News
Special team tasked with devising counter-Goldstone policies
Roni Sofer
Published: 25.10.09, 21:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
13 Talkbacks for this article
1. Only IDF officers know fully what happened in Gaza
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (10.25.09)
With out questioning IDF officers the world will never have complete answers in Gaza, with Goldstone being the only real source of information. Is the government trying to protect IDF or the government itself? The Goldstone report will most likely go to ICC after UNGA vote and this will hurt IDF officers more than Government, only a commission of inquiry into the Gaza war will stop it.
2. A MAN in charge. Imagine Olmert or Livni bowing to the world
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.26.09)
and cursing the IDF. Bibi is not perfect but he is 100 times the man Olmert was. B"H for elections.
3. Bibi is looking terrible, tiring himself out
Taroni   (10.26.09)
He has wasted his energy negotiating with Hussein the hitlerite, appeasing the "peace partners", running from one stupid topic to the next. Now he is tired and will be unable to make good decisions in the soon-coming war. Decision one: fire Barak, he's an old woman and will again deliberately lose a war, same with drooling insane man Peres. Wake up Israel...
4. #1
J K ,   NYC, USA   (10.26.09)
Maybe the question should be why the IDF had to go into Gaza at all. 8 years of cross-border attacks, a soldier kidnapping and a relentless rocket campaign by Hamas only warranted 9 pages out of 575 in the Goldstone report. I'd like to see that question answered first.
5. Goldstone report
Marilyn ,   USA   (10.26.09)
Basically once a war starts, it is inevitably going to get out of control and it's going to become unethical. There is no way around this basic premise. This is why the focus is on war avoidance. If investigations are wanted, it would be more fruitful to see how much effort was made by both parties to avoid this situation and to recreate circumstances and see other ways around, etc.
6. Reports reports reports how nice RIGHT ???
M. S. ,   mpls america   (10.26.09)
I realize no body blames Hamas for starting begining the 2009 Gaza war by allowing so many missiles fired at Israel but now Israel committed war crimes beyond comprehension by defending itself such is the mentality of those who may point the finger at others never themselfs RIGHT ??? Thank You... M. S.
7. Enormous precautions were taken to protect civilians in Gaza
Rivkah   (10.26.09)
But when Hamas combatants hide out in mosques and schools and hospitals and shoot IDF from them, isn't it reasonable to go after the terrorists who has terrorized Isaelis for many years, wherever they are, to protect Israel from such attackers? If there is no fear of consequences, the enemies of Israel will attack with impunity. The UN is so biased against America and Israel that we should pull out and kick them out of New York City where UN diplomats rape and kill and commit all sorts of crimes against Americans without being prosecuted because of diplomatic immunity. When I went to Officer Indoctrination classes for Medical Service Corps Officers in Bethesda, Maryland in 1975, the first lecture was about the rape of a 12 year old US Navy dependent daughter by a person with diplomatic immunity, so no charges could be filed even though the child's life was destroyed. NOW, there are MILLIONS of foreigners in America with diplomatic immunity commiting crimes without being prosecuted. A US Senator told retired US Army Chief of Chaplains Jim Ammerman that there were five million foreign national troops in North America, three million of them in the United States, who have diplomatic immunity from prosecution. At the tiny US Navy Naval Air Station in Lemoore, California, there are so many crimes such as rape of children and wives and women in the military and female civilian employees that I was told by one of the rape crisis counselors who worked there that there are three full time rape crisis counselors at NAS Lemoore! WHY OH WHY ISN'T THE UN INVESTIGATING THE CRIMES OF THOSE WHO REPRESENT IT IN AMERICA????? WHY OH WHY ISN'T NATO INVESTIGATING THE CRIMES OF FOREIGN TROOPS IN AMERICA? The German Luftwaffe flies cover over American cities because it is more certain they will shoot down airliners that are hijacked than US military pilots would. So the US military pilots are sent to 120 other countries while vile foreigners rape their wives and children back home. GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!
8. Bibi and Barak
Basil ,   Beit Shean   (10.26.09)
Two men with their heads in the sand.
9. All wars that Israel has waged have been just, forced ...
Ron B. ,   Lod   (10.26.09)
All wars that Israel has waged have been just, forced upon it by the Arab leaders. War involves life-and-death situations; mistakes are made and innocents inevitably die. But in maintaining our moral standards, we should never forget that the IDF is an army of the people and we are also obliged to ensure that we do not go to the other extreme and endanger the lives of our soldiers by preventing them from defending themselves. As to the blood libels against Israel and the IDF : http://xrl.us/be8dzf
10. This calls for immediate discussion! (end)
Brian Cohen ,   Judean People's Frnt   (10.26.09)
11. The Best Counter-Measures Are To...
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (10.26.09)
1. Ignore this stupid report, and 2. Quit the UN. Israel's need to "be accepted" by the world community can be suicidal if what it takes to "be accepted" runs contrary to our need to survive. Let's face it. There are many nations out there who want us to disappear from the face of the Earth. Nothing would make them happier then if Israel and the Jews would evaporate into thin air. For them (and the UN) to "be accepted" will be for us to be all Baptised, shipped to the Moon or die. Fools like Mr. S. Peres and his ilk, have no idea what it really means to be a "Jewish" (he thinks it means to speak Hebrew) and are willing for us to disappear from history - as long as we were "accepted". They do this all under the guise of "peace".
12. ok how much?
ghostq   (10.26.09)
money that is so many "teams" and so much money go to waste for what? for an idiot judge who scream disbar me, judge usually don't give media interview when the case is open, mmm stop making teams that lead to nowhere. you think that in the future another self hate jew wont make another report and than what, you need something else, not team just fixing the huge gov you got, to many ministers that probably do nothhhhhhing.
13. It will never defuse the issue.
org   (10.26.09)
If Israel wants to solve this issue once and for all, just do the damn investigation already. If it thinks by dodging the issue will help, that means the leaders of Israel are either incredibly stupid or terribly naive or maybe both
Back to article