Your efforts are much appreciated and, even if they do not result in bringing Gilad home, they certainly do help to bring greater respect for our Beduin citizens.

However the Israeli government must recognize the pain and suffering for the thousands of Palestinians held in israeli dungeons, many of them without trial or even accusation. Including women and children!

...and support any action for rescuing any IDF soldier from captivity regardless of his/her enthnicity and religion! Whomever risks his/her life to protect ours, deserves not only our respect and recognition, but also our relentless, determined and dedicated support in time of need.

Nour, let's clarify several myths: 1. Noam Shalit was KIDNAPPED across the interantionally recognized borders. He was guarding the border. That was his "crime". 2. The "thousands of Palestinians" were arrested either for planning or perpetrating terror attacks against innocent civilians. Hundreds of them even "succeeded" in murdering innocent children on their way to school and civilians in buses or in public markets. They are CONVICTED murderers or murder planners. 3. Despite these facts, these "thousands of Palestinians" get Red Cross visits, family visits, attorney visits, get to STUDY and achieve university degrees while in jails and even WORK sending $ to their families. That's a LUXURIOUS DUNGEON, don't you think??? 4. And yes, Noam Shalit is held in real Dungeons, used as a human shield by the Hamas leaders during Cast Lead who hid behind his underwear in bunkers under the only Hospital in Gaza. He is still being used as a human shield. 5. Noam Shalit was never visited by the Red Cross, nor family, attorneys and definitely is not able to study and enrich his life with a university degree. He is being held like a rat and tortured and abused by his inhuman palestinian abductors. Now let's NEVER FORGET THE DIFFERENCE Nour!

But the palestinians held in Israel are getting food, visiters, the family knows were they are!! etc etc...

a very good talkback, but Noam is the father, the soldier's name is Gilad.

Bedouin are muslim arabs who serve in the army to defend the jewish state. Does not exactly match your insitments about arabs..

1. that fed terrorist samir kuntar. he looked rather round upon release. he was a cold blooded murderer of a child 2. those free speech and reporters coming into these so called dungeons to interview samir kuntar, marwan barghuti and many other terror prisoners in those "dungeons" 3. they all see sun light which shalit has not seen in three years. 4.they all see their families on weekends and have conjugal visits with their wives. shalit has never had the opportunity to date and kiss a girl. 5. they are all visited by the red cross and their family and relatives know where they are, under which conditions and how their health is. 6. most prisoners like barghutte and kuntar received their higher education and master degrees from israeli universities coming into those "dungeons" to educate them. they all received diplomas on our tax dollar for free...then they got out and joined a terrorist group again vying tob kill more jews. THEY ARE NOT INNOCENT, MY DEAR. THEY WERE CAUGHT RED HANDED IN ACTS OF MURDER AND TERROR UPON INNOCENT CIVILIANS AND THIS IS WHY THEY ARE ALL IN JAIL. WOMEN TOO, CAUGHT WITH SUICIDE BELTS ON THEM. WOULD YOU FREE THEM TOO? AS TO CHILDREN, WE ALL SAW WHAT THE PALESTINIANS DO TO CHILDREN. there are 5 children, well, not children. they are 17-19 that occupied themselves with terrorism and therefore got incarcerated. you don't want your son in jail, keep him in school or at home where he can't by approached by terrorists using his naivite and body to detonate innocents. 17-20 is not children. they should know right from wrong. compalin to iran. they just executed 143 young boys and girls even for homosexuality and "indecency" in public just this year, ranging from 14-19. executions, hangings and stonings. now, that is what should piss you off, my dear. that is what you should scream against. also, how is hamas treating fatah prisoners??? even youth???? beatings, hangings, shootings, chopping hands and feet, execution style shooting at knee caps, etc... that also should piss you off my dear. if you didn't concentrate too much on israeli prisons who are palaces compared to those in your arab lands, you'd have much more time to save your women and children from the utrocious sharia laws in your countries, utrocious human rights abuses aND UTROCIOUS POLICE STATES AND REPRESSION EXISTING IN THE LANDS OF YOUR PEOPLE. SHAME ON YOU! HAMEED ABOUGHAZE IRANIAN tell me one thing of the above that looks like a dungeon