs to stand firm and look out for its own interests for a change. Tiny Israel is too small for two states, especially when the Arab group takes joy in massacring Jews. The Arabs own 99.9% of the Middle East. They have the space to place ALL the Arabs who claim to be Palestinian –– without cramping. They have the money to settle the Palestinians, especially if the money now spent on the Arab "refugees" is added in. And why should there not be room in the Middle East with its 22 Arab states for a single Jewish State? In fact, when you think about it, the major question is: where should the Palestinian arabs be resettled? that and the need for Israel to stand firm and look out for its own interests for a change. More at : http://xrl.us/bi5c8
4. 280, 000 settler dotted throughout
Steve   (06.06.09)
the west bank, must go home inside Israel. They can become Palestinians, if they wish
5. Be strong and of good courage
Neil Turner ,   Watford, UK   (06.06.09)
I think that Israel must now recognise that the USA, under Obama, is no longer your best friend in the world Sure there are Americans who love you and will support you, but the US Administration is hell-bent on sacrficing Israel to Islam, much as Europe sacrificed Czechoslovakia in the 1930's. I read a lovely piece on Ynet a few days ago - a Rabbi who extolled you to stand up to pressure, as to yield would only invite more pressure. Humanly speaking, this is the road to disaster. But Israel is not a product of human endeavour. As a Christian who loves Israel, I believe that your God is with you, and He will watch over you Be strong and of good courage, and remind yourselves of those Hebrew men and women of old who put their faith in God and were not disappointed
6. Boomerang
Michael ,   Haifa   (06.06.09)
This is pay-back time for years of our stupidity, arrogance and trickery.
7. To #5: Maybe He needs new glasses!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.06.09)
We all appreciate your support but I am afraid the He, if there is a He, has not been looking our way for quite some time. I am sure that Gilad Shalit and his family would appreciate a little more "watching over him"!
8. It is Israel's Land
Brod ,   USA   (06.06.09)
It is Israel's land. Israel does not need approval from Bush or anyone in developing its own liberated historic homeland of Judea and Samaria. Hillary is wrong on this. Now her true Suha-kissing-color has emerged. It is time they know the history of the Middle East before they spew their crap. For too long they have been imbibing the cesspool of Islamist-Jihadist Taqiyyah (Deception) that they allowed themselves to be misled by the propaganda of the Islamist-Jihadist world. Modern Israel is in their Ancient Land of Israel. It is none of the business of other countries to be intruding in Israel's internal affairs.
9. Tread carefully
Marty ,   USA   (06.06.09)
Obama's goal is to get Israel angry and thereby cause friction between the U.S. and Israel. In other words he is looking for a fight by giving impossible conditions. He will then use his personal popularity to diminish Israel in the eyes of many Americans. This battle needs to be fought in the U.S. and that means we need many liberal Jews to wake up and start writing their congressman. Jewish Americans could have been helpful to my family and others that were destroyed in the Holocaust by putting pressure on their Democratic congressman. They didn't. Will they be guilty now as well?
10. The "Roman" "Empire" strikes again!!
Clinton = snake!   (06.06.09)
11. "ORAL DEAL EXISTS"
Monica Lewinsky ,   Safed Israel   (06.06.09)
12. Former deputy mayor of Jerusalem is correct.
Ypip ,   Canada   (06.06.09)
And Meron Benvenisti's idea is quite different different from Obama's vision, that is: Maintain the status quo. Manage the conflict. There is no solution in the near future. A single state must be continually worked upon and structured into a consociational democracy. It is the only way to deal with such symbolic issues such as Jerusalem. The aspirations of both people would best be served by such a state.
13. To #7: He has 20/20 vision
Neil Turner ,   Watford, UK   (06.06.09)
Hi David There's nothing wrong with His sight :) He watches over Israel as a hen watches over its chicks. 2Ch 16:9 says "For the eyes of the LORD run to and fro throughout the whole earth, to shew himself strong in the behalf of them whose heart is perfect toward him" Note the condition. Israel must turn to God, cry out to Him. Your history is littered in miracles.... I can't think of any other nation that came into being 2000 years after it was scattered through the nations As far as Gilad Shalit is concerned, I have prayed for him daily since the day of his capture. I am in faith that he will be free
14. RE: Expansion Settlements
Edward Anderson ,   Savannah, USA   (06.06.09)
If I were Jewish, I'd be highly offended with what the US is doing to Israel about the settlements. Israel is essentially being told by it's black US Pharoah that ALL Jewish babies must be thrown in the river, to appease the Muslims and that NO GROWTH will be TOLERATED!!! Last I recalled, Barak Hussein Obama IS AN ARABIC NAME, NOT AMERICAN/JEWISH!!! DO THE MATH!!!
15. Gey in Draird
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (06.06.09)
16. Hillary--first apply it to your family!
Larry G. ,   Hamilton, Canada   (06.06.09)
So Hillary, in terms of demanding that the Jews must cease and desist building in Judea & Samaria even regarding cases of natural growth; we demand that your daughter, Chelsea be forbidden to have any children! Also in order to further appease Muslim anger, Chelsea must be forbidden to purchase land that already has a house on it and be prohibited to buy any empty lot to build a house on. Instead she must be forced to live with her parents! If you agree to these terms, then and only then will we give any consideration to your boss's demands!
17. Israel Is Partly To Blame
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (06.06.09)
Once upon a time,Israelis acted like men..with courage ,pride and self-respect.Now they ask permission from America for every little thing,like little children.Please Mrs.Clinton can I go to the Toilet?.Do I have your permission? how the mighty have fallen and have become Schmattes.(Smartootim in hebrew.)
18. Same Clinton who kissed Arafat's wife
Semsem ,   New York, USA   (06.06.09)
The same Clinton who kissed Arafat's wife after making an antisemitic outburst.
19. Bill makes millions off the Arabs. She an EX New York Senato
Fortunee ,   New York, USA   (06.06.09)
Bill makes a fortune off money paid by the Arabs to him. There is a conflict here with his wife as the Secretary of State. Boy she's changed since being the Senator of New York. A 2 faced hypocrite.
20. Hillary lackey of Saudis
Ora ,   Canada   (06.06.09)
She has always been a lackey of the Saudis and other Arab donors. And, by the way, who listens to her? ex-Mayor Giulliani was the only honest one who refused Arab donations following 9/11 because it came with "strings attached regarding Israel"
21. On US Leaders' Job Descriptions and Impartiality
Fair-Minded ,   usa   (06.06.09)
I voted for Pres. Obama because I think he is a brilliant, fair-minded reflective person who is uniquely qualified to lead our country BUT... If Pres. Obama and Sec. Clinton want the US to be taken seriously as an IMPARTIAL interlocuter for the Israeli-Palestinian Mid-East process, they cannot be perceived by EITHER SIDE as being biased or as creating demands that pressure either party. Their job is to MEDIATE the negotiations between the parties and try to get them to agree to a fair compromise to their conflict. They will get NOWHERE with the Israeli gov't or the Israeli public if the perception becomes that they are trying to apply "pressure" (i.e. extortion!) by threatening to withdraw support. Likewise, they can almost certainly expect a backlash from BOTH Israelis AND Palestinians if they think their job is dictating the terms in order force a settlement to the dispute. They cannot on the one hand meddle in the affairs of another country or would-be country and on the other act like they are being fair and impartial. IT JUST WON'T WORK.
22. #19 Clinton hasn't changed 1 bit; she's still a 2-faced
Hillary Unveiled ,   USA   (06.06.09)
hypocrite. This is because she uses social action as her modus operandus to achieve her true aspirations, which are power and greed.
23. Can we believe
Fred ,   Netanya   (06.07.09)
the mouth that kissed Suha(sewer) Arafat?
24. we must build more settlements
tom   (06.07.09)
with all due respect, neither clinton nor obama is god. we do not bow to anybody but god. we may seem fanatical, but we do not kill. we tell the truth. this land belons to the jews as envisioned in the bible. no ifs &s or buts. look what happen to both the leaders who gave up territory. this is an obvious sign grom god. just look at sharon & olmert. tzippi is licking out because she has not led yet. look what happen to poor begin. And look at the us presidents who tried to push us. where is bill clonton now with all his disgrace? where is jimmy carter with all his itelligence. who even respects him? obama will probably fall too. hillary may fall too.
Back to article