News
Netanyahu: Advance international effort to change laws of war
Roni Sofer
Published: 20.10.09, 19:32
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
31. All Jews should be appalled by Natanyahu's request
Anonymous Lebanese ,   TX, USA   (10.21.09)
I can’t believe what I am hearing??? Netanyahu wants to change the laws of wars… He wants to undermine one of the major pillars of Human Rights….One of the safeguard of Humanity against the madness of Men… Doesn’t he know that these laws were put in place following the atrocities that millions of innocent civilians died and millions more suffered during the second world war, including the millions of Jews who fell victims of the horrors of Holocaust. Generations of Holocaust survivors & their surviving relatives worked relentlessly with other people from around the world to put these laws into place so that they can stand up and shout high for everybody to hear “Never Again such atrocities will be allowed to happen” . Sure he claims that he only wants to tweak the laws to fit the war on terror, soon more and more of the laws will be tweaked or disappear…and soon all what is left of the “Never Again” shout is just a whisper. And since when turning oneself into a terrorist to fight terrorist is acceptable. It is like the Allies should have behaved like SS butchers in fighting Nazi Germany. What is it so special about IDF that it shouldn’t be subjected to scrutiny? The US & the British Armed forces were subject to similar accusations…they faced them, took responsibility and worked to rectify their mistakes…why should Israel do less…Just because a couple of over-zealous IDF officers might have gone overboard and didn’t’ account for civilian casualties when giving orders, or some trigger happy soldiers might have caused the death to some innocent civilians, Netanyahu wants to undermine one of Humanities safeguards… Let them stand trial, and have their chance to defend themselves instead of stooping so low in trying to sneak their way out. Is this man so shortsighted or so morally deprived to stoop so low as to issue such a recommendation? And the funny thing is, not even Ahmadinejad, or Saddam the butcher of Baghdad thought of changing the laws of war…But Benjamin did….I tell you…he can’t stoop any lower. And Jews around the world, as well as Israelis should be the first to denounce this.
32. In a war, kill anyone you need to kill and tell the moaners,
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.21.09)
groaners and complainers to go straight to hell.
33. Golstone Report
Dan ,   Canada   (10.21.09)
Just come out and say, UN is an anti semitic organization. Even the birds on the trees know that.
34. Netanyahu: Advance international effort to change laws of wa
George ,   Canada   (10.21.09)
and make them suitable and favorable for Israel. Funny,is this man real ?what he think about himself ? Abraham Lincoln!!
35. ITS ABOUT TIME
Ken ,   Australia   (10.21.09)
Good luck with your endeavours, please acheive them, we all know who commited war crimes in gaza and the IDF was not one of them. You must succeed in this effort, to not be deliniated in war, its un-acceptable. Hamas will end up with the balame in the end and thats the price they will pay. After this, hamas should pay istrael for the cost of the battle to the last shekel, money and for the dead soldiers fammillies. It is the biggest hoax by the molokites in years and they are still holding the boy under the ground ( Shalit. ). These guys think there so smart that they would just get away with it clean and easy, but the burden will come back in there faces, how dare they think they can play with this strip as a stage for there insanity , it is tottally unaceptable, the blame needs to be immediatly placed on damascus ( Mashall) For giveing the orders, all this idiot had in mind is dead jews and a further kick in the face of israel by orchestrateing a complete stupid mess to stay in power for as long as possible , with the egg on the face of israel and the further power play to delegitamize the state in its benign plan to keep this insane philosophy alive and well across the world, OH Yeah - it was all our falt we keep all the arabs in the area locked up in a prison , what a big load of BS. Now whos going to have egg on there faces , now you can really see the puppetts that these people are and the stupid mentalities that drive them, its very clear now. Groups like this should never be allowed to hold anyone for ransom, where do they get the belief that they can hold Israel for ransom its a sick mind you deal with, it just goes to show that the blockade and the efforts against hamas are totally legitamate and they Hamas are the bearers of the deaths in gaza not the israelis, this is also clear to see.
36. Was Churchill a War Criminal ?
Lawful Combatants   (10.21.09)
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3791096,00.html
37. it's time to level the moral playing field
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.21.09)
terrorists don't follow the rules of war anyway, so their opposition to this is only because it will free israel from being constrained on the battlefield and from criticism afterwords. if the terrorists can target civilians from within civilian populations, then all responsibility should be on them for what happens when they are engaged. there should be no punishment or apology for fighting cowardly terrorists on their terms.
38. imagine
Galut ,   selah   (10.21.09)
World war two fought with the same rules forced upon israel ....england and the allies= israel ... germany italy and japan =hamas ,hezbulah & Fatah the out come would be ?????
39. Anonymous Lebanese @ 31, to answer your question ...
leo ,   usa   (10.21.09)
"What is it so special about IDF that it shouldn’t be subjected to scrutiny?" Exactly the same thing that is special about Hezbollah and Hamas. Now what is it about those two and great many others, which has World have their deeds go unnoticed? Please, do tell.
40. #31 you have issues
Shai ,   USA   (10.21.09)
Look at your emotional rant. The laws he is referring to gives terrorists treatment according to regular human beings, which they are not. People who act outside the boundaries of humanity shouldn't be treated humanely. Noone is talking about becoming a terrorist, and noone is saying the IDF shouldn't be subjected to scrutiny. The problem is the ridiculous, relentless, cruel, and vicious attempts to delegitimize the only army in the world that goes out of its way to drop over hundreds of thousands of pamphlets, make tens of thousands of phone calls, and send tens of thousands of text messages to the civilians in a bombat zone in order to safeguard them. The problem is the equivocation of an army that actually takes these procedures, with a group of genocidal terrorists. IDF should never even see a courtroom because 1) It is THAT obvious it did not commit warcrimes according to anyone not brainwashed by politically biased NGOS, and 2) Kangaroo courts are a waste of time, and that is exactly what it will be. All Jews should denounce this? No. All DECENT PEOPLE around the world, who TRULY oppose terrorism (since you're Lebanese I know that's rare in your community) to FULLY support this. That is the decent thing to do.
41. To Shai - 40
Anonymous Lebanses ,   TX, USA   (10.21.09)
So tell me Shai Who would then decide who is a civilian and who is a terrorist, and who should be treated to use your word as "Less than Human Being"??? Should we leave it to Bibi to decide??? Or an another extremist Israeli politician who doesn't mind exterminating Palestinians and throwing Israeli arabs out of Israel and maybe other people whom he dislikes or disagree with??? Please do remember that 60 years ago, there was a man who also has his own definitions of "Less than Human Being"....and These Laws were put in place so that this definition do not occurr... Following WWII the Nazi Butchers...were all brought to Justice and treated like human beings and were tried based on these laws... International community made it a point to say that they will not steep to the level of savagery & barbarism of Nazis's behavior. And they will treat all people in the same manner under the Human Rights laws & Laws of war even if the Nazis did not deserve it... International Community should be steadfast in being the Moral compass, even if some terrorist elements defy its laws. and doesn't play by the humanitarian rules..but at the end the terrorist will be brought to justice and judged according to the laws that bibi wants to undermine.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article