Opinion
Why does Iran hate us?
Isaac Ben-Israel
Published: 29.06.09, 19:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
31. Avi #23 I hate Shas even more than you do
avi   (06.30.09)
for different reasons though but their hate of gays CANNOT be compared to nazis in any way and you should apologize.
32. Iran doesn't hate Israel
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (06.30.09)
Iran hates the US for deposing Mossadeq and the Shah, for installing the Ayatollas and then helping the Arabs in the Iran Iraq war Iran hates the Arabs for killing 1 million Iranians with gas and Scuds. By publicly hating Israel, Iran gets credibilty in the Muslim world, credibility that gives them time to make nukes for protection from American attack and to destabilize the Arab regimes.
33. It's not me. It's you.
Gideon Reader   (06.30.09)
Nah. Iran's hate is based on a singular personal dislike of the author of this column himself. Come to think of it. I am not so thrilled with him either.
34. What a crock
Ben ,   Rockville,MD   (06.30.09)
Our existence proves Islam is nonsense and a big lie. That is why all Moslems hate us. Iranians are little more vocal.
35. Well, maybe its because of Israel's aggression against Iran
Tarik ,   Boston, MA USA   (06.30.09)
Israel armed and trained the SAVAK secret police that terrorized Iranians under the brutal Shah regime, and Israel allied itself with the Shah to oppress Iranians. That is an excellent reason why Iranians don't like Israel. Plus, Iranians can see the sort of terrorism Israel visits upon Palestinians every day. It doesn't matter if they are "brothers" or not--people all across the world see Israel's brutal aggression and respond naturally. In short, Iranians don't like Israel for the same reason as everyone else: Israel is a racist, terrorist state. On the other hand, Zionists have an impressive ability to craft self-serving explanations for their own diplomatic failure and to deny reality.
36. Ancient Empire Building?
Gerofsky ,   Newark, USA   (06.30.09)
I'm not sure if I believe this, but for the sake of argument: Iran has a long and proud history going back to Biblical times. For many centuries before and after Mohammad, Persia ruled the Middle East, including the Jews AND the Arabs. Ancient dreams die hard in the Middle East. Could Israel be a pawn in the dream of restored Persian dominance over the Arab lands, as much as it would be a desired colony itself? The Revolutionary Guard now seem in charge, and those are the guys who fought and lost a war in Iraq to export the Khomeini Revolution to Arab soil. Perhaps they want a second chance? A threat to destroy Israel is effectively a threat against Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Syria, etc. Again, this sounds too fantastic to believe. But ditto for Pearl Harbor on Dec. 6, Nine-Eleven on Sept. 10, etc. It's probably not the case -- but again, Biblical-era dreams and Mohammad-era dreams die hard amidst the Persians, as well as with the Arabs AND the Jews. Just something to think about.
37. #35 get real
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (06.30.09)
Savak were boy scouts compared to the interrogators of any Arab country, the Hamas or Fatah. Have you heard of torture that Haitham Abdallah Amr suffered before being murdered by Fatah? It makes Tarantino look like an amateur. Do you think that Iranians really care about a few tortured Mullahs after the murder of 1 million Iranians with gas? Or after Ahmadinejad sent his Arab Basji to "quell protests"? Speak to real Persians and you will hear that they want to get rid of the Mullahs and join Israel in the 21st century.
38. Maybe They Hate You Because Of the Constant Threats ....
World Citizen ,   the world   (06.30.09)
Your Leaders Issue Against Them? They are not threatening to bomb your nuclear facilities with nuclear weapons. Your leaders are. They have signed the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. Israel hasn't. They have been in one war in the last 60 years and they didn't start it. Iraq did. Israel on the other has been the aggressor in every war in the last 60 years except for Yom Kuppur. Iran occupies no other people's land. Israel on the other hand, has been in violation of the Geneva Convention since 1967. It occupies the West Bank and Jerusalem. It is amazing the read these articles and the posts of the average Israeli on this site. Israelis don't seem to have clue that the paradigm in which the civilized world views them has changed dramatically. We don't see you as the victims you claim to be. You are the aggressors and have been for as long as the modern state of Israel has lasted. Your nation is a racist pariah. You are not hated becuase you are jews. You're hated because of the evil you do unto the less powerful people living amongst and around you.
39. Thank you for the clear explanation ..
redbourn ,   tel aviv   (06.30.09)
40. #35 - I think you replied to the wrong article ..
martin ,   tel aviv   (06.30.09)
nothing that you wrote seems relevant to this article. Please check to see if what you wrote might have meaning elsewhere. Martin
41. #38,You may be talking till you get blue
(06.30.09)
in your face, you may build up your theories on paradigms as you put it, you may even blow yourself up with so much hatred, you may even get deluded about who attacked who during all of Israel's wars of defense, or, you may rationalize your hatred. In the end it all comes down to your ugly, disgusting, barbarian, primitive, animalic hatred...of Jews, that is. One can see a Jew hater from a thousand miles when one sees one. And you my "friend" are one of them.
42. Iranians hate their own government
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (06.30.09)
I seriously doubt if the Iranians really care one way or the other about us. The theocracy in Iran will implode, that is just a matter of time.
43. #41 Everyone Who Dares Question Israel Is Jew Hater
World Citizen ,   the world   (06.30.09)
according to people like you. But what you are doing is called "projection" in psychoanalysis. You are projecting your hatred of the world onto me and the world. I don't hate Israel or Jews. But I do hate what you are doing to the Palestinian people and the Middle East. And I do have the right and the obligation to say something about it. If I hated Jews I wouldn't be on here telling you that you must change. I'd say nothing and watch your nation crumble from i the weight of its own corruption and hatred. You and your fellow countrymen can choose to ignore people like me. But you do it at your peril. When Israel falls don't blame us. We told you that you were doing was wrong. You ignored us.
44. Wouldn't buy this idea alone for ten cents
bobo ,   Mechanicsburg USA   (07.01.09)
So you're saying (or not saying) that Jewish has nothing to do with it? I can't buy that. This idea is so simplistic and actually apoligetic for their hatred of Israel and it also disregards the build in sham of a religio/political belief system born in and encouraging hate and intolerance. Somehow I missed that part in your article.
45. Kidding Yourself
bobo ,   Mechanicsburg USA   (07.01.09)
NO! If you question Israel it is not anti-Jew you do have a right and obligation to do that, although you are pretty snotty with your opinion. When you question, critize and blame Israel and Jews for all the Arab's problems without giving at least equal and (in my opinion obviously more) blame to the Arabs them selves, you are a Jew hater Mr./Ms. World Citizen. Don't kid yourself, your not kidding anyone else.
46. IDIOT
bobo ,   Mechanicsburg USA   (07.01.09)
You World Citizen are an idiot!Just one comment before i leave you for ever. If you're so proud of Iran putting their Ahmad Henry on the dotted line with the Nuke Non-Pro Treaty, and you are saying that because Israel didn't sign it, what are they doing proliferating nukes then? DUH! BYE IDIOT
47. This is what you believe
Rods alfo ,   Tehran   (07.01.09)
I wonder why you wonder Mr Ben Israel. Iran does not hate Jewsh or hebrew but what is inside your heart is telling you that they hate you so it means you are the one who is hating not them
48. #38 World Ignoramus
Cynthia ,   USA   (07.01.09)
If you're going to rattle your cage in front of your computer, at least make an effort to learn the historical facts. Israel has been involved in several wars, all started by Arab aggression, including the War in Gaza (9000 kassams and bombs preceded Israel's response). The Yom Kippur, not Kupper war was another example as was the War of Independence in '48 when seven Arab countries and militias attacked Israel. The Iranian Regime feeds the same propaganda and cliches to the Iranian people so the Regime can continue their Jihad against the west. The Regime tries desperately to isolate the Iranian people from the outside world so they can continue their lies. But hate destroys the haters. Just look at what's happening in Iran.
49. How about Israeli hatred?
Goolam ,   JhbSouth Africa   (07.01.09)
Every post-colonial culture sees the Israeli project as nothing more than proxy colonialism. No country in modern history has faced more neo-imperialism than Iran. Effectively having to fight the USA in Iraq and dealing with efforts to overthrow Iranian attempts at self-actualised democracy. Secondly, I have never read more paranoid, religious fanatics (read this post) and racist (anti-Arab) comments from as I have from Zionists and Israelis. Iran knows that Israel is effectively a racist military dictatorship and the roots of their revolution cannot allow them to be silent on the matter. But its not only Iran that voices these facts, but many other non-Muslim countries as well. Hate? Get over yourself.
50. The Iranians hate us because...
Steve   (07.02.09)
their religion tells them to. Direct from the Quran and Hadith: "O ye who believe! Take not the Jews and the Christians for friends. They are friends one to another. He among you who taketh them for friends is (one) of them. Lo! Allah guideth not wrongdoing folk." - Quran 5:51 "The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His messenger and strive to make mischief in the land is only this, that they should be murdered or crucified or their hands and their feet should be cut off on opposite sides or they should be imprisoned; this shall be as a disgrace for them in this world, and in the hereafter they shall have a grievous chastisement" - Quran 5:33 "Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued." - Quran 9:29 "Allah's Apostle said, "The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Jews, and the stone behind which a Jew will be hiding will say. "O Muslim! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kill him." - Hadiths (Bukhari 52:177)
51. Why Iran hates Israel
Rick Abner ,   Knoxville, U.S.   (07.15.09)
Israel has become an example of success in the mideast. Their land is coveted. Iran desires the success Israel has achieved but is unable to obtain it in the present form of government. So they therefore choose to hate what they cant have.
52. Help for Palestinians
Mona Pellerin ,   Maggie Valley, USA   (09.29.09)
It seems if the Muslims wish for everyone to embrace Islam, they would be better neighbors to the world. It would seem that help in the way of economics would be a better choice over the hate messages that Iran chooses to send to the West. Don't they get tired of war and killing under the name of God?
53. Maybe this is part of the reason for demonizing Israel but
BeachJustice ,   new york, new york   (10.08.10)
I dunno, it seems a little to convenient to argue "Iranian leadership doesn't like new stuff, and the west represents new stuff. So it is going to war with the west". Firstly Iran repeatedly has shown a desire to compete in the domains of sci/tech, secondly Iran has offered to HELP the US at the onset of the Iraq war. The daily occurrences and actions of the leadership make me think something else is going on with them behind the scenes, they have other goals, including the revolutionary guard.
54. israel
israeliteindeed ,   Australia   (02.05.12)
Why cant the Arabs destroy Israel. Because Israel is the Kingdom of God. Please read the scriptures. The return of the Jews to their land is Bible Prophecy.Now they await their King who will sit on the Throne of David as promised. God said they will never be moved again. Why cant people see this great prophecy being fulfilled now.
55. Israel-Iran
Jim ,   Santa Cruz , Ca USA   (08.28.13)
I've always wondered what exactly Iran has against Israel, as the 2 have never had any armed conflicts, as far as I know. In my humble opinion perhaps the reason is Iran not only not being Arab nor a Sunni nation like the majority of the middle east Arab states, wants to be the dominant country in the mid east, and they believe being the most anti-Israel country in the region will help them attain that end. Even though Saddam Hussein was a tyrant he kept Iran in check, now that he's gone Iran's influence and boldness has increased.
56. Iran doesn't hate Israel people
sara ,   Iran   (02.17.15)
Iranian doesn't hate Israel people,we hate war and cruetly,and fighting with cruetly Www.masaf.ir
57. Haha
Sage ,   Iran   (05.03.16)
Iranians don't hate you! If you don't believe me go back and study yiur history. We saved your hide 3x. Two times recorded in bible the most recent one during WWII. You brokered weapons deal during one of our darkest hours and we thank you for it. Return the next two favors and we call it even :)
58. lol
Siavash ,   Tehran   (12.22.16)
LoL, it's not about western culture. Its about Zionism
Previous talkbacks
Back to article