News
Brazil protest againt Peres: Shimon Hitler
Amnon Meranda
Published: 12.11.09, 22:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
75 Talkbacks for this article
31. Child killers are not wanted in any country
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (11.13.09)
Coward "soldiers" who can only fight 50 km far from targets, High technology serves only high cowardish of Israel, They cannot face their faters, only kill their mothers and children. you will eventually get punishment deserved.
32. dozens muslims and leftists protest..really not a big deal
(11.13.09)
33. excellent
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (11.13.09)
Shimon Peres was always the most Left wing mainstream leader of Israel, dragging Rabin into the failed Oslo accords to rescue Arafat from the dustbin of history. Peres was the one who always supported Fatah/PLO and compared Likud to Hamas. It is strange justice that the day Ilan Pappe is silenced for being an Israeli, Peres is condemned in such an offensive way by the people he supported.
34. #17 don't forget
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (11.13.09)
Don't forget Arab hero Samir Kuntar who purposefully smashed the head of 4 year old Einat Haran. Don't forget the Arab hero who used his sniper rifle to shoot Shalhevet Pass (9 months) in the arms of her father. Don't forget the two brave Arabs who murdered the Hatuel family: Merav (2), Roni (7), Hadar (9), Hila (11) and Tali their mother. After these heroes gunned their car, they heroically came to shoot the little girls individually from close range and shot Tali in her belly to murder her unborn child.
35. What's in common between Brazil and..
Melville ,   Clichy, France   (11.13.09)
...the rest of the world ? a clue is one of the language used by the demonstrators. PC prevents us from calling a cat a cat, but these demonstrators write in arabic...
36. # 9
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.13.09)
Noor your disrespect to your fellow talkback writers is very low.No one here has "dirty fingers" & I suggest you apologize to Sarah as fast as you can. And try hard to keep your words CLEAN here.
37. Carsten, thank you.
renee   (11.13.09)
38. DEAR LAWRENCE RAP ARTIST
Keren ,   IL-BR   (11.13.09)
Excuse me if I am hassling you-that's not my intention. But let me ask you something:are you kidding me that you wanted to go to Brasil? Go for visits,it's your best deal,unless you want those brasilian tribes smiling politely at you and wondering what the hell you are talking about.
39. Brasil
Walt K ,   Sherbrooke, Canada   (11.13.09)
Should take cares about pirates who kill indians and steal their natural ressources... and what about gold diggers who put mercury in water... they poison the water that first nations used to drink. And what about gang members who steal, kill and rape all the time... and what about the beautiful Carnival of Rio where hundreds of individuals are killed every year... and what about Brasil who is an industrial power, but keeps hisr children stay and die on the streets... At last, wars in Middle east kill less than a peacetime in Brasil.
40. Sarah B and Hague Conventions
Truthseeker ,   USA   (11.13.09)
This is a reply to an earlier comment made by you. Sarah, I have searched and searched and cannot find anything in the Hague conventions that speaks to your claims that Israel has the right to keep the land especially after it began the war. I checked out the Wikipedia site to which you referred. There was not a single word about the Hague conventions. As far as Germany goes, Germany was the aggressor in World War 2. In 1967 it was Israel that was the aggressor. Jordan came into the war only because it had a treaty with Egypt that called upon Jordan to come to the assistance of Egypt should that country be attacked. If what you say is true please give me the exact words from the Hague conventions that you are relying upon as well as the URL where you found them. That is, if indeed, those words exist.
41. # 27Sarah B and terrorism
Truthseeker ,   USA   (11.13.09)
Sarah, of course terrorism is wrong but those who commit and have committed terrorism are not just on one side. Are you not aware that Israel itself was born with terrorism. Have you not heard of the slaughter of over 100 men, women & children by the terror groups Irgun & LEHI at Deir Yassin on April 8, 1948? Have you not heard of the bombings perpetrated by Jews in Arab markets? Don't you know that Jewish terror groups blew up the King David Hotel, the Arab owned Semiramis Hotel and Rex theatre. And what would you call the shelling of the Arab district of Haifa when Arabs were forced into the sea. I would call every one of those acts terrorism. Of course Palestinian hands are not clean but neither are the hands of Israelis. Too bad more Jewish parents, like mine, did not tell their children that terrorism and taking someone else's land is wrong. Why is that? Complete lack of moral compass?
42. Really Sarah?
Bob ,   NYC, USA   (11.13.09)
You mean like the Jewish individuals arrested in Italy for murdering kids for the purpose of making snuff films? You should think of converting since then you would learn the meaning of the phrase, "He who is without sin cast the first stone".
43. To: No. 29
Sarah B ,   New York / Saviyon   (11.13.09)
Brazilians are also the subject of this article, moron.
44. HEY NOOR, WAY TO DEFLECT THE ISSUE!
MICHAEL ,   CONNECTICUT   (11.13.09)
Noor, What is the real issue? The long tried suggestion that Israel's Right of self defense against attack of its own children being murdered by your kind, somehow has a moral equivalancy when children intentionally put in harms way get killed? Put on as many protests as you like aginst Perez or any other Jewish leader...Most of the world understands the real story behind the rhetoric.
45. anytime in society that Hate and bitterness is taught....
Galut ,   Selah   (11.13.09)
...as a virtue ...it not only affects those they hate but spills over to those in thier own social network when there is a disagreement on approach to those who they hate... Hamas & Fatah & hezbulah are prime examples .... without israel in the picture these organizations would be a continual bloodbath the loosers -the palistinian people...
46. Cause
KD ,   Buffalo, USA   (11.13.09)
Addle, the problem is that people seem to forget the reason that Israel went into Gaza in the first place. Why are Palestinians shooting rockets into Israel in the first place-and why for 8 years. No one-like what just happened to with the seized weapons ship-seems to care as long as its being shot (or is going to be shot at) at Israelis. But when Israelis respond, people pretend as treat the response as it came out of nowhere
47. Good welcome to Perez ,Israeli Generals stay home
Sami ,   Lebanon   (11.13.09)
Israel is loosing ground. Its reputation is sinking at the sky -racketing speed. This what happen when the extremist politicians come to power. Majority of Israeli (about 74%) support and voted for the far right extremist leaders.. If there were no American political cover up, most of the Israeli war generals and leaders were sharing the prison cell with Karaditch no doubt.
48. Brazil
CAS ,   Los Angeles USA   (11.13.09)
South American is not that far from the Arab world. Keeping their population poverty stricken and ignorant and breeding hatred of Jews. The Allies killed at least 24,000 German civilians in the Battle of Dresden. I would say the actions of Israel in the Gaza conflict are more analagous to that. Not ideal, but necessary to win a war against the truly evil.
49. not true
andres L ,   tel aviv - Israel   (11.13.09)
Im brazilian jew, did aliah in 2006, from Sao Paulo. I totaly desagree with the main title that this news gain. " brazil protest: perez hitler. First of all its not brazil that its protesting its maybe 100 people that have nothing to do, but call israel a nazi country because its easy to blame the stronger. Just to reminde Ynet that brazil has more than 4 million arabs and 1 million live in Sao paulo. So 100 people its a joke. Do not call brazil protest because perez was recieved in brazil as a king that little can enjoy such behaviour. He was congratulated in the national senate, congress etc. So, 100 brasilians arabs do not have to change the israeli view and the ynet readres image's over brazil, a true friend of Israel and a very strong jewish comunity center.
50. The enemies of freedom.
Ron B. ,   Lod   (11.13.09)
Arabs compare often Israel to the Nazis. In that way they try to hide their own Nazis methods at home and the seamy side of life in their countries. It is not new : the U.S.A. and Israel are the targets of the venomous hate of the Arabs and Islam. Let’s not mistake, let’s not forget who are the enemies of freedom and of our civilization, who are the heirs of Hitler. If you think “Islamist Fascism” is an empty slogan, observe the reality just open : http://xrl.us/bjrdf
51. #33 is right!
JAy3 ,   Israel   (11.13.09)
BUt i would think the word "Kappo" is more apt to describe what Peres is! It amazes me how this egomaniac named Peres, can get away with treason to the state!
52. Would these protestors give Ahmadinejad the same welcome?
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (11.13.09)
When he visits Brazil soon? If the answer to that is no, this only proves the huge, astounding hypocrisy of these two-faced Islamofascist activists. If the dovish Peres, one of the engineers of the disastrous Oslo accords, with his pipe dreams of the "new Middle East", who is responsible for Israel's many unconditional capitulations to the Palestinians, especially when suicide bombers around us exploded all the time, gets such a horrid welcome - then what sort of a welcome does Ahmadinejad deserve, with his wonderful track record of human rights? Would these activists prove their integrity by making such protest to him? Should I bet even a nickel on that? I think we all know the answer.
53. #13 Peter, Vienna
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (11.13.09)
"When one hears the name Israel..." - And when one hears the name Austria, I really don't think I need to spell out the first thing that comes to mind. "Does this country have any reputation left??" - How about being a hi-tech superpower, having the some of the best doctors, being an international patent center, being a world leader on Defense Technologies, having the most foreign companies in the Nasdaq, and receiving 5 Nobel Prizes in the last decade alone? How about developing the processor in your computer, or many of the medicines that you use? How about extending a helping hand to any country in the world that suffers natural (Turkey, Greece) or man-made (Kenya) disasters? How about treating of people from enemy Arab countries, in our hospitals? How about us accepting thousands of refugees fleeing Darfur, who have nothing but praise for our country? And what has YOUR country done to fix its reputation since WWII? Not much, really. "Antisemitism exists because of your own deed's." Oh really? What "deeds" have my ancestors done in Europe, that sent them to the gas chambers? What "deeds" have the Jews in Arab countries do, to be forcibly expelled? I could go on and on lambasting the stupidity of this comment, but something so stupid hardly deserves my efforts. "You better wake up and smell the coffee, or else the way things are going, in a few years to come, the jewish future wont look bright." - I would have to say the exact same thing back at you in Europe, with regards to your growing Arab population. In a few years to come, the way things are going, the European future looks very, very bleak.
54. #6 People who count gave Peres roses
Cynthia ,   USA   (11.13.09)
Not the couple dozen savages in the street. Eat your heart out Marco. Peres had a successful trip and returned with a million dollar aerospace contract. You're a cheerleader for the real war criminals.
55. #54 Cynthia
Marco ,   Spain   (11.13.09)
" a million dollar aerospace contract " ??? Wow, must be something out of this world!!! Cynthia, at todays rates,a million dollar cant even buy two donkeys!
56. This protest is from brazilian arabs,their 2nd rally on
Nelson ,   Brazil   (11.13.09)
the bombing of a kind of shellter in south Lebanon where hundreds of children dyed!! It's been when Peres was running to a mandate against the right and showed Israeli muscles in response to some Hizbolah atack, and lost elections for that. That very same mistaken targeting also hapenned in 2nd Lebanon war don't remember the name of the place. In the first protest I hopped they wouldn't charge us jews generically, and they surprised me not even focusing directly on Iarael, but instead cryed "Peres, murder". This is clearly the second edition of that rally. Comparing any evil to Nazism is just apropiatted. Their are on their right. 95% brazilian arab descendents are Cristhian, highly integrated to Brazilian main course western culture, recently one "arab" big shot in Foreign Ministry made clear that in midle east terrorist activities Brazil was sided with the democracy, Israel, the "arab" president of the Brazil-Lebanon Comerce Chamber quotted terrorism, and not Israel, as the main problem of midle east and no one respects more jews in this country then "our lebaneses"
57. The arabs always accuse us of the types
jason white ,   afula,israel   (11.13.09)
of crimes they commit. They steal parts of our religion and holy places. Too bad we did not commit all the crimes we are falsely accused of. Maybe then the palis would leave us alone in fear of more deaths. They continue with their terrorism, because they know that the government of Israel is led by cowards. These cowards worry more about world opinion than the lives of its citizens. If the intl court wants to try us, then we should level the court with a couple of JDAMs, Let those anti Semites fear us for once.
58. brazil
colin   (11.13.09)
Peres likened to hitler. Very very bad but maybe Peres will realise nobody wants to hear his bullshit--not in bRazil and definitely not in Israel He was not voted to be president but got the place through the back door by the crooked Olmert.
59. #55 I feel your pain, Marco
Cynthia ,   USA   (11.13.09)
Israelis are creating technology for the future while you guys are herding donkeys.
60. There is no evidence that...
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (11.13.09)
Adolf Hitler's Hebrew name was Shimon. That would have meant that at birth he would have been named a very rhythmical Schimonn Schicklgruber. Maybe I should have read the article...
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article