News
Moscow circus presents monkeys as Jews
Yael Levy
Published: 13.07.09, 13:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. well i must admit there is a similarity between
AVI ,   ISR   (07.13.09)
The Monkey and Eili Yishai
2. Boker Tov, Good Morning, Dobri Utra
Pavel Petrovich ,   Netanya   (07.13.09)
Di you think Russia has become Baalei teshuva? That they repented? We have lived with this kind of incitement from the days of the Czars, the Pogroms, Lenin's Bolsheviks,Stalin's purges, the GPU, NKVD, etc. Nothing changes just faces
3. I don't think it's anti-Semeitc
Israel   (07.13.09)
I think it's pure backwardness - lets not forget Russia lived behind an iron curtain - they are primitive and backward and have clearly not been brought up to date on what is acceptable and what isn’t. They probably don’t care anyway.
4. bad taste
Lisa   (07.13.09)
ignorance and bad taste- Russian style-
5. Please......
(07.13.09)
Dont insult monkeys!
6. Circus Wedding
Roscoe ,   Portugal   (07.13.09)
People need to get over it !!! Geeezz!!!! If it were a Christian wedding----would the Christians get all worked up over it ??? If it were a skit depicting ANY other ethnic group---no one would say squat !!!
7. to #6 than y jewish than from all minorities
ghostq   (07.13.09)
in the world? making fun of someone else customs as a circus act. simple because it's jewish and they find other people faith funny.
8. At least they're not blacks
Steve from Raleigh   (07.13.09)
Because that would be racist. Do liberals even believe Jews are humans?
9. Pathetic Russian "Humor"
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (07.13.09)
Clearly targeted at an audience whose IQ is probably close to that of the performing monkeys, it would be difficult to have these primates perform as drunken, corrupt and lazy fools, which would probably hit a little too close to home for this lot.
10. #5 Please!
Jewish monkey   (07.13.09)
would you also brave enough to publish your email address and name? Please! Thank you.
11. NEXT TIME MAKE IT OBAMA
Petra ,   USA   (07.13.09)
DARE YOU. RUSSIA IS GOING TO HELL IN AN ANTI SEMITIC HAND BASKET. SHE CAN'T AFFORD TO FEED HER OWN BUT, HEY! DISPLAY YOUR IGNORANCE AT A CIRCUS. WHEN WAS RUSSIA NOT ANTI SEMITIC?
12. PETA should be informed immediately
Or Angutan   (07.13.09)
I find the whole thing absolutely anti-chimpitic. .
13. No, this is not just "bad taste". This is anti-Jewish racism
Svetlana ,   Vilna, Lithuania   (07.13.09)
14. GOOD GOOD ! I AM GOING TO GO TO MOSCOWWWW :)
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (07.13.09)
15. Meanwhile how many "monkeys" got prize Nobel?
m   (07.13.09)
You all the analphabets out there who are happy with the stupid article, just ask this question. But you probably know the answer. Many of you won't even be alive today if not for Jonas Salk (ask someone who he was)
16. Not politically correct.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (07.13.09)
Bad taste, I'd say so. A bit anti-Semitic? Considering Russian history, yes. But this rather tasteless display of un-political correctness pales before the really nasty anti-Semitic displays in the Arab & Muslim world which are filled with hate & dehumanization. All things considered, we don't have to be so thin-skinned.
17. OK, if is is so inoffensive and funny...
Roscio ,   Rome, Italy   (07.13.09)
Then why not also do a monkey version of a MUSLIM wedding? Want to start a betting pool on how many performances before the tent is burned down and the monkeys beheaded?
18. #17 you make a good point
usa   (07.13.09)
19. The more things change ...
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (07.13.09)
the more they stay the same.
20. to #14 good stay there they need other
ghostq   (07.13.09)
country's mental patient such as yourself.
21. Context is everything. If they had used trained seals
usa   (07.13.09)
instead of monkeys, everyone would have laughed and thought it was adorable. However, given that chimps and monkeys are often used as metaphors for dehumanizing ethnic groups like blacks and Jews, I can see why people would be offended. I for one am not offended and in fact I think it's hilarious, even though it is bad taste. Only uptight Jews eschew comedy with bad taste. Mel Brooks is the king of bad taste when it comes to ethnic jokes, and Jews seem to have no problem laughing at those jokes. Let's lighten up a bit, folks.
22. By the way ....
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (07.13.09)
It's the context that makes it obnoxious, the fact that this is in Russia, known for being a rather anti-Semitic country. Had this same act been done here in Israel, we might have all had a good laugh.
23. to #17 so true
ghostq   (07.13.09)
they will peacfully laugh like they always do, muslems r known for good spirit.
24. Different reactions depend on one's experience
usa   (07.13.09)
Those who have directly experienced anti-semitism will be very offended. Those who haven't will think it is just bad taste. Others think it's funny because they simply don't care if anti-semites hate them and refuse to be embarassed for their Jewishness, prefering instead to see the anti-semites themselves as the ones who are primitive and sub-human.
25. erm,.. i saw many shows of animals marrying
S.   (07.13.09)
each other. Christian way. That was never considered to be an insult towards Christians. I see no difference towards the Jewish themes. Note also that only the people getting married are the monkeys. In my opinion the claim is too far fetched.
26. add to #5,10 Jewish monkey email
Jewish monkey   (07.13.09)
Sorry, my email is: valery.pepper@gmail.com Waiting for your details now.
27. Oh Sarah...... #19
Terry ,   Chicago, IL   (07.13.09)
If it were an "Arab wedding" you would have a smile that is 4-foot wide on your face.
28. #17 Are you suggesting that Jews have as little humour
(07.13.09)
as Muslims? pity
29. It's one thing if the Russians make fun of themselves
Chaiya ,   Israel   (07.13.09)
But to make fun of other people is - if not outright anti-Semitism (in this case) - in extremely bad taste. And I thought that the Russians had class!
30. See how long the circus lasts if it were
jason white ,   afula,israel   (07.13.09)
a moslem wedding.
Next talkbacks
Back to article