News
Mount Hebron: Leftists bring Palestinians water
Olga Gouresky
Published: 27.09.09, 13:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
22 Talkbacks for this article
1. I hope it was Bottled from the Dead Sea
Roland Seener ,   London England   (09.27.09)
2. Supplying water to Arab squatters
Israeli mum   (09.27.09)
The action by Leftist activists is simply provocative and presumably makes them feel like heros. In this situation the Israel government actually supplies people who are the responsibility of the PA. This is a humanitarian action, done without fanfare and reference to Carmel, which please remember pays taxes and water rate same as the rest of Israeli citizens.
3. Talk to UNRWA
steve from raleigh   (09.27.09)
I'm sure in another 60 years they'll get it sorted out.
4. Funny
Bill ,   Portland USA   (09.27.09)
Why instead of a picture of water being transported, the picture shows people being transported like cattle. Seems to be just a stunt and no water went to the villages.
5. WHERE IS ALL THE MONEY THAT IS GIVEN TO THE PA?????
Brian ,   Tel Aviv   (09.27.09)
WHY ISN'T IT PROVIDING WATER!!!!
6. SAD!
(09.27.09)
Poor thing they don't care about the thousands of jews who dont have enough food...
7. water
colin   (09.27.09)
NO WATER. NOT WET.. Terible.All the donations and money ffrom the anti Israel UN spent on rockets and not water lines???Where is Goldstein to investigate and report to the UNSC on the humanterian suffering because the pipes were used for pipe bombs instead of transporting water.Let the leftests also not have water,What a waste!!!!
8. Look at the guy on the tractor
Cameron ,   USA   (09.27.09)
Dragging along a whole, heavy load of self-righteous. Quite a load of tools for the Arabs to use.
9. #5 because Israel has tapped the aquifers
Wanda ,   Montreal   (09.27.09)
10. I don't see water, I see a bunch of lefties
Israeli   (09.27.09)
Did they bring small bottles of mineral water so the poor "Palestinians" won't have to drink tap water? I remember how Carter said Gazans are dying of hunger, then they said the meat we're supplying them for Ramadan isn't soft enough so they must import better meat through the tunnels. Hunger indeed.
11. Stolen Water
Hisham ,   Palestine   (09.28.09)
That area is considered "C" area in the Palestinian Israeli agreements which the P A is not allowed to work there. The problem is that Israelis pump water from West Bank to Israel and the settlements and they sell a little of the Palestinian stolen water to the Palestinians who are not in area C where Palestinians are denied having water networks or electricity.
12. i don't know what's worse
Israeli   (09.28.09)
The nasty inhuman talkbacks, the branding of being humanistic and helpful as "leftist" or the exaggerations of the Israeli and Palestinian activists who only loo at the picture through a particular victim lens. No one has rational conversations in this region.
13. Bring water to the Pals.
Yochanan   (09.28.09)
As a Jew,I find these talk-backs mostly sad.We can disagree with the political goals of the Pals.Yet just as many X'ers were happy to see our fellow Jews loaded onto trains for the death-camps.Thinking we Jews were sub-human.Now we read in these talk-backs that many Jews think that the Pals. are sub-human.
14. Heartless
Truthseeker ,   USA   (09.28.09)
If some of the posters here are representative of Israeli Jews then Israel was a terrible idea. There was a time when Jews were compassionate but now I see Jews acting toward the Palestinians, in many ways as Germans acted toward Jews. And now you even attack our fellow Jews who display the humanity that you and all too many Israelis sorely lack. Hope you repent on Yom Kippur.
15. Just another anti Israel publicity stunt
jason white ,   afula,israel   (09.28.09)
by anti Zionist leftists. Would the arabs do the same for Jews? Furthermore who give the amounts in ounces?
16. Water? Where is the water?
Aviva ,   Jerusalem   (09.28.09)
I see a bunch of people crammed into a trailer, for a photo op. For the same amount of trouble and money they could have loaded up a truck with cases of mei eden.
17. Yom Kippur
Ricardo Macher ,   KarneiShomron Israel   (09.28.09)
Today was Yom Kippur! Whoever spends his time working against Israel instead of praying to HaShem , is a lousy picture of a Jew and of course, there idea of Israel is not shared by 99,9% of Israelis, why give then free space? They are self haters just like Naturei Karta!
18. Ricardo - What a sad commentary
Truthseeker ,   USA   (09.29.09)
Richardo Macher - How sad that you would deny fellow human beings water . What kind of a person are you? I hope that today on Yom Kippur you atoned for your sins, at least one of which is inhumanity to your fellow man. HaShem will bless those Israelis who stand for the best of Judaism and the best of Israel while those who are mean and petty will not find favor, nor should they.
19. 12
Gil ,   Tel Aviv   (09.29.09)
You wrote "loo at the picture" lol..
20. $ BILLIONS $ - FILLS SWIMMING POOLS IN $ ARABIA $
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (12.23.09)
BILLLION OF AID DOLLARS OVER THE YEARS AND THEY ONLY MAKE ROCKETS TO SHOOT AT ISRAEL. IS THAT THE OBJECTIVE OF THE PAL / ARAB PROPOSED STATE ? THE ARAB LEADERS WOULD RATHER LINE THE POCKETS OF THE HAMAS AND FATAH IN THEIR BANK ACCOUNTS IN SWITZERLAND. I KNOW THAT MY COUNTRY CANADA WOULD HAVE BOMBARDED THE HECK OUT OF THE ARAB GAZANS..............FOR EVEN SHOOTING A FEW ROCKETS INTO OTTAWA, OR CALGARY, OR VANCOUVER. IT WOULD NEVER HAVE GOT TO THE 1000'S OF ROCKETS, BELIEVE ME. OUR ARMY AND AIR FORCE WOULD HAVE MADE THE BATTLE AGAINST GAZA COMPLETE !!! NO LEFTISTS WOULD EVEN WANT TO GO TO GAZA AFTER WE CANADIAN'S WERE FINNISHED WITH THESE ARAB GAZANS. ISRAEL IS TOO SOFT ON ROCKET LAUNCHING ARABS.
21. HOW MANY ARAB GAZANS DIED OF THIRST THIS YEAR ??
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (12.23.09)
ARE THERE ANY UNWRA, OR U.N. FIGURES ON THIS ? WHAT IS IT 10,000, OR 100,000 ARAB GAZANS WHO DIED OF THIRST ?? THE POOR PEOPLE IN THE DARFUR, SUDAN SHOULD ONLY HAVE THE SAME WATER AS THESE ARABS COMPLAIN ABOUT. AMNESTY, THE U.N. AND OTHER ASSORTED AID GROUPS ARE PREJUDICED AGINST THE PEOPLE IN DARFUR.................... U.N., AMNESTY, .........THIS IS REAL RACISM.............GIVE DARFUR A BREAK .... HELP THESE PEOPLE !!!!
22. #13.Yochanan... VERY POOR COMPARISON
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (12.23.09)
Yochanan ..... ARE YOU REALLY SERIOUS ? DO YOU SEE ANY DEATH CAMPS HERE ? IT LOOKS LIKE THESE PEOPLE ARE ON A HAY RIDE AND HAVING FUN. IF WE MAKE FUN IN THE YNET TALKBACKS, IT'S A LOT BETTER TO MAKE FUN THAN TO SPEAK ABOUT " DEATH CAMPS". THE ARABS MAKE FUN OF THE JEWS AND IN RETURN SOME JEWS MAKE FUN AT THE ARABS AND THE ISRAELI LEFTISTS,
Back to article